"Paralysis by Analysis" Has a New Cousin... "The Rates Will Get Better"

"Paralysis by Analysis" Has a New Cousin... "The Rates Will Get Better"

AJ ExnerPro Member
Lender · Springfield, MO · Member since 2023 · 664 posts · 320 votes

Ahh, the quippy anecdote for new investors: "Paralysis by Analysis"

An investor finds a deal, they run the numbers, they run them again, they look at the comps, they build another spreadsheet, they talk themselves into it, than they talk themselves out of it, and eventually… they don't buy the property.

But I think there is a different version of this happening today, particularly among somewhat more seasoned investors.

I call it: “I'm waiting for rates to get better.” (The grass is greener)

And I understand the logic... to a certain extent

If you're sitting on equity (hello COVID-era rates), looking at a new project with today's interest rates, it's easy to think: “Why deploy the money today when I might be able to get a better rate for my equity six months from now?”

So you wait...

for rates to come down.

for the market to improve.

for financing to become more attractive.

But while you're waiting, you're watching deals come and go.

Here's the question I've been wrestling with:

At what point does waiting for better financing become more expensive than simply investing at today's financing costs?

I'm not suggesting investors should ignore interest rates or force a deal that doesn't work. Quite the opposite, the numbers still need to work.

But there is a difference between waiting for a better deal and waiting for the perfect environment.

I had a friend who used to say that you need to focus on hitting singles instead of trying to hit 'Home Runs' every time

There's also another piece that gets overlooked:

If rates fall significantly, you're not the only person who notices.

More buyers come off the sidelines.

Competition increases.

Property values move.

Sellers become less motivated.

And the deal you were waiting to buy at a lower borrowing cost could become a more expensive acquisition.

That's the part of the conversation I find fascinating.

You can be right about rates going down and still be wrong about waiting.

The goal is to identify opportunities where the fundamentals make sense today and where you have enough flexibility to improve your position tomorrow.

You can't improve a deal you never bought.

So I'm curious what everyone else is seeing, are you finding that investors are becoming overly cautious because they're waiting for rates to improve?

0Reply
238 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Shiloh LundahlPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    3mo

    @AJ Exner Yes. Real estate investing is not as easy to make money in as it was before 2022. So a lot of people got out of buying properties. They are waiting for it to become easy again. Meanwhile, it has gotten easier for more experienced investors because a lot of the competition has disappeared so I am getting better deals now than compared to the past the previous few years. 

  • G. Brian DavisPro Member
    Investor · Hatboro, PA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 906 votes
    3mo

    AJ, this matches what I see constantly. Investors waiting for a better rate are also implicitly betting they can predict the debt markets, which is a different skill than picking a good deal. Waiting rarely pays off, since you also lose two years of rent growth and appreciation while sitting on the sidelines.

    • AJ ExnerPro Member
      OP
      Lender · Springfield, MO · Member since 2023 · 664 posts · 320 votes
      2mo
      Quote from @G. Brian Davis:

      AJ, this matches what I see constantly. Investors waiting for a better rate are also implicitly betting they can predict the debt markets, which is a different skill than picking a good deal. Waiting rarely pays off, since you also lose two years of rent growth and appreciation while sitting on the sidelines.


       When people ask about that, I always respond with "there are people who get paid alot more than me to figure that out", but I do continue to find myself gently nudging and encouraging to help keeping things moving reminding them of Newton's first law:
      "The object at rest, stays at rest, while the object in motion, stays in motion"

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.