How I'd write an offer that beats a wholesaler's lower number

How I'd write an offer that beats a wholesaler's lower number

Lender · Houston, TX · Member since 2026 · 127 posts · 27 votes

A while back I posted about why investors lose houses to wholesalers who offer less. A few people asked the obvious follow-up: fine, so how do you write the offer that wins anyway? Here's how I'd do it.

Start from what the seller is actually buying. Someone who calls a "we buy houses" number wants a date he can count on, nobody tramping through, and no repair list. Every condition in your offer is one more way the deal can die, and he can feel that even if he can't name it.

So I'd strip the offer down:

1. Walk the house before you write, then make the inspection period 3 to 5 days, not 10 to 15.

2. Put proof of funds and a lender pre-approval in the same email as the offer.

3. Let him pick the closing date. A week of extra carry is cheaper than losing the deal.

4. Write "as-is" into the contract and mean it. No repair asks after the inspection.

5. Make the earnest money hard after the option period. It tells him you're not tying the house up while you shop it.

The catch is on your side. If you're going to drop the contingencies, your numbers have to be done before you offer: the ARV, the repair budget, and what the lender will actually advance on that ARV. If you find out after you're under contract that the loan comes in, say, $20,000 short, the "clean" offer is the one that blows up, and you've just handed the wholesaler his next listing.

That's the real reason wholesalers win these. They aren't faster at closing. They're faster at deciding.

I wrote up how I run the numbers before an offer on my website, which you can find through my profile, and you can sign up there to get new reports by email.

For those of you buying direct from sellers: which of these has actually moved a seller for you, or is it still mostly price?

0Reply
150 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
    2d

    Steve, most of this is right — the seller is buying certainty, not just price. I walk the house before I write, keep the inspection short, write as-is and mean it, and let the seller pick the closing date.

    Where I differ is point 5. I never put earnest money down. My certainty comes from the numbers being done before the offer: purchase under $100K, ARV $180K-$265K, Section 8 rent $1,395-$1,950 for 3BR+, and the 1% rule. If the ARV and rent don't work, no amount of hard earnest money fixes it.

    Wholesalers win because they decide fast. I decide fast too — because I know my buy box cold. Deal flow is my bottleneck, so I don't waste time on houses outside it.

    What has moved sellers most for me is a clean, fast close on a number I can actually pay.

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 159 votes
    2d

    Steve, great playbook — and James is right that the numbers have to be done before the offer.

    From the agent side, I would add one thing: how the offer is presented matters as much as what is in it. A clean offer still needs to feel clean to the seller. I call the listing agent or seller to walk through the terms — the short inspection, the proof of funds, the closing date they choose — so the certainty is heard, not just written down.

    The caution for newer buyers is Steve's last point. Dropping contingencies is only smart when the repair budget and the lender's numbers are confirmed. A clean offer with soft numbers behind it is the one that falls apart under contract.

    What has moved sellers most for me is that combination: a simple offer, verified funds, and a lender who answers the phone.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.