Need Advice on Rental Property I House Hacked In 2022

Need Advice on Rental Property I House Hacked In 2022

Investor · Central Florida · Member since 2026 · 1 post · 1 vote

Hi, I am needing some advice from a property purchased in 2022 in Central Florida using the House Hack method. Of course, I am one of the 11.7% of FHA owners who bought in 2022 that went underwater. I am a realtor part time and full time RN. I was on a contract when Ian hit in 2022 and my contract was cancelled. For 3 months I couldn't get a job due to all the bridges being under water while living there and got behind on payments. I ended up having to take a partial payment plan. The property has a 2 detached houses and own electric (3/2) and (1/1). Was a short term rental and both tenant occupied for one year. I will list details below. It was on the market last year and it had several buyers interested but all had a poor credit and couldn't get a loan. I am looking to walk away from the property because I have too much on my plate currently. I am current on all payments as well. I need advice on what I should do to exit. Here is what I came up with:

  1. Putting it back on MLS

  2. Find a buyer to assume the FHA loan (buyer will need to clear $44,674.94 to assume)

  3. Hold

  4. Bankruptcy and Short Sale(not an option bc I don’t have delinquency)

Property and Mortgage Details

Appraised 2025: $315,000

Mortgage:

Purchased: 2022

Amount: $270,019.00

Loan: FHA

Principal Balance: $248,101.35

Interest Rate: 4.375%

Principal: $442.02

Interest: $906.15

Escrow Taxes and Insurance): $938.57

Monthly Payment: $1,949.70

Loan Maturity: 2052

Payment Supplement:

Payment Supplement

Start Date: October 2025

End Date: October 2028

Total Amount: $44,674.94

Monthly Payment after 10/28: $2,286.74

Property Description

Lot Size: 0.4 Acres

Zone: R3

Share city water

Electric: separate with Duke

Driveway: 2 separate entrances

Main Home:

3 Bed 2 Bath

1,711 Sqft

1925

Central Air, Window Unit

Privacy Fencing

Monthly Rent: $1,700/M

Detached Home:

1 Bed 1 Bath

738 Sqft

Attached Garage

Privacy Fencing

Monthly Rent: $875/M

1Reply
510 views

Most Popular Reply

Devin PetersonBusiness Member
Lender · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2022 · 2k+ posts · 699 votes
5d

Rebecca, sorry you went through that after Ian. Looking at your numbers, you may not be as underwater as it feels. $315k value vs about $248k on the first plus the $44.7k supplement is roughly $293k owed, so a straight sale is close to break-even once commissions and closing costs come out. Being current on payments keeps all your options open.

A few thoughts on each exit:

Assumption: that 4.375% rate is your selling point, so I'd market it that way on the MLS. Keep in mind FHA assumptions need the buyer approved by the servicer (credit and income) and they have to plan to live there, so it has to be an owner-occupant, not an investor. They'd also need cash for the gap between the price and the loan balance, plus the supplement, which is typically a separate HUD lien that gets paid off at sale or assumption (lines up with what you were told). Ask the servicer for a release of liability so you're fully off the loan.

Retail sale: poor-credit buyers were the problem last time. Since it's two separate rentals bringing about $2,575 a month, I'd also target investors. A DSCR loan qualifies the buyer on the property's rent instead of personal income, which can widen your buyer pool, though those loans usually need around 20-25% down and decent credit too.

Hold: rents vs a $1,950 payment cash flow on paper, but with a 1925 main house, vacancy, repairs, a property manager if you're stepping back, and the jump to about $2,287 after Oct 2028, the margin gets thin.

Before picking a path I'd run an updated CMA and get a payoff statement from the servicer showing both liens, so you know your exact net on a sale.

See this reply in the discussion

11 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Devin PetersonBusiness Member
    Lender · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2022 · 2k+ posts · 699 votes
    5d

    Rebecca, sorry you went through that after Ian. Looking at your numbers, you may not be as underwater as it feels. $315k value vs about $248k on the first plus the $44.7k supplement is roughly $293k owed, so a straight sale is close to break-even once commissions and closing costs come out. Being current on payments keeps all your options open.

    A few thoughts on each exit:

    Assumption: that 4.375% rate is your selling point, so I'd market it that way on the MLS. Keep in mind FHA assumptions need the buyer approved by the servicer (credit and income) and they have to plan to live there, so it has to be an owner-occupant, not an investor. They'd also need cash for the gap between the price and the loan balance, plus the supplement, which is typically a separate HUD lien that gets paid off at sale or assumption (lines up with what you were told). Ask the servicer for a release of liability so you're fully off the loan.

