Rental Property Investor · Brunswick, OH · Member since 2018 · 200 posts · 127 votes
If you've ever used State Auto Insurance Companies for your homeowners coverage, I'd love to know what your experience was like. I've gotten surprisingly low quotes from a local agent who reps them. They have an A+ BBB rating, and they're based in Ohio, which is where I am. Online reviews are poor--but they are poor for just about any insurance company because people tend to leave reviews for their insurance company only when they're dissatisfied. Any feedback would be appreciated!
I also recently got a low quote of "State Auto Insurance" from an insurance agent. Did you end up going with this insurance company? Do you mind sharing the experience? Thank you.
@Ellie Yang yes I did go with State Auto. The purchase process was smooth and I am happy with the agent, coverage and price. Can't tell you much more than that at this time, but let me know if I can answer anything else.
@David Bardwell I just did a search on this forum for State Auto and came upon this thread. After several years with American Modern for several properties in Indy, I decided to shop around. Like you found, State Auto rates are significantly lower than I am currently paying. Do you have any follow-up with your experience to share? Ever make a claim?