Investor-friendly real estate agents in Middletown, OH

3 agents in the BiggerPockets network work with investors in Middletown, Ohio and the towns around it: Cincinnati, Dayton, Centerville, and Cleveland. Between them they hold 13 reviews from BiggerPockets members. If you are looking for a real estate agent for investors in Butler County, start with the list below.

Updated November 2026 · Strategies these agents work: fix & flip, land, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, short-term rental, single-family rental, townhouse/condo

Free to use, no obligation to sign.

The agents

1MJ
Me Jenkins
IRONGATE INC REALTORS · Middletown, OH
5.0(1 review)
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Fix & Flip
- Land
- Mobile Home Parks
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- Primary Residence
- Single-Family Rental
Me Jenkins is a Middletown, OH agent rated 5.0 from 1 BiggerPockets member review, who specializes in fix & flip, land, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), primary residence, and single-family rental.
I have flipped over 50 properties in the downtown Dayton area and enjoy making investments as well as helping clients to do the same. One time, I even turned a $1 duplex into $200,000! From my own personal experience and real estate knowledge, I want to help you start making investments today! My goal is to help you find the perfect investment property, whether you're looking for a house to flip for future buyers, or one to call your own. For almost a decade, I have gained experience with investment properties, which eventually led me to become a realtor with Irongate as of 2022. Since the very first property I flipped, I always preserve one original detail in the house. In that first home, this was a firetruck light switch in a child’s bedroom. The key to your real estate investment goals, is M.E.!
“When I started thinking of buying investment properties out of state, I came to the Biggerpockets website and sent out messages to realtors in Ohio and ME reached out to me immediately.”
Jess Azong, BiggerPockets member · reviewed July 2024
Serves Centerville, Cincinnati, Dayton, Fairborn, Huber Heights, Kettering, Lebanon, Mason, Miamisburg, Moraine, Morrow, Oakwood, West Carrollton, XeniaAlso listed for Dayton, OH
View full profile
2MP
Mike Paolucci
Reafco - Mike Paolucci · Middletown, OH
5.0(12 reviews)·504 forum posts
View profile
- Residential
- Fix & flip
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Primary Residence
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
Mike Paolucci is a Middletown, OH agent rated 5.0 from 12 BiggerPockets member reviews, who specializes in fix & flip, multi-family (2-4 units), primary residence, short-term rental, and single-family rental.
Fix & Flip, MTR, LTR, BRRRR, House Hacking, & Multifamily. I’m an investor-friendly real estate agent based in Ohio, actively investing across Columbus, Dayton, and Cleveland. I currently own 7 doors personally and have another 11 doors through partnerships, so I’m in the trenches right alongside my clients. I got started in 2021 as an out-of-state investor, which gave me a strong understanding of how to analyze deals remotely, build the right team, and manage risk from a distance. In 2022, I transitioned into property management, focusing on maintenance and leasing—so I’ve seen firsthand what impacts cash flow, tenant quality, and long-term performance. Today, I work with investors at all stages—from first-time buyers to those scaling portfolios—helping them find solid opportunities, run numbers the right way, and execute with confidence. I’m especially focused on value-add and cash-flowing rental properties in growing Ohio markets. Always open to connecting with other investors, sharing insights, and helping however I can. If you’re investing in Ohio or looking to get started, feel free to reach out.
“This was my second time working with Michael on an out-of-state investment property in Ohio, and I keep coming back for the same reason: his communication is outstanding.”
Hayden Ontai, BiggerPockets member · reviewed August 2026
Serves Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, DaytonAlso listed for Columbus, OH, Dayton, OH
View full profile
3SM
Spencer Marshall
eXp Realty · Middletown, OH
13 forum posts
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Fix & flip
- Land
- Mobile Home Parks
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- New Construction
- Office/Retail
- Primary Residence
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Spencer Marshall is a Middletown, OH agent, who specializes in fix & flip, land, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
I focus on rehab, MTR, and LTR projects in the greater Cincinnati area. My clients take on anything from small single family flips to 100 unit LTRs. I believe there is no perfect way to invest. Whatever you are comfortable with is where we will start. I work full time as a real estate agent serving the Dayton, OH and Cincinnati, OH Real estate markets. A local native, I grew up in Cincinnati and graduated from Ohio State University. In addition, I personally invest in both Cincinnati and Dayton. I live in Cincinnati and am continuously exposed to the numerous opportunities in these emerging markets. Real estate is my passion and I truly believe Real Estate is the best path to generational wealth. The more investors we can bring to the market, the easier it will be to capitalize on these opportunities. Please reach out to me with any questions regarding where to get started, what areas to buy in, or my opinions on a deal.
Serves Cincinnati, DaytonAlso listed for Cincinnati, OH, Dayton, OH
View full profile

Investing in Middletown: the numbers

Metro-area figures from BiggerPockets market data, as of November 2026.

$258,600median home price
$1,105median monthly rent
0.43%monthly rent to price
3.6%unemployment rate

Source and definitions: Market Finder.

Nearby markets these agents also cover

Each town below has its own list of investor-friendly agents.

Ohio All markets

Questions investors in Middletown ask

Local answers only. The general ones (what investor-friendly means, what it costs, how vetting works) are on the main finder page.

What do Middletown agents specialize in?

The 3 agents listed here specialize in fix & flip, land, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.

Do these agents cover Cincinnati, Dayton, and Centerville too?

Yes. Between them, the agents listed here also serve Cincinnati, Dayton, Centerville, Cleveland, Columbus, Fairborn, Huber Heights, Kettering, Lebanon, Mason, Miamisburg, Moraine, Morrow, Oakwood, West Carrollton, and Xenia. If your search is really greater Middletown rather than the city itself, start with the agent whose reviews mention the town you are buying in.

How should I choose between them?

Read the investor reviews first, then the agent's own forum posts, which show how they think about a deal before you have spent an hour on the phone. Ask each for the last three investment deals they closed in Butler County and how those deals performed. An agent who works with investors will have the numbers ready.

What is an investor-friendly real estate agent?

An investor-friendly real estate agent represents buyers who purchase property to rent, renovate, or resell rather than to live in. They can price a property against rent comps and renovation costs, not just against nearby sales, and they are used to offers written for speed and inspection terms an owner-occupant would not accept. Many are investors themselves.

Are you an agent in Middletown?

Apply to be listed for investors in Ohio.

Agent application