Is wholesaling legal in Illinois? (Chicago Suburbs)

Most Popular Reply

Realtor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 103 posts · 44 votes
11y

@Steve G. That's wonderful! I'm so happy to hear you're doing some deals and truly appreciate the compliment on the podcasts. It's been a while and it is definately on my to do list to get back to. I have a couple of coaching students who work in Florida so I will put you in touch with them in a private email. One of them is doing a BIG amount of business and now transitioned from wholesaling to rehabs and is doing 2 or 3 deals right now (I forgot how many) but he's an awesome guy to know and work with.

@Jerry Stanford True to the word my friend. My attorney once told me years ago, "itent is a tough thing to prove". One thing I know being a broker and having a license all these years is that in a very loose translation, brokerage is defined as charging a fee for services provided. So if I as a broker list a property for sale for a percentage of the sale price or a fee whether that is upfront or at closing or anywhere in between, I am brokering a deal. I get paid to bring a buyer and seller together (usually from the seller but it can be from either or both sides) and I usually have no skin in the game. If on the other hand I am the buyer on the contract, have put down earnest money (even if it's only $10.00) and then find a partner, investor relative or other buyer who wants it, if my contract is written properly and it is disclosed (in the contract) that I can assign it and may not be the one who closes.... then I would feel confident in my approach to wholesaling the deal via my equitable interest in the property. Mind you most of these rules apply to residential deals as commercial is a whole other animal and much looser since the powers that be generally feel that a buyer and seller of commercial real estate are somewhat savvy investors.

@Dale Stevens I'm with you... there is so much left up to interpretation that one can get lost in the shuffle. When I work with people on the "Real Estate Investing" process, I start by letting them all know one thing, "We may be starting as a wholesaler but wholesaling is not a sustainable business model". If you do not learn the old gas station adage: "When is the last time you went to a gas station that only sold gas"? (In other words multiple streams of income) then you will eventually stall and either evolve out of necessity or become extinct. Wholesaling is a good start, low barrier of entry, low cost (and profit) but a place to cut your teeth. From there one has to learn, grow and do better until they find the niche that works best for them. I am primarily a rehabber/builder now days. In the next 10-15 years... I may let others do the chasing and be 100% hard money or JV partner, who knows? The problem with wholesaling in a nutshell is you'll notice most of the people in the space don't hold any inventory. You blast to your list, 10 wholesalers pick it up, add $10K to your deal and send it to their list, that happens 1 or 2 more times down the line and all of a sudden there is no deal anymore and it turned into a daisy chain of crap where no one knows how to get the deal and get paid if they could find the originator. It's a mess with all the BS programs that are out there "selling the secret to wholesaling in under 11 hours" or whatever else they can conjure up. It's like the diet pill commercials for real estate investor wannabes. You know what I'm talking about, "take this pill, eat like ****, don't exercise, sleep 12 hours a day and you'll still lose weight". People who buy that stuff are the same people who are too lazy to call and ask for a refund and these companies know it.

My advice to wholesalers.... forget all the BS and nonsense about "co-wholesaling", flipping houses from Beirut with a laptop and a hookah or making a 6 figure income working in your underwear and never having to leave your house. This is a business so be prepared to work, this is a business and who makes the most money in any business model? People or companies who control all or the majority of the process. In other words, when you spend some money on marketing to generate a lead and IT'S YOURS then you have exclusivity. NOW you have something worth some money to sell. Don't think that recycling other peoples inventory will make you rich, it won't end well for you. Have your own list or start building it, get aggressive and use your "WIT" (Whatever It Takes) to get a deal sold.

Anyway... I rambled, thanks for all your input gents, I would love to talk further on this or any other subject you like, anytime. Have a great evening.

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Willow Spring, NC · Member since 2009 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    11y
  • Real Estate Coach · New Zealand / USA · Member since 2014 · 296 posts · 82 votes
    11y

    Try searching for @Michael Kevorkian - I believe he's active in Chicago.

    Good luck!!

