Hold or Sell Commercial Property in a Hot Market

Hold or Sell Commercial Property in a Hot Market

Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2020 · 2 posts · 1 vote

Hello Bigger Pockets, this is my first post, and debating whether to hold or sell my office condo suite that I bought back in 2011 after my landlord filed bankruptcy and was left rent free for almost a year until I was able to offer a low purchase price to the bank that held the "bad note." Fast forward to 2019 after selling my practice that was housed in this office condo and the new owners paying me rent on a 5 year lease with 2, 3 year options to renew, I'm debating whether to now sell since my wife and I of 19 years are going through a divorce. In the settlement, our house and office condo are essentially worth the same when factoring in taxes for the commercial sale and no sales tax on our primary home. Therefore, if I agree to take the office condo and she gets the home, should I then hold onto this passive income asset and save on taxes, commission, and closing fees or should I sell and pay those fees now which would be split between me and my wife and then eventually invest in another commercial property? Otherwise, I could eventually 1031 the property when I find a new property or just hold onto the property indefinitely since it has an NOI of roughly $45K/year?

I appreciate any insight into how to best handle my next move on this commercial property since I'm also planning to relocate to South Carolina after living in Arizona since 2004?

Thanks,

Dr. C

1Reply
70 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Smyrna, GA · Member since 2018 · 974 posts · 645 votes
    5y

    Hi Dr. C, I'd focus on what aligns most with my goals and peace. If I'd be more peaceful starting investments in my new home (SC) and getting a fresh start - then great, I'd do that. But if that isn't aligned with my goals and wouldn't bring me peace knowing that I'm off track, then no, I'd hold it and the NOI and stick to my guns. Another thought - given a settlement and to ensure a fair split, sell both and split it all evenly, then there's no feelings of one got a better deal if things don't go well on the commercial sale.

  • Real Estate Agent · North Myrtle Beach, SC · Member since 2018 · 110 posts · 99 votes
    5y

    Hi Dr. C @Chad A Carlsson - I would second @Joseph Firmin by following your long term goals. Can you run your exact forecasted expenses (capital gains tax, commissions and closing fees) and see where you end up? Sounds like a good deal if you effectively halve the cost of those fees and frees up some capital to find something new. If you do hold it, you would also need to factor in management, potential headaches as well as a "premium" for whatever makes you sleep well at night being so far away. 

    A 1031 exchange may be a good move - make sure you start identifying properties before you sell and follow the steps in order to move the net proceeds to an escrow account so you can roll that into your next investment within the 45-day window. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2020 · 2 posts · 1 vote
    5y

    Yes, I've considered the capital gains tax and commission when selling the office space and eliminate those costs and how it affects my overall net. I'm even thinking of refinancing and buying my ex out of both properties after running the numbers on the NOI, cash flow, and long term passive income let alone potential value by holding onto the office condo property alone vs selling it.

    Just waiting to see what the rental comps are for long term rentals in Gilbert vs short term rentals since the market is soooo hot in AZ and the inventory sooo low.  People are paying top dollar just to rent until their home is built or when one of any are available to even buy! 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.