Rental Property Investor · NY · Member since 2016 · 130 posts · 16 votes
Hi all,
I have a first floor resident who has his TV automatically turn on at 4am to wake him up. It's set to a loud volume because he claims he has sleep apnea (sleeping disorder) and can show a doctor's letter to prove it. TV playing loudly at 4am bothers the 2nd floor resident right above him. In the case where a resident says he has a medical condition, is there anyway this can be resolved so the resident on the 2nd floor isn't disturbed at 4am?
My first instinct would be to not get involved with tenant drama. I would suggest that the second floor tenant approach the first floor tenant and diplomatically address their concern. If they are not breaking a law, I'm not sure anything can be done. Apartment neighbors are sometimes noisy, and everyone needs to work it out as they are adults. You are their landlord; not their counselor. If you get involved, it will be a time sink and you will get called every time someone gets their nose out of joint. You will feel like the parent in a long car trip with your two children in the back seat.
If this TV dude is the nexus for other discontent in the building and is a PITA with you and others, I might send them a "notice to cure" after the neighbor's appeal fell on deaf ears (pardon the pun).
I think the "medical condition" thing is a red herring, because I don't think that gives someone the right to violate the peaceable enjoyment of others in their residences. (My guess, anyways.)
Lastly, they sell several kinds of silent alarms that your tenant could buy online instead of using the blaring TV, so there are other accommodations he can make to address his "medical condition."
I wouldn’t shake a bees nest until you hear complaints from the other tenants . Once they start getting annoyed then I’d tell him to go buy an alarm clock or something and quiet enjoyment of peace must be shared by all in the building not just him
Normally, I would agree with @Wesley W. about not getting involved in tenant drama, but this, as he also indicated, is one of this instances where tech can change the game. I know something about this from personal experience.
There are alarm clocks with vibrating devices. You put the vibrating puck under your pillow and it shakes you awake. Some of these work with cell phones. Check Amazon.com for "bed shaker."
You can also help this guy rig up an LCD-bulb clip-on desk lamp or two to a simple electrical outlet timer to turn on at a certain time and shine a light or two in his face to help him get up. Check Amazon for "outlet timer."
If, in the end, the guy simple CAN'T DO without lots of noise to wake him up, you can screw in and finish an additional layer of drywall to his ceiling.
I have sleep apnea and a simple cell phone alarm wakes me up. Cpap machines are not loud at all (just a soft white noise sound). This excuse doesn’t make sense to me.
Thanks all. I think this comes down to an issue of "peaceful enjoyment." Resident on the 1st floor is disrupting the peaceful enjoyment of resident above him. Therefore, resident on first floor needs to make an effort to wake up by an alternative means (e.g. buy a vibrating device).