  • Realtor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 103 posts · 44 votes
    11y

    @Steve G. Long time no talk.... how have you been? I hope things are going great for you! @Edward Mitchell let me start with the old CYA and say "I am not an attorney... I am not giving legal advice... I advise you to seek legal advice... wear your seat belt and eat your vegetables". Now that we got that out of the way.... I am under no impression that wholesaling is illegal in Illinois or any state for that matter assuming you are doing things right. Recently I came across this article on the Illinois Association of Realtors website about wholesaling and even listing that wholesale deal with a broker in the MLS. Read it as I think it will or should answer many questions you may have.

    "3. I am a broker representing a buyer/developer. He is now under a contract to purchase the land for subdivision and he wants to "pre-market" the lots before closing on the land transaction. May he list them on MLS, or otherwise advertise them for sale?

    The important fact to remember here is that title does not transfer till the purchase of the land is complete. In other words, the developer/buyer cannot transfer good title to the land, or any part thereof, to any subsequent buyer until the developer/buyer becomes the owner of the property. Title does not transfer until the land transaction closes. As any real estate practitioner knows, a lot can happen between the time a contract is formed and the closing of the transaction. (This is true especially in subdivision development where the developer must undoubtedly meet requirements of the Illinois Plat Act and any other applicable local regulations before the land can be successfully subdivided, which specific requirements will not be addressed for purposes of this question).

    On the other hand, the developer could advertise what he does have for sale. At this point, on the facts above, he owns only rights in the contract to purchase the land. He could transfer those rights to a third party (assuming provisions in the land purchase contract would allow this). He, along with your help as his real estate representative, could probably even market this in some manner. However, you must keep in mind your duties under the License Act to avoid any advertising that would be in any way false, deceptive or misleading. Thus, you would want to be certain when doing any advertising that the ads contain clear language that sufficiently explains the situation. You might even do an ad campaign soliciting interest should the land transaction be consummated. This becomes the developer's business decision based on your advice and input from his other advisors.

    Developers sometimes handle "pre-marketing" by taking deposits and contracts that are specifically conditioned upon the consummation of the first land sale from potential lot buyers. In addition, developers have actually sold options to potential lot buyers contingent upon consummation of the land sale.

    Regarding your question about listing on the MLS, there are a couple concerns. First, under the License Act (and probably MLS rules), you must have the written consent of the owner to advertise the property for sale. Keep in mind, on these facts, you do not yet represent the owner. You represent the contract buyer. Second, if the land was listed with another brokerage company, that firm may have the exclusive right to market the property for sale pursuant to an exclusive right to sell agreement. As a result, without some agreement with the current listing broker, you could not expose the land (or subdivided lots) to the MLS until title transfers and your developer client owns the land.

    The situation might also be that the developer went directly to the landowner that was not represented by another broker to effect the purchase of the land. In that case, you probably need to get permission of the landowner to list the land as available for sale. The terms of the purchase contract between the developer and the landowner may actually contain the necessary permission to list, so you should check that contract for such a provision."

  • Investor · Downers Grove, IL · Member since 2015 · 353 posts · 213 votes
    11y

    @Michael 

    @Michael Kevorkian nice post. The example of the developer, while a good one, also has a hiccup to it. As with most times when you go to court, you deal with "INTENT". What was the INTENT of the person. In your example, it seems clear a developer had the intent to buy the property.

    In the case of "Wholesaling" there is no intent to actually be a primary or a buyer. That is where the tap dance comes. Because they have no intent to purchase, are they essentially just acting as an agent. Usually the dollar amounts are so low that no one bothers legal recourse. All it takes is one crazy judge and boom... 

    For me, with wholesaling, I endeavored to do it. I bought into the guru HYPE. I put up the signs, did the marketing, attempted to build a buyers list. But I just found that if I was going to spend all that time finding a cash buyer to wholesale to, I could just go out and find a cash partner, and I made more money doing deals I actually wanted, not ones I was just attempting to peddle off to others.

  • Chicago, IL · Member since 2015 · 469 posts · 81 votes
    11y

    @Dale Stevens makes a very good point...it is truly a tap dance.  While there is no cut and dry law that says "Wholesaling is Illegal in IL", there is a very thin and transparent line. Much is subject to interpretation and as Dale noted if you get a judge that's pretty cut and dry then all hell may break loose.  In my mind it's your intent vs your right. You have to right to contract to purchase a property and the right to assign the right to purchase to someone else. Whether or not your intent to sell to an end buyer all along makes you a broker/agent for the buyer or not is very murky water and caution should be taken. If you are not a broker, my suggestion is to find a good RE investor friendly attorney that can look over what you are doing and let you know if there are some possible potholes or red flags. 

