South Florida 2-4 unit underwriting at ~7%. What are you stressing first?

South Florida 2-4 unit underwriting at ~7%. What are you stressing first?

Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 0 votes

I have been looking at Miami-Dade September 2026 resales (Miami Realtors released Oct 16) next to the Freddie Mac national 30-year benchmark.

A few dated points that keep coming up when I underwrite small multifamily here:

1. Houses and condos are not the same market. September single-family supply was about 5.1 months. Existing condo supply was about 12.3 months. House median ~$692k (+4.06% YoY). Existing condo median ~$417k (-0.69% YoY). Medians of closed sales, not an appraisal of any one property.

2. Borrowing cost still bites. The Oct 29 Freddie Mac national average was 7.24%. The Nov 5 print was 7.18%. Those are conventional survey averages, not quotes for a financed investment purchase. An investor loan can run higher.

3. Example numbers only (P&I). An $800,000 purchase with 25% down is a $600,000 loan over 360 payments. At 7.24%, principal and interest is about $4,089 a month. At a hypothetical 6.24%, about $3,690. Difference roughly $399 a month. That excludes taxes, insurance, flood, HOA, vacancy, management, repairs, reserves, closing costs and utilities. Model those before calling anything cash-flow positive.

4. Apartment rent samples are not duplex comps. MMG's Miami Q3 2026 apartment report showed average rent $2,381 and 0.7% annual growth, with ~94.7% occupancy. Useful context for the apartment market. Not a rent comp for a particular 2-4 unit.

5. Scenario weights are opinions, not forecasts. On Nov 1 I sketched uncalibrated 2-year weights for sound 2-4 unit buildings at 45% up / 35% flat / 20% down, where up means >+5% nominal price change, flat within ±5%, down <-5%, and rents, financing, taxes and transaction costs are excluded.

Those are subjective research categories dated Nov 1, not proven predictions. An earlier October outlook existed only as an unpublished draft and is not a scored public forecast record.

What I keep asking on every showing: what purchase price still works after the rent roll, insurance, taxes, repairs, reserves and today's financing are supported by evidence?

Curious how others here are stressing deals right now. Rate? Insurance? Condo/building eligibility? Vacancy? Something else?

Disclosure: I built siEarn, a South Florida income-property research tool.

0Reply
325 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2021 · 556 posts · 427 votes
5d

Insurance first, then vacancy. In Florida, insurance is the swing factor, so underwrite it with a real quote, not a plug number. A rate move hurts, but a bad insurance quote can wipe out cash flow fast. Hope this helps, DM me if you want a second set of eyes on the numbers.

See this reply in the discussion

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2021 · 556 posts · 427 votes
    5d

    Insurance first, then vacancy. In Florida, insurance is the swing factor, so underwrite it with a real quote, not a plug number. A rate move hurts, but a bad insurance quote can wipe out cash flow fast. Hope this helps, DM me if you want a second set of eyes on the numbers.

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 425 posts · 143 votes
    3d

    Marcos, I like the way you're framing this — and I agree with Noah that insurance is the swing factor in Florida. From the agent side in Memphis, the first thing I stress is the rent itself. Your example shows why: the P&I difference between 7.24% and 6.24% is real money, but it's the rent that has to cover all of it, and apartment averages aren't duplex comps, as you said. So I stress the rent down to what the actual rent roll and deposits support, then vacancy, then insurance and taxes with real quotes. Rate is the one input I can't control, so I don't build a deal around a future rate cut — I build it around a purchase price that works at today's rate. What are you seeing on insurance quotes for the buildings you're looking at?

  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 117 posts · 28 votes
    3d

    Marcos — good question, and the order matters more than any single number.

    I underwrite the same way on my own small multifamily. I run 17+ units across five buy-and-hold deals, including a 3-unit in Worcester and a 6-unit in Warren, RI, plus an STR in Revere. Here's how I'd stress yours:

    1. Rent roll first. Underwrite only in-place rents, not pro forma. If the deal needs a rent bump to work, it doesn't work yet.

    2. Insurance and taxes next, with real quotes — not the seller's numbers. In Florida those two can move the deal more than the rate.

    3. Vacancy and reserves after that. Older 2-4s will test you on maintenance, so hold a real reserve per unit.

    4. Rate last. Underwrite at today's rate and treat any refi as upside, never as the plan.

    If it clears on in-place rents at today's rate with honest insurance, it's a real deal. Happy to compare notes — feel free to connect or follow along.

  • Technology · Member since 2026 · 16 posts · 3 votes
    1d

    Marcos, on the taxes Inder and Ametria mentioned, one Florida-specific thing I'd check before the rate: don't use the tax figure on the listing. In Florida the assessed value usually resets to market value on the January 1 after a sale. That's true even if the seller was an investor, because the 10% cap on non-homestead property resets on a change of ownership. If the seller lived in one of the units, their bill may also have a homestead exemption and the Save Our Homes cap on it, and as far as I know neither carries over to an investor buyer. On a building the seller has held for years, the gap can be thousands a year.

    Easy check: the Miami-Dade Property Appraiser site has a tax estimator where you enter a value, like your purchase price, and it estimates the bill using the current millage rates. I'd run that on every deal, then stress insurance and the rate on top of it.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.