Investor-friendly real estate agents in Hershey, PA

5 agents in the BiggerPockets network work with investors in Hershey, Pennsylvania and the towns around it: Lancaster, York, Harrisburg, and Lebanon. Between them they hold 6 reviews from BiggerPockets members. If you are looking for a real estate agent for investors in Dauphin County, start with the list below.

Updated November 2026 · Strategies these agents work: fix & flip, land, long-term rental, mid-term rental, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, townhouse/condo

Free to use, no obligation to sign.

The agents

1CG
Chris Good
Astoria Realty Advisors · Hershey, PA
51 forum posts
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Land
- Long-term rental
- Mid-term rental
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- Office/Retail
- Primary Residence
- Self-Storage
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Chris Good is a Hershey, PA agent, who specializes in land, long-term rental, mid-term rental, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), office/retail, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
Buy, sell and grow your rental portfolio with a broker who owns 50+ rental units himself. Astoria Realty Advisors is an investor-friendly brokerage in Lancaster County, PA, led by broker/owner Chris Good. We help investors across Lancaster, Dauphin, Berks and Perry counties find, analyze and close on single-family rentals, small multifamily, mid-term rentals, commercial property and land. Every deal gets an owner's review: rents, repairs, financing, cash flow and exit. What you get: - Deal analysis from an agent who invests - Auction and off-market opportunities when they come up - Our network of investor-friendly lenders, contractors, inspectors and property managers - Clear communication and a transaction that moves forward with clarity and ease Call or text Chris at (717) 821-1610, or tap Contact us.
Serves Chester, Ephrata, Harrisburg, Lancaster, Lebanon, Lititz, New Holland, Pottstown, Reading, West Chester, York
View full profile
2SZ
Sheldon Zimmerman
The Sheldon Zimmerman Team · Hershey, PA
5.0(6 reviews)·63 forum posts
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Fix & flip
- Land
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- New Construction
- Office/Retail
- Primary Residence
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Sheldon Zimmerman is a Hershey, PA agent rated 5.0 from 6 BiggerPockets member reviews, who specializes in fix & flip, land, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
"Real estate investing, even on a very small scale, remains a tried and true means of building an individual's cash flow and wealth" - Robert T. Kiyosaki I have been in the real estate business since 2007 and have worked with a variety of clients, ranging from first time home buyers to experienced real estate investors. I have partnered with other investors to do fix and flips and purchase rental units. I personally have 20+ doors, ranging from Reading, Pennsylvania to Kansas City Missouri, with goals for that number to continue growing. After obtaining an Associate’s Degree in Electrical Technology from Thaddeus Steven’s School of Technology, I have experience in construction from working in the electrical field for over 10 years. Having this knowledge and background in construction will allow me to point out potential issues in homes you may look at. I will be able to give my advice on any electrical issues and an approximate cost for repair items. I provide a full service of real estate needs and can represent first time home buyers or assist in the sale of homes for families who are upsizing or downsizing their current properties. I also can help you with land development needs. I have helped to start both an industrial park and a residential development. I have also assisted in a large commercial project for a nonprofit mission organization. My goal is to provide you service with all your real estate needs, from buying to managing to selling and everything in between! If you need an honest, hardworking agent that works for your benefit, and your profit. You know who to call!
“Sheldon is like a unicorn in real estate.”
Chad Gallagher, BiggerPockets member · reviewed July 2024
Serves Harrisburg, Lancaster, Lebanon, Norristown, Philadelphia, Reading, YorkAlso listed for Pottstown, PA, Reading, PA, York, PA
View full profile
3AM
Aaron M Pendergast
Realty One Group Generations · Hershey, PA
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Fix & Flip
- Land
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- Primary Residence
- Single-Family Rental
Aaron M Pendergast is a Hershey, PA agent, who specializes in fix & flip, land, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), primary residence, and single-family rental.
I am a 3rd generation agent who owns and operates family owned brokerage Realty One Group Generations with partners in the family and an Ameriprise wealth management franchise. I handle sale an operations for the brokerage and for our real estate team Glenda Kane & Company, which has 8 agents who are ready to handle business throughout South central PA and Northern MD. The team allows us to move quickly for our clients in this fast paced seller markets. Our hallmark is communication and the agents on our team understand the importance of being accessible and making sure every phone call gets returned. So much so that we guarantee it. If an agent doesn't return a client's call within 24 hours we will actually deduct it from our commission. Don't get too excited about that though because in the six years since we implemented the program we have yet to have paid out a client for an agent not returning their client's call. It's our belief that while industry knowledge and proper financial acumen and connections are valuable to our client base, that nothing matters more than communication and availability. Our family also owns and operated an expanding property management company Hulson Homes in the York and Adams County area. I primarily handle investors looking to purchase or list their homes while my brother Alex Kane oversees the property management side. Our broker of record Glenda Kane (also goes by mom) was instrumental in the residential side of the market managing one of the largest teams in the area for last 30 years. Myself, and agents I manage, are specialized in different areas in the market from listing, purchasing, investment NOI and cash flow analysis, and commercial purchasing and management. We look forward to handling any and all of your real estate needs.
Serves Gettysburg, Hanover, Harrisburg, Lancaster, Mechanicsburg, New Oxford, YorkAlso listed for York, PA
View full profile
4SN
Sarah Naylor
The Bailey Naylor Team · Hershey, PA
1 forum post
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Fix & flip
- Mobile Home Parks
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- New Construction
- Primary Residence
- Self-Storage
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Sarah Naylor is a Hershey, PA agent, who specializes in fix & flip, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
The Bailey Naylor Team takes pride in working with clients to purchase, Manage, and sell investment properties specializing in buy/hold utilizing the BRRRR method/standard financing, multi units, Air bnb, HouseHacking, fix and flips, and more. The Bailey Naylor Team is a group of seasoned investors and investor-friendly Realtors who hold a deep understanding of what it takes to identify high-potential investment properties that deliver strong returns. We pride ourselves on our ability to find opportunities that align with our clients’ specific goals, whether that’s long-term growth or immediate cash flow. With our extensive market knowledge, expert negotiation skills, and commitment to client success, we are dedicated to helping you make smart, profitable investments every step of the way.
Serves Akron, Brickerville, Brownstown, Collegeville, Conshohocken, Denver, East Petersburg, Elizabethtown, Ephrata, Lancaster, Lansdale, Lebanon, Lititz, Manheim, Millersville, Mount Joy, Norristown, Pequea, Plymouth Meeting, Quarryville, Reinholds, Sinking Spring, Stevens, Temple, Wernersville, West Reading, Wyomissing, York
View full profile
5BF
Ben Fernandez
Ben Fernandez at Keller Williams · Hershey, PA
169 forum posts
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Long-term rental
- Mid-term rental
- Mobile Home Parks
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- New Construction
- Primary Residence
- Self-Storage
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Ben Fernandez is a Hershey, PA agent, who specializes in long-term rental, mid-term rental, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
With over 15 years of real estate experience, I help real estate investors identify, acquire, and execute profitable deals with confidence. From first-time investors to seasoned portfolio builders, my focus is on strategic representation that supports smart acquisitions, efficient operations, and scalable growth. I specialize in sourcing and structuring opportunities for fix-and-flip and buy-and-hold strategies, leveraging market analysis, value-add identification, turnkey performing asset sourcing, and creative financing solutions to maximize returns. Whether utilizing HomeStyle Renovation loans, FHA 203k financing, traditional lending, private capital, or cash-style offer strategies, I help investors compete effectively for turnkey, distressed, and undervalued properties. My approach goes beyond locating deals—I assist investors with pricing strategy, renovation scope alignment, capital expenditure analysis, exit planning, and long-term portfolio positioning across diverse market conditions. To further support buy-and-hold investors, I also offer property management services in the Lancaster area, providing hands-on oversight that helps protect assets, stabilize cash flow, and streamline operations after acquisition. Each transaction is guided by clear communication, data-driven insights, and a strong understanding of risk versus reward. Known for a client-first, execution-focused mindset, I work to reduce friction from contract to closing while protecting investor interests at every stage of the transaction—and beyond. If you’re looking for an investor-savvy real estate professional who understands numbers, strategy, market analysis, execution, and ongoing asset management, let’s connect and turn opportunities into profitable outcomes.
Serves Harrisburg, Lancaster, Lebanon, YorkAlso listed for York, PA
View full profile