  • Real Estate Coach · New Zealand / USA · Member since 2014 · 296 posts · 82 votes
    11y

    @Michael Kevorkian - very well thanks for asking! Thanks mainly to the very motivational Podcasts you broadcasted a while back, I'm now wholesaling JV's in Florida!

    Back to the topic - I'm presuming an option to buy contract (as opposed to a P&S Agreement) would bring about even more issues in IL?

  • Realtor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 103 posts · 44 votes
    11y

    @Steve G. That's wonderful! I'm so happy to hear you're doing some deals and truly appreciate the compliment on the podcasts. It's been a while and it is definately on my to do list to get back to. I have a couple of coaching students who work in Florida so I will put you in touch with them in a private email. One of them is doing a BIG amount of business and now transitioned from wholesaling to rehabs and is doing 2 or 3 deals right now (I forgot how many) but he's an awesome guy to know and work with.

    @Jerry Stanford True to the word my friend. My attorney once told me years ago, "itent is a tough thing to prove". One thing I know being a broker and having a license all these years is that in a very loose translation, brokerage is defined as charging a fee for services provided. So if I as a broker list a property for sale for a percentage of the sale price or a fee whether that is upfront or at closing or anywhere in between, I am brokering a deal. I get paid to bring a buyer and seller together (usually from the seller but it can be from either or both sides) and I usually have no skin in the game. If on the other hand I am the buyer on the contract, have put down earnest money (even if it's only $10.00) and then find a partner, investor relative or other buyer who wants it, if my contract is written properly and it is disclosed (in the contract) that I can assign it and may not be the one who closes.... then I would feel confident in my approach to wholesaling the deal via my equitable interest in the property. Mind you most of these rules apply to residential deals as commercial is a whole other animal and much looser since the powers that be generally feel that a buyer and seller of commercial real estate are somewhat savvy investors.

    @Dale Stevens I'm with you... there is so much left up to interpretation that one can get lost in the shuffle. When I work with people on the "Real Estate Investing" process, I start by letting them all know one thing, "We may be starting as a wholesaler but wholesaling is not a sustainable business model". If you do not learn the old gas station adage: "When is the last time you went to a gas station that only sold gas"? (In other words multiple streams of income) then you will eventually stall and either evolve out of necessity or become extinct. Wholesaling is a good start, low barrier of entry, low cost (and profit) but a place to cut your teeth. From there one has to learn, grow and do better until they find the niche that works best for them. I am primarily a rehabber/builder now days. In the next 10-15 years... I may let others do the chasing and be 100% hard money or JV partner, who knows? The problem with wholesaling in a nutshell is you'll notice most of the people in the space don't hold any inventory. You blast to your list, 10 wholesalers pick it up, add $10K to your deal and send it to their list, that happens 1 or 2 more times down the line and all of a sudden there is no deal anymore and it turned into a daisy chain of crap where no one knows how to get the deal and get paid if they could find the originator. It's a mess with all the BS programs that are out there "selling the secret to wholesaling in under 11 hours" or whatever else they can conjure up. It's like the diet pill commercials for real estate investor wannabes. You know what I'm talking about, "take this pill, eat like ****, don't exercise, sleep 12 hours a day and you'll still lose weight". People who buy that stuff are the same people who are too lazy to call and ask for a refund and these companies know it.

    My advice to wholesalers.... forget all the BS and nonsense about "co-wholesaling", flipping houses from Beirut with a laptop and a hookah or making a 6 figure income working in your underwear and never having to leave your house. This is a business so be prepared to work, this is a business and who makes the most money in any business model? People or companies who control all or the majority of the process. In other words, when you spend some money on marketing to generate a lead and IT'S YOURS then you have exclusivity. NOW you have something worth some money to sell. Don't think that recycling other peoples inventory will make you rich, it won't end well for you. Have your own list or start building it, get aggressive and use your "WIT" (Whatever It Takes) to get a deal sold.

    Anyway... I rambled, thanks for all your input gents, I would love to talk further on this or any other subject you like, anytime. Have a great evening.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.