How to spot a deal that looks good on paper but won't cash flow

How to spot a deal that looks good on paper but won't cash flow

Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 159 votes

A deal can look great in a listing and still lose money every month. The problem usually isn't the price — it's the numbers that never made it into the pro forma.

Here are the costs I see underestimated most often:

Vacancy. A pro forma that assumes 100% occupancy every month is a fantasy. Even a well-managed rental has turnover, and every vacant month has a mortgage, taxes, and insurance to pay. I underwrite with a vacancy allowance, because a property that only works when it is never empty does not really work.

Maintenance and CapEx reserves. A roof, an HVAC system, and a water heater each have a lifespan. If you are not setting aside something monthly for repairs and replacements, you are not cash flowing — you are borrowing from your future self.

Property management. Even if you plan to self-manage, run the numbers with management included. Your time has value, and if you ever need to hand the property off, the deal should work.

Taxes and insurance. Both tend to rise over time, and a reassessment after a sale can change the tax picture. Check the actual bills, not the seller's estimate.

Turnover costs. Cleaning, painting, small repairs, and re-leasing add up between tenants, and they are rarely in a seller's numbers.

Rent assumptions. This is the big one. Verify the rent against actual market rent for comparable homes nearby, not the rent on the listing or a number from a different neighborhood. A deal built on optimistic rent is built on sand.

For example, a property listed at $120,000 with a projected rent of $1,400 a month can look like a win. But if realistic rent is closer to $1,250, and you add in a vacancy allowance, maintenance reserves, management, and rising taxes and insurance, that same property can go negative by $100 or more a month.

A good price does not guarantee cash flow. The deal has to survive honest numbers.

What is the one cost you see investors underestimate most often?

0Reply
184 views

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 126 posts · 31 votes
    2d

    Good question — the example you gave is exactly where deals usually break. The rent assumption is the first place I stress-test. A $1,400 pro forma rent means nothing until you've checked what similar units are actually leasing for right now.

    Second is taxes and insurance after the sale. I own 17 units across 5 buy-and-hold deals, including a 3-unit in Worcester and a 6-unit in Warren, RI. In the multifamily deals I've underwritten, the tax bill and insurance quote on a new purchase are often higher than the seller's numbers, so re-run both with real quotes before you trust the spreadsheet.

    Third is reserves on older buildings. CapEx and turnover don't behave like a newer build, and skipping them is how a deal that looks cash-flow positive turns into a monthly contribution.

    Underwrite rent conservatively, expenses honestly, and only buy if it still works. Happy to connect if you want to walk through a deal.

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 159 votes
    2d

    Inder, thank you — this is exactly the kind of answer I was hoping the post would bring out. The point about re-running taxes and insurance with real quotes instead of the seller's numbers is so important, and the older-building reserves point is one I see trip people up often. I really appreciate you sharing your experience from your own portfolio.

  • Staten Island, NY · Member since 2013 · 153 posts · 78 votes
    2d

    The one I see missed most is property taxes after the sale. A lot of people underwrite with the seller's current tax bill, but in many areas the assessment can change after a sale or a big renovation, so call the local assessor and ask how they handle it before you buy. On your example, I'd also put in a vacancy number and a management fee even if you plan to self manage, because at 1,250 rent one empty month a year is roughly 100 a month gone on its own.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    1d

    A bigger problem is using the WRONG metrics!

    Using Class A assumptions on Class C/D rentals will almost always lead to huge losses.

  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 240 posts · 91 votes
    1d

    Ametria, thank you for laying this out so plainly. The one I watch closest is the rent assumption. I am still learning, and the mistake I keep seeing is a deal built on a rent number nobody checked against real comps nearby. If the rent is optimistic, everything after it is optimistic too. I also check the actual tax bill, not the seller's estimate, because a reassessment after the sale can change the picture fast. Appreciate you asking the question.

    • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 159 votes
      1d

      Thank you, Chris — I appreciate that. You're spot on about the rent assumption; it's the number that can quietly make or break the whole deal, and it's the one I see buyers take at face value most often. Verifying it against real comps before you commit is one of the simplest ways to protect your cash flow.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.