Emotional Support Animal (ESA) Low Allergen Building - *FAS

Emotional Support Animal (ESA) Low Allergen Building - *FAS

Member since 2018 · 3 posts · 2 votes

*FAS = FUNDAMENTALLY ALTER the nature of SERVICES provided

Why has no one been able to turn down ESA requests based on the wording of the actual FHA law?

From the FHAA Federal Housing Authority:

[Landlords are required to accept ESA requests] unless doing so would impose an undue financial and administrative burden or would fundamentally alter the nature of the housing provider's services.

-------------

Granted this does not apply to the majority of situations, but for a small percentage it should!

Ok, so lets say a landlord had a building that was specifically marketed towards tenants who have allergies. When they bought the building, during renovations they tore out carpeting, hepa vacuumed as much trace of any previous pets in buildings, removed and replaced subfloor where needed, ran hepa filters, painted walls, etc etc. Maybe even hired allergy consultants to measure allergens. The end result is lower rates of pet dander and allergens in the buildings.

Surely they could market this as a "reduced allergen" apartment (or in case of new construction actually claim "no pets have ever lived here") and there would be a solid niche market of folks who suffer from allergies who would love to live in a unit like that!

Now since the landlord had undertaken renovations to create a low allergen place to live, marketed their building as such - being forced into accepting an ESA would "fundamentally alter the nature of the services provided" and thus allow them to legally decline the request!

Why has no one tried this, surely there must be a few buildings in this situation!!

You would need proof (pics) of renovations, of marketing to "reduced allergen living", and possibly letters from any tenants & their doctors stating that said tenants indeed impacted by allergies and that is one of the big reasons they chose to live their.

This is getting ridiculous that everyone is being held hostage by these standards that don't take into account how it affects everyone involved. Legally speaking, is this a solid defense? Why or why not?

1Reply
47 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Post Falls, ID · Member since 2016 · 606 posts · 699 votes
8y

I will post the same reply that I posted on Mr. Landlord.

The Idaho Apartment Association gives quarterly trainings on Fair Housing.  A question with a similar situation was asked in a recent training.  Namely, what would happen if one resident had a severe allergy to animal dander and a second resident requested an ESA for their disability.

The solution is that the first resident needs to request a Fair Housing accommodation for their allergies to live in animal-free housing.  The first resident would need to provide documentation from their physician stating the medical need for this accommodation.  This would protect the LL if a subsequent resident requested an ESA.  The first resident's request for an allergen free living situation would make it legal for the LL to deny the ESA.  It all comes down to who has their accommodation documentation in first.

As I recall, the trainer said this would only work for apartments in close proximity to one another.  You would not be able to deny ESAs throughout a large apartment complex, because it would be very unlikely that the animal dander would travel long distances.

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    8y

    Is it a solid legal defense? Possibly, ask your attorney and be prepared to spend a lot of cash to defend this position in court should it come to it.

    I suspect that this is not frequently done because you have a limited market of people who want a reduced allergen building. Low demand means that you cannot easily charge significantly higher rent for these units. However, the costs associated with continual removal of allergens is going to be quite high. Probably higher than the extra rent you could charge. You would also have a higher duty of care with this type of building and therefore, higher liability.

  • Investor · Post Falls, ID · Member since 2016 · 606 posts · 699 votes
    8y

    I will post the same reply that I posted on Mr. Landlord.

    The Idaho Apartment Association gives quarterly trainings on Fair Housing.  A question with a similar situation was asked in a recent training.  Namely, what would happen if one resident had a severe allergy to animal dander and a second resident requested an ESA for their disability.

    The solution is that the first resident needs to request a Fair Housing accommodation for their allergies to live in animal-free housing.  The first resident would need to provide documentation from their physician stating the medical need for this accommodation.  This would protect the LL if a subsequent resident requested an ESA.  The first resident's request for an allergen free living situation would make it legal for the LL to deny the ESA.  It all comes down to who has their accommodation documentation in first.

    As I recall, the trainer said this would only work for apartments in close proximity to one another.  You would not be able to deny ESAs throughout a large apartment complex, because it would be very unlikely that the animal dander would travel long distances.

  • Member since 2018 · 3 posts · 2 votes
    8y

    Thank you Greg and Bettina. I will look into the allergy accommodation from FHA. Makes complete sense to me and the was exactly the type of thing we've been looking at.

  • Investor · Thousand Oaks, CA · Member since 2017 · 306 posts · 123 votes
    7y

    Agree will Declare our Buildings a low Allergen Buildings in all future leases after remediation of units, Currently i have a fourplex with a No Pets, No Smoking Standard in all leases. While inststalling new Smoke Alarms in the building i had a severe allergic reaction inside this tenats apartment they admitted to having a Cat. After we sent out remider letters to all about the no Pet, no smoking clauses in their leases. The Same Tenant involved called back angerly and said she would not get rid of her Cat and that i could not make her, then she hung up. She later called back and now claims its an Emotional supprt cat and she vouletered that she has depression and was prescribed Xanex. (I never Asked about her medical reasons) I asked if she can give us a Emotional Support Animal letter from her Doctor and shes out shopping for one now. (i see websites selling them for $22 so am sure she will buy one. Given, That Im allergeric to Cats. or that the Center for Diease Control claims 40 million Americas are now infected with the parasite Toxoplosmosis Goni from Cat Feces. I think I might challege this. I did also just Raise the annual rent  by $50 per month a separate and standard increse.  BTW the Center for Diease control claims people with the Cat parasite Toxoplsmosis develop mental disorders, Anger easily and are involved in Risky even suicidal behavors. Cats are a serious Health risk Wash your hands when around them. 

  • Investor · Thousand Oaks, CA · Member since 2017 · 306 posts · 123 votes
    7y

    also, I'm told after Tenants move out with Cats to do all the Remediation work, Remove all Carpets put down new flooring, repair and clean all surfaces including air ducts for heating and air. to call an Indoor Air quality inspector and get units certified as Allergen free. We have an IAC2 dot org locally. but getting my own Blacklight for new properties so I can see urine problems before buying. and low-cost indoor air quality meters off of Amazon.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.