Property manager hasn't paid me in 6 months and has gone unresponsive — what actually

Managing Your Property
4hFollow

Property manager hasn't paid me in 6 months and has gone unresponsive — what actually

Manas M.
CA · Member since 2017 · 57 posts · 18 votes

Out-of-state owner here (based in California) with two Section 8 single-family rentals in Birmingham, Alabama — one in Birmingham, one in Hueytown.

My property manager has not passed through a dollar in about six months, despite collecting the Housing Assistance Payments. The housing authority confirmed in writing that they paid the manager in full every month. The manager's own statement shows a substantial amount held. I have received nothing.

The manager has now stopped responding entirely — no replies to calls, texts, or emails.

What I've done so far:

- Filed complaints with the Alabama Real Estate Commission, BBB, Alabama Attorney General, and HUD OIG

- Sent a formal demand letter with a November 16, 2026 deadline

What I'm looking for is specific, practical advice from anyone who has actually been through this:

1. Did a demand letter on an attorney's letterhead get your PM to pay, or did you have to file suit?

2. For a claim this size in Alabama, is it worth filing in District Court, or did you go small claims and waive the excess over the cap?

3. Has anyone used the AREC Recovery Fund? How did that work in practice?

4. Anything else that actually moved the needle — mediation, collection agency, something I'm missing?

I have one attorney quote so far and it feels steep relative to the size of the claim, and I'm concerned about costs running away if the PM contests it. Open to cheaper routes if they actually work.

Appreciate any firsthand experience — especially from Birmingham / Jefferson County investors.

0Reply
72 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Ametria Chaney
    Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 362 posts · 128 votes
    4h

    Manas, I'm so sorry you're dealing with this — six months of collected rent that never reached you is every out-of-state owner's nightmare, and you've already done the right things by getting the housing authority's confirmation in writing and filing the complaints. A few thoughts from the Realtor side: first, protect the properties themselves — make sure the tenants' Section 8 status and leases are intact, and line up a replacement manager now so you're not stuck if this one disappears entirely. Second, the attorney-letterhead demand often does move the needle where a self-written one didn't, because it signals you're ready to file; if you do file, many owners in your shoes weigh small claims for speed and cost against the amount they'd have to waive. And on the Recovery Fund, I'd ask the Alabama Real Estate Commission directly what it covers and what documentation they need. Keep everything in writing from here on out.

    0Reply
  • Vaibhav PuranikPro Member
    Member since 2025 · 115 posts · 59 votes
    4h

    This might be crazy idea but I will suggest anyways - Is it worth hiring a private investigator to see what exactly happened? Also, what about the service to the tenants? Are they responding to tenant requests? Also, why not immediately break it off with them and give it to some other property management while you keep dealing with the recovery? Speaking to other property managers in the market can also get you more intel.

    [email protected]
    0Reply
  • BJ Everson
    Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 155 posts · 60 votes
    2h

    Manas, sorry you're dealing with this. I'm not in Alabama and this isn't legal advice, but a few practical steps protect the properties while the money gets sorted out. (Disclosure: I'm a Realtor with Swiss Realty Group and assist at Swiss Property Management Group in Columbus.)

    • Send written termination under the management agreement's termination clause, and in the same letter demand the tenant files, signed leases, keys, the security deposit ledger and a trust account statement by a set date.

    • Ask the housing authority what they need to change the payee on the HAP contracts to you or a new manager. Stopping the next payment from going to this manager limits the loss.

    • Send each tenant a written notice saying who to pay and who to call for repairs from now on.

    • In the AREC complaint, ask specifically about the manager's trust account, since that's where the HAP money should have been held.

    • Get both homes inspected soon. An unresponsive manager often means unanswered repair requests, and a failed HQS inspection can pause the HAP. On suit vs small claims, a local collections or landlord-tenant attorney can tell you quickly whether it fits small claims, and some will do a flat-fee demand letter. Is the manager still collecting the tenant portions too?

    0Reply
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.
Log InJoin for Free