10 sfh vs one 10 door property

10 sfh vs one 10 door property

Investor · Atlanta · Member since 2019 · 602 posts · 102 votes

Hi,
Is purchasing 10 sfh over period of time to replace full time job income to retire better or buying 10 unit multi family better.10 unit multi family I do not see many in my market. Even if I see they are very rough areas which I cannot self manage for sure.also selling 10 unit in future might be 10 times more challenging than selling 10 sfh. Gurus teaching Mfh best pay 30k for coaching not talking cons but only superficial stuff. Please advise

1Reply
126 views

Most Popular Reply

Atlanta, GA · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 3 votes
2d

I'd probably take 10 good SFHs over a rough 10-unit every time. People love talking about scale but a bad property in a bad area is still a bad property. Plus if one tenant moves out of a SFH you're 10% vacant. If one tenant moves out of a 10-unit you're also 10% vacant. The difference isn't as huge as some gurus make it sound.

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Atlanta, GA · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 3 votes
    2d

    I'd probably take 10 good SFHs over a rough 10-unit every time. People love talking about scale but a bad property in a bad area is still a bad property. Plus if one tenant moves out of a SFH you're 10% vacant. If one tenant moves out of a 10-unit you're also 10% vacant. The difference isn't as huge as some gurus make it sound.

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 771 votes
    2d

    I'd take 10 single-family houses over one rough 10-unit, every time. I've built to 236 properties doing single-family in Memphis, and the math is plain.

    One bad tenant in a 10-unit is 10% vacant, same as one empty SFH — but a rough 10-unit puts all your risk in one building, one roof, one bad block. With 10 SFHs you can sell one, refi one, or walk from a bad deal without touching the other nine. That's real exit flexibility.

    Run each house on its own numbers: buy under $100K, ARV $180K-$265K, 3BR+ Section 8 rent $1,395-$1,950, and the 1% rule as a first filter. If it doesn't hit the rent for the price, pass — deal flow is the bottleneck, not finding a big building.

    Don't pay $30K for coaching that tells you multifamily is the only way to scale. Scale is doing the same good deal over and over.

  • Property Manager · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2020 · 79 posts · 39 votes
    20h

    10 single family homes would typically make more sense but the 10 door single unit is easier to force appreciation through rents and tenant quality.

    10 doors in 10 different markets though makes it safer. You arent relying on one market to appreciate and will be able to protect your cash better as if one market fails the others will make up the difference.

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    19h

    The SFR will appreciate far faster than the 10 unit and that's where the wealth is made.

    The SFR will have FAR superior financing terms.

    The SFR will sell mostly to Owner occupants who will pay more than the rental income would demand.

    If you suddenly need 10-50% of your money for another investment or life reasons you can sell 1-5 units, not so with the 10 unit.

    You can buy the SFR one at a time with 1/10th the money, starting much sooner.

    The SFR on average will have more but MUCH cheaper capex.

    The SFR won't involve and tenant in tenant or shared wall problems.

    The SFR on average will have 1/w to 1/4th the turnover with better/more stable tennants.

    The SFR inventory will be 20x? 100x? As large for you to choose from.

    The SFR could be nice enough or in a special place that you would want to live in it one day.

    TLDR: SFR all day every day. Easier to buy, easier/cheaper to finance, easier to sell/exchange, more inventory to choose from, less investor buyers, less hassle, higher appreciation, less chance of a 5 or 6 figure capex bill and lower turnover.

    Whats the upside to the MFH? It’s not easier to manage, if it’s cheaper per unit that’s because there’s less appreciation. The units are smaller so all the turnover is cheaper per turn.

  • Arman AhmedPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 975 votes
    18h
    Quote from @Gp G.:

    Hi,
    Is purchasing 10 sfh over period of time to replace full time job income to retire better or buying 10 unit multi family better.10 unit multi family I do not see many in my market. Even if I see they are very rough areas which I cannot self manage for sure.also selling 10 unit in future might be 10 times more challenging than selling 10 sfh. Gurus teaching Mfh best pay 30k for coaching not talking cons but only superficial stuff. Please advise

    Honestly, I’d lean toward building a portfolio of single-family rentals if flexibility and easier resale are priorities. A 10-unit property can offer economies of scale, but one vacancy or major repair can hit harder, especially in a rough area.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.