    Retail sale: poor-credit buyers were the problem last time. Since it's two separate rentals bringing about $2,575 a month, I'd also target investors. A DSCR loan qualifies the buyer on the property's rent instead of personal income, which can widen your buyer pool, though those loans usually need around 20-25% down and decent credit too.

    Hold: rents vs a $1,950 payment cash flow on paper, but with a 1925 main house, vacancy, repairs, a property manager if you're stepping back, and the jump to about $2,287 after Oct 2028, the margin gets thin.

    Before picking a path I'd run an updated CMA and get a payoff statement from the servicer showing both liens, so you know your exact net on a sale.

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 159 votes
    5d

    Hi Rebecca, I am sorry you went through all of that, and Devin gave you a solid framework to work from. Before you choose a path, I would get two things: a payoff statement from your servicer showing both liens, and an updated CMA from a local agent who knows your area. Those two numbers tell you what each exit actually nets you.

    Your 4.375% rate is the selling point if you go the assumption route, so it is worth marketing that way, and your two separate rents make the property interesting to an investor buyer as well. One thing to weigh on holding: your payment jumps to $2,286.74 after October 2028, so run the hold numbers at that payment, not today's, and be honest about reserves for a 1925 house. You are in a much stronger position deciding this while you are current on payments, so compare the real net on each option before you decide.

  • Aaron ZimmermanBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4d

    I would see if the loan can be assumed but also you should understand what that means from a lender for future purchases

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 281 posts · 144 votes
    4d

    Rebecca, Devin and Ametria covered the payoff and assumption mechanics well, so I'll add the Central Florida rental side, because that's what decides how attractive this is to your next buyer.

    Your best buyer is probably a house hacker. An FHA assumption needs an owner-occupant, and your layout is exactly what one wants: live in the 3/2 and rent the 1/1. In your marketing, lead with what that buyer's housing cost looks like with the cottage rented, not just the 4.375% rate. That's an easier story to sell than "two rentals."

    If either unit is leased right now, watch the timing. An owner-occupant buyer has to move in, so a 3/2 lease that runs well past your listing date can kill exactly the buyer the assumption needs. Line up the lease end dates with when you list.

    The 1/1 may be worth more as a furnished mid-term rental than at $875. Central Florida has steady 30+ day demand from travel nurses (you know that world better than most of us), insurance adjusters and contractors doing storm repairs, and work crews on longer jobs. Most of my units run on 30-day minimums for that demand. Check furnished 1-bedroom comps on monthly platforms near you first. Higher income on the cottage helps a buyer's numbers. But furnishing costs money and turnover means more work, so it only makes sense if a buyer or a manager will run it, not if you're trying to clear your plate.

    Since it used to be an STR, confirm what's allowed on that lot now, because it changes who your buyer is. Around Orlando the answer flips depending on which side of the city line you're on. Inside the City of Orlando, renting a whole home for under 30 days generally isn't allowed in residential zones; the residential option is home sharing, where the owner lives on site. Unincorporated Orange County allows single-family rentals under 30 days only in the R-3 district. You listed R3, so if your lot happens to be in unincorporated Orange, that could be a real selling point to an investor. Zoning labels don't carry over between jurisdictions, though, so check with your own city or county zoning office before you market it either way. Stays of 30+ days are generally treated as regular leases, which is a big reason mid-term works in places where short stays don't.

    If you hold, test the numbers at the 2028 payment of $2,286.74, not today's. $2,575 in rent leaves room on paper, but not much once you add management, repairs on a 1925 house and vacancy.

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    4d

    Is it rented now, and if not, why not? You said you bought it FHA as a house hack, so when did you move out of it? Why was it only rented for one year - was there a reason it went vacant and you didn't re-lease it?

    On paper it looks like you should be making a little bit of cash flow on it. Central Florida is a big area - where is it located?

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Rental Property Investor · Tallahassee, FL · Member since 2026 · 8 posts · 0 votes
    4d

    Here's how I'd lay it out side by side.

    Sell: $248,101 + $44,675 owed is about $292.8k. At $315k, 6% in costs is about $18.9k, so you'd net roughly $296k. That's around $3k left before prorations and repairs. You're a realtor, so listing it yourself is where the margin is.

