South Florida 2-4 unit underwriting at ~7%. What are you stressing first?
I have been looking at Miami-Dade September 2026 resales (Miami Realtors released Oct 16) next to the Freddie Mac national 30-year benchmark.
A few dated points that keep coming up when I underwrite small multifamily here:
1. Houses and condos are not the same market. September single-family supply was about 5.1 months. Existing condo supply was about 12.3 months. House median ~$692k (+4.06% YoY). Existing condo median ~$417k (-0.69% YoY). Medians of closed sales, not an appraisal of any one property.
2. Borrowing cost still bites. The Oct 29 Freddie Mac national average was 7.24%. The Nov 5 print was 7.18%. Those are conventional survey averages, not quotes for a financed investment purchase. An investor loan can run higher.
3. Example numbers only (P&I). An $800,000 purchase with 25% down is a $600,000 loan over 360 payments. At 7.24%, principal and interest is about $4,089 a month. At a hypothetical 6.24%, about $3,690. Difference roughly $399 a month. That excludes taxes, insurance, flood, HOA, vacancy, management, repairs, reserves, closing costs and utilities. Model those before calling anything cash-flow positive.
4. Apartment rent samples are not duplex comps. MMG's Miami Q3 2026 apartment report showed average rent $2,381 and 0.7% annual growth, with ~94.7% occupancy. Useful context for the apartment market. Not a rent comp for a particular 2-4 unit.
5. Scenario weights are opinions, not forecasts. On Nov 1 I sketched uncalibrated 2-year weights for sound 2-4 unit buildings at 45% up / 35% flat / 20% down, where up means >+5% nominal price change, flat within ±5%, down <-5%, and rents, financing, taxes and transaction costs are excluded.
Those are subjective research categories dated Nov 1, not proven predictions. An earlier October outlook existed only as an unpublished draft and is not a scored public forecast record.
What I keep asking on every showing: what purchase price still works after the rent roll, insurance, taxes, repairs, reserves and today's financing are supported by evidence?
Curious how others here are stressing deals right now. Rate? Insurance? Condo/building eligibility? Vacancy? Something else?
Disclosure: I built siEarn, a South Florida income-property research tool.