I pencil-underwrote every active 2-4 unit in Oxnard, CA. Here's what I found.

I pencil-underwrote every active 2-4 unit in Oxnard, CA. Here's what I found.

Real Estate Agent · Ventura County · Member since 2024 · 8 posts · 4 votes

✏️Spent this morning running a pencil sheet on every active duplex in Oxnard zips 93030 and 93033 (5 listings, $750K-$929K).

Terms: 25% down, 7.25%, 30-yr, taxes at 1.25% of list price. NOI uses ~5% vacancy, plus insurance, maintenance and reserves.

Result: none clear 1.0x DSCR on in-place rents. Most land around 0.4-0.5x.

The five:

  • 5340 S J: $929K, $5,550/mo, ~0.73x

  • 1026 S C: $788K, ~$3,470/mo (est.), ~0.50x

  • 141 S Hayes: $750K, $3,000/mo, ~0.44x

  • 509 E Date: $788K, $3,148/mo, ~0.44x

  • 639-641 W Kamala: $830K, ~$3,450/mo (est.), ~0.40x

Older duplexes ($750K-$830K) were renting about $1,100-$1,900 a door. The price that actually works at 1.25x on those rents is roughly $330K-$390K.

Best of the five was the remodeled duplex at $929K with ~$2,750/door rents. It would need about $8,100/mo total to hit 1.25x, versus $5,550 today.

A couple of caveats: two of the rents are estimates (marked above), and I used list price for property tax reassessment.

Right now it looks like an appreciation or owner-occupant play, not a cash-flow one. Is anyone finding 2-4s in Ventura County (or similar high-cost coastal markets) that pencil today? What assumptions would you change?

2Reply
91 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender · Washington DC · Member since 2026 · 69 posts · 18 votes
    11h
    Quote from @Noelle Harrelson:

    ✏️Spent this morning running a pencil sheet on every active duplex in Oxnard zips 93030 and 93033 (5 listings, $750K-$929K).

    Terms: 25% down, 7.25%, 30-yr, taxes at 1.25% of list price. NOI uses ~5% vacancy, plus insurance, maintenance and reserves.

    Result: none clear 1.0x DSCR on in-place rents. Most land around 0.4-0.5x.

    The five:

    • 5340 S J: $929K, $5,550/mo, ~0.73x

    • 1026 S C: $788K, ~$3,470/mo (est.), ~0.50x

    • 141 S Hayes: $750K, $3,000/mo, ~0.44x

    • 509 E Date: $788K, $3,148/mo, ~0.44x

    • 639-641 W Kamala: $830K, ~$3,450/mo (est.), ~0.40x

    Older duplexes ($750K-$830K) were renting about $1,100-$1,900 a door. The price that actually works at 1.25x on those rents is roughly $330K-$390K.

    Best of the five was the remodeled duplex at $929K with ~$2,750/door rents. It would need about $8,100/mo total to hit 1.25x, versus $5,550 today.

    A couple of caveats: two of the rents are estimates (marked above), and I used list price for property tax reassessment.

    Right now it looks like an appreciation or owner-occupant play, not a cash-flow one. Is anyone finding 2-4s in Ventura County (or similar high-cost coastal markets) that pencil today? What assumptions would you change?

    Great breakdown. The numbers really highlight how much purchase price and financing structure matter when underwriting rental properties. I'm an investor and real estate financing partner, and I’m always interested in connecting with people who take a numbers driven approach to acquisitions. Curious, are you actively looking for opportunities in Oxnard, or are you primarily analyzing the market right now?

    • Real Estate Agent · Ventura County · Member since 2024 · 8 posts · 4 votes
      3h

      Thanks, LaTarence! I'm a realtor in Oxnard, building my practice around serving investors, so I'm ready for the right deal when it comes along.

      Since you're on the financing side: what DSCR minimums and rates are you seeing on 2-4 units in California right now? I used 7.25% and 25% down. Happy to compare notes.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.