I just replaced my 19 year old gas range with a new one, only to realize that its griddle & grates are cast iron. If not cleaned well, dried, and oiled regularly, cast iron can rust. If in a lease, tenants agree to properly care for the griddle & grates, but then they don't, can they still argue that rust is "normal wear and tear"? Note that I'm in Oakland CA where judges are known to side with tenants.
Look, here’s the reality—tenants break stuff, and sometimes they’re responsible, sometimes they’re not. But when it comes to a stove’s cast iron griddle and grates, it all comes down to negligence vs. normal wear and tear. If they’re just using the stove like any normal person would, that’s on us as landlords. But if they’re slamming heavy pots down, scrubbing with corrosive cleaners, or overheating it to the point of warping, that’s tenant damage—plain and simple.
The lease is the first line of defense. If it clearly states tenant responsibility for appliances, you’ve got leverage. But even if it doesn’t, state laws usually back landlords when it’s clear negligence is at play. Worst-case scenario? You document the damage, deduct it from their security deposit, and move on.
Bottom line: tenants don’t get a free pass just because 'things happen.' If they’re careless, they pay. And if you set the expectation upfront, you avoid these headaches altogether.