Investing in Hershey: the numbers

Metro-area figures from BiggerPockets market data, as of November 2026.

$253,100median home price
$1,212median monthly rent
0.48%monthly rent to price
2.9%unemployment rate

Source and definitions: Market Finder.

Nearby markets these agents also cover

Each town below has its own list of investor-friendly agents.

Pennsylvania All markets

Questions investors in Hershey ask

Local answers only. The general ones (what investor-friendly means, what it costs, how vetting works) are on the main finder page.

What do Hershey agents specialize in?

The 5 agents listed here specialize in fix & flip, land, long-term rental, mid-term rental, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.

Do these agents cover Lancaster, York, and Harrisburg too?

Yes. Between them, the agents listed here also serve Lancaster, York, Harrisburg, Lebanon, Ephrata, Lititz, Norristown, Reading, Akron, Brickerville, Brownstown, Chester, Collegeville, Conshohocken, Denver, East Petersburg, Elizabethtown, Gettysburg, Hanover, Lansdale, Manheim, Mechanicsburg, Millersville, Mount Joy, New Holland, New Oxford, Pequea, Philadelphia, Plymouth Meeting, Pottstown, Quarryville, Reinholds, Sinking Spring, Stevens, Temple, Wernersville, West Chester, West Reading, and Wyomissing. If your search is really greater Hershey rather than the city itself, start with the agent whose reviews mention the town you are buying in.

How should I choose between them?

Read the investor reviews first, then the agent's own forum posts, which show how they think about a deal before you have spent an hour on the phone. Ask each for the last three investment deals they closed in Dauphin County and how those deals performed. An agent who works with investors will have the numbers ready.

What is an investor-friendly real estate agent?

An investor-friendly real estate agent represents buyers who purchase property to rent, renovate, or resell rather than to live in. They can price a property against rent comps and renovation costs, not just against nearby sales, and they are used to offers written for speed and inspection terms an owner-occupant would not accept. Many are investors themselves.

Are you an agent in Hershey?

Apply to be listed for investors in Pennsylvania.

Agent application

Investor-friendly real estate agents in Hershey, PA

The agents

Chris Good

Sheldon Zimmerman

Aaron M Pendergast

Sarah Naylor

Ben Fernandez