Investor-friendly real estate agents in St. Matthews, KY

4 agents in the BiggerPockets network work with investors in St. Matthews, Kentucky and the towns around it: Louisville, Mount Washington, Shelbyville, and Shepherdsville. Between them they hold 2 reviews from BiggerPockets members. If you are looking for a real estate agent for investors in Jefferson County, start with the list below.

Updated November 2026 · Strategies these agents work: fix & flip, land, long-term rental, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), primary residence, single-family rental, townhouse/condo

Free to use, no obligation to sign.

The agents

  1. 1JP

    Jay Pitts

    RE/MAX Premier Properties · St. Matthews, KY

    View profile
    • Residential
    • Fix & Flip
    • Land
    • Multi-Family (2-4 units)
    • Primary Residence
    • Single-Family Rental

    Jay Pitts is a St. Matthews, KY agent, who specializes in fix & flip, land, multi-family (2-4 units), primary residence, and single-family rental.

    INVESTORS We are the #1 Real Estate Team in Kentucky. We have the knowledge, experience and resources to help you strategize your investment portfolio, or if you are working on your first investment property we will guide you through all the steps to ensure you meet your goals. For real estate tips follow me on Insta @jaypittsrealtor

    Serves Douglass Hills, Elizabethtown, Jeffersontown, Jeffersonville, Louisville, New Albany, Saint Matthews, Shively, Vine GroveAlso listed for Louisville, KY
    View full profile
  2. 2MD

    Monica Dunlap

    Totally About Houses - Louisville · St. Matthews, KY

    View profile
    • Commercial
    • Residential
    • Fix & Flip
    • Land
    • Multi-Family (2-4 units)
    • Multi-Family (5+ units)
    • Primary Residence
    • Single-Family Rental

    Monica Dunlap is a St. Matthews, KY agent, who specializes in fix & flip, land, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), primary residence, and single-family rental.

    Investor-friendly agent specializing in long-term rentals & buy & holds. Specialties: Investor Agent - Buyer's Agent - Listing Agent - Relocation - Property Management - Landlord Why Choose Me As Your Agent? When you work with me, you will receive a knowledgeable and professional real estate agent, a committed ally to negotiate on your behalf, the systems in place to streamline buying or selling your home, and the backing of a trusted company, eXp Realty. Why Work With A eXp Agent? Looking to sell your home? As a real estate associate of eXp Realty, you will now have access to associates across the country to help you sell your property. With our technology, we are leading the way in how homes are sold and purchased through online marketing. Through our eXp, your listing will display on top-name sites like Zillow and Trulia to get you the most brand exposure to your home. Looking to purchase a home? With our eXp technology and advanced websites, searching for properties that are active on the MLS is a breeze. Now you can search 24/7, save properties to your profile to view later and schedule showings with me so you can see these properties in person. My job is to make the real estate buying process that much simpler and as a real estate associate of eXp, we are doing just that. Our company prides itself in staying on the cutting edge of technology and if you select me as your real estate agent, you will receive all of this and more. You could never find a more dedicated, energetic, or focused agent to represent you. Please give me a call for a no-obligation assessment of your needs!

    Serves Bardstown, LeGrande, Louisville, Mount Washington, Shelbyville, Shepherdsville, TaylorsvilleAlso listed for Louisville, KY
    View full profile
  3. 3JR

    Justin Robbins

    The Forge Group · St. Matthews, KY

    5.0(2 reviews)

    View profile
    • Commercial
    • Residential
    • Long-term rental
    • Multi-Family (2-4 units)
    • Multi-Family (5+ units)
    • Primary Residence
    • Single-Family Rental

    Justin Robbins is a St. Matthews, KY agent rated 5.0 from 2 BiggerPockets member reviews, who specializes in long-term rental, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), primary residence, and single-family rental.

    Build your Portfolio with The Forge Group, a dedicated real estate team specializing in the Louisville market. This premier group of professionals is committed to guiding clients through every step of their real estate journey, whether they are buying or selling. With a focus on delivering exceptional value, they transform the complex process of real estate into a seamless and rewarding experience, helping you build your future with confidence. Run by a Real Estate Investor and Agent. We love the hunt for money making properties. We work heavily with small and large multi-family and Single Family homes. Turn Key Rentals, Flip and BRRRR, House Hacks I will help you to find the best fit property for your portfolio goals. Happy to work with new investors or experienced. Let's build your wealth. My Portfolio: 9 current properties House Hacked my primary Residence then made a rental 2 Turn Key Cash flowing single-family rentals 4 BRRRR Single Family Rentals 1 Value add 4-plex (increased rent by $1000 a month) 1 BRRRR Triplex Multiple Flips

    “Justin was very informative and provided consistent communication through my investment property purchases.”

    Taniesa Velez, BiggerPockets member · reviewed July 2024
    View full profile

Nearby markets these agents also cover

Each town below has its own list of investor-friendly agents.

KentuckyAll markets

Questions investors in St. Matthews ask

Local answers only. The general ones (what investor-friendly means, what it costs, how vetting works) are on the main finder page.

What do St. Matthews agents specialize in?

The 4 agents listed here specialize in fix & flip, land, long-term rental, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), primary residence, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.

Do these agents cover Louisville, Mount Washington, and Shelbyville too?

Yes. Between them, the agents listed here also serve Louisville, Mount Washington, Shelbyville, Shepherdsville, Bardstown, Crestwood, Douglass Hills, Elizabethtown, Jeffersontown, Jeffersonville, LeGrande, Lexington, New Albany, Saint Matthews, Shively, Simpsonville, Taylorsville, and Vine Grove. If your search is really greater St. Matthews rather than the city itself, start with the agent whose reviews mention the town you are buying in.

How should I choose between them?

Read the investor reviews first, then the agent's own forum posts, which show how they think about a deal before you have spent an hour on the phone. Ask each for the last three investment deals they closed in Jefferson County and how those deals performed. An agent who works with investors will have the numbers ready.

What is an investor-friendly real estate agent?

An investor-friendly real estate agent represents buyers who purchase property to rent, renovate, or resell rather than to live in. They can price a property against rent comps and renovation costs, not just against nearby sales, and they are used to offers written for speed and inspection terms an owner-occupant would not accept. Many are investors themselves.

Are you an agent in St. Matthews?

Apply to be listed for investors in Kentucky.

Agent application
Included RentRedi subscription. All-in-one property management platform for collecting rent, handling repairs, and finding tenants.

Upgrade to unlock Pro Perks

Pro Perks are only available to annual Pro members. Upgrade to unlock them now.

What's included in Pro Perks

~$5,000+ potential annual value

  • Investor loan & insurance discounts
  • Property management & banking/ bookkeeping subscriptions
  • Savings on home renovation materials