    Hold: $1,700 + $875 is $2,575 in rent. Today that's $625 over the payment. After 10/2028 it's $288. Take out 5% vacancy and 10% for repairs on a 1925 house and the post-2028 number goes slightly negative, before any PM fee.

    So the hold only works if rents go up or you add value. The sale is close to a wash. If the real problem is time, put a property manager's fee into the hold math before you decide. If it still doesn't pencil, selling now beats selling in 2028 with a bigger payment.

    One more thing I'd check: 0.4 acres zoned R3. Ask the county what density that allows. If it allows more units, a small builder might pay more than an owner-occupant would.

    Rough screening numbers, not an appraisal.

  • Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 0 votes
    2d

    The real question is whether $288 a month covers a manager. That's your margin after Oct 2028: $2,575 rent minus the $2,286.74 payment, before vacancy or repairs on a 1925 house.

    A manager at 10% is about $258.

    Selling isn't much better: $315K minus $248,101 and the $44,675 supplement leaves $22,224, and 6 to 8% selling costs ($18,900 to $25,200) eat most of it.

    So ask the servicer for written payoffs on both liens, then price a manager. If one fits, holding may beat a near-zero sale.

  • Ryan BrownPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2022 · 140 posts · 46 votes
    2d

    Hey Rebecca, a property like this with a 4.375% rate is exactly what subject-to buyers look for, so expect some of them to reach out once you list. Subject-to means the buyer takes the deed and makes your payments, but the loan stays in your name. It can work for some sellers. In your situation, though, it has a specific problem that's worth knowing about before anyone pitches it to you.

    The HUD rider for the Payment Supplement says the supplement ends on any transfer of title, including the kinds of transfers that normally protect you from the due-on-sale clause. HUD's partial claim lien also becomes due when the property is sold or transferred. So the moment you deed the property to a sub-to buyer, the payment relief stops, the partial claim comes due, and the loan stays in your name. The rider also says that selling or transferring the property doesn't change your liability for repaying the supplement funds.

    That doesn't mean creative financing is off the table. It means any offer like that has to deal with the partial claim up front, and you'd want a real estate attorney to review it before you sign anything. If what you want is to walk away cleanly, a regular sale or an approved FHA assumption with a release of liability gets you there. A sub-to deal keeps you tied to the property.

  • Technology · Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 5 votes
    1d

    Rebecca, one thing nobody has raised yet is the homestead exemption, since you bought this as a house hack and later rented both units.

    As far as I know, in Florida the homestead exemption only covers the part of the property you live in as your permanent home. If you moved out and the parcel still shows homestead while both units were rented, the county property appraiser can go back up to 10 years and bill the missing tax plus a 50% penalty and 15% interest a year. Even while you lived in the 3/2, the rented 1/1 likely wasn't covered. I'd look up your parcel on your county property appraiser's site and see what it shows. If the exemption is still on there, it's worth a quick call with a Florida real estate attorney or CPA before you contact the appraiser.

    It also matters for the exits people laid out above:

    Hold: if the exemption comes off, the tax part of that $938 escrow goes up, so the post-2028 margin gets thinner than the numbers in this thread.

    Sell or assumption: the buyer's taxes reset toward market value the year after they buy, so the escrow on your statement isn't what they'll pay. An assuming buyer should run the 4.375% payment with the new tax so the deal doesn't fall apart late.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6h

    Staying current through a job loss and a partial payment plan is no small thing. Whichever exit you choose, the tax side is worth understanding before you list, because the two houses are treated differently. The detached 1/1 is a separate dwelling, so if you lived in the main house, the home sale exclusion can only apply to that part. To qualify, you need to have lived there two of the five years before the sale, which gives you up to three years after moving out. The rented portion has its own gain or loss, plus recapture on any depreciation taken.

    With a roughly $315K value against a 2022 purchase, the sale may end up close to breakeven after selling costs. A loss on your personal-use portion isn’t deductible, but a loss on the rental portion usually is. It’s generally treated as an ordinary loss rather than a capital one, which makes it more valuable, and selling the rental part also frees up any suspended passive losses. An assumption sale is taxed the same as a regular sale, so all of this applies either way. Get the purchase price allocated between the two houses so the gain or loss on each is clear.

    Feel free to DM me, I’d be happy to share a few resources that might help.

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.