Last September '15, I had 4 tenants (young professionals, all friends, great tenants thus far) sign the lease on my 4-bed rental unit. This year, 1 of them is going away, so 3 will remain (incomes are in check). Given that they ALL 4 have paid for 'last months' and 'deposit' in '15, how do you recommend I should deal with last month's and deposit when signing the new lease which I plan within a week or so? I'm also increasing monthly rent by $50.
If you are changing the deposit amount etc having a paper trail for returning is good. However, you can just ask them to give the incremental amount for the increase and get a release from the leaving tenant that the last months and security deposit transfer to the new lease. This would mean they settle up among themselves on the deposit/last month. They collectively give you any incremental increases. One thing I do now is show the security deposit on file on the front page of the lease, then there is no question if I don't increase the deposit what they have as a deposit.