Is Chicago Still a Good Market for Multifamily Investing in 2026?

Is Chicago Still a Good Market for Multifamily Investing in 2026?

Real Estate Coach · Chicago, IL · Member since 2020 · 172 posts · 66 votes

I've been investing in Chicago multifamily real estate for the past few years, primarily focusing on 2–4 unit properties, and I still think there are some great opportunities in this market.

A few things I've noticed recently:

  1. Rental demand is strong. Chicago continues to have solid rental demand, making cash flow achievable if you buy at the right price.

  2. Good deals are harder to find. Higher property prices, financing costs, and competition have made it more difficult to find properties that cash flow immediately.

  3. Property taxes are a major concern. Chicago's property taxes can completely change a deal's numbers. I've become much more conservative when underwriting expenses.

  4. Value-add opportunities are where I'm focusing. I'm particularly interested in properties where I can renovate units, increase rents, or potentially add units through ADUs.

Overall, I'm still bullish on Chicago multifamily, but I think being selective is more important than ever.

Curious what other investors think:

Are you still buying multifamily properties in Chicago? What neighborhoods are you targeting, and are property taxes making you reconsider investing here?

Would love to hear what everyone is seeing in the market.

2Reply
202 views

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Aaron ZimmermanBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2d

    The best way to make the numbers work is buying deeper and adding value. I’ve seen this work well time and again with my clients.

  • Lender · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 441 posts · 193 votes
    1d

    Agree that it remains a strong market - low inventory for several years now for both renters and buyers as demand persists. Based on the data we have, it looks as though this will continue for years to come. I've also owned across the country and have found more reliable tenants in Chicago. Perhaps this is due to midwestern values, or perhaps because this is the market I have roots in and know best. I'm bullish on the market and encouraging investors with integrity and know-how to keep it moving forward!

  • Jonathan KlemmBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Contractor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1d

    Hey @Micah White - Love seeing someone still bullish on Chicago 2-4 units, I'm right there with you! Yes, taxes are a big reason to go heavy on the value-add side. If you're opening up walls and pulling permits anyway, you can bring the MEPs up to code, push rents, and the numbers can carry a higher tax bill. I'd also underwrite taxes conservatively like you're doing, because the bill can jump after a reassessment.

  • Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1d

    I'm not buying any more in Chicago until it gets its financial house in order, reins in the Chicago Teachers Union, and fixes the Police Union.

    Reducing the Chicago City Counsel to 15 aldermen from the current 50 would be a HUGE step in the right direction. Right now everybody's triangulating the political and not the financial. Chicago can't afford to do that any more.

    The problem is that property taxes are potentially too variable, and with commercial buildings downtown cratering in value (stepping over the homeless at high noon with deserted streets is not a good sign), residential and small multi-family property taxes are the only real alternatives for the tax man.

    With businesses weak, that means jobs are iffy, and that hits rents. All of that is before you get tangled up in an impossible eviction system, too.

    I'll look at 1031 exchanges for easier-to-manage buildings and consolidate my position in Chicago, but there are very few opportunities that even remotely fit that category.

    I'm sure that finding out why the Chief Financial Officer's quitting for moral reasons won't help either.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Dhaka, Dhaka · Member since 2026 · 43 posts · 6 votes
    1d

    Micah, trying to make a 2–4 unit pencil out in Chicago off retail MLS prices—especially once Cook County tax reassessments hit is basically trying to swim upstream with bricks in your pockets!

    You nailed it on point #2: the only way value-add still works there is buying deep enough upfront (15–40%+ below live sub-market medians) before a property ever hits a bidding war. When we track off-market data across Chicago pockets, isolating distressed or fatigued listings with real equity cushion is usually what saves the cash flow from getting eaten alive by taxes.

    Are you mainly hunting specific South/West Side value-add pockets right now, or sourcing off-market deals across the broader Chicagoland metro?

  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    23h

    Chicago has been a great market for rent growth on the north side and I see that trend continuing because adding rental supply here is very expensive and difficult while demand for the units is strong. What works for my clients is buying 3 and 4 unit buildings good desirable areas, doing a cosmetic rehab + add in unit laundry, and then drastically increasing the rents to market rates which is surprisingly high. We often see rents double vs what they were listed at in MLS under less savvy ownership. I brokered a 3 unit a few months ago rents now up 50%. Just brokered a brick 4 at 820k by albany park that is the clients 4th deal and he plans to do the same recipe again. You definitely need to look at the deals goals over the long play and not just focus on gross rents when purchase off MLS day 1.

  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago · Member since 2021 · 183 posts · 65 votes
    22h

    Great post, and I agree on pretty much all of it. I'm a broker on the north side and invest myself, and I'm still bullish on Chicago 2 to 4 units. You just can't buy the way people did five years ago.

    On taxes, you're right to be conservative. The biggest mistake I see is investors underwriting with the seller's current tax bill. If the building hasn't been reassessed in a while, or if you're doing a big renovation, that number can change a lot. I underwrite with what I think the bill will be after the next reassessment, and I check the building's appeal history. A lot of owners never appeal, so sometimes there's money to be saved there too. It doesn't make me want to leave Chicago, but it's the line item that kills the most deals I look at.

    For neighborhoods, I spend most of my time on the Northwest Side: Irving Park, Avondale, Albany Park and Portage Park. You still get solid brick 2 and 3 flats, the renter pool is strong, and the prices haven't run up the way they have in Logan Square or North Center. The deals that work there usually need something: dated units, under-market rents, or an owner who's been in it for 30 years and hasn't kept up.

    That's why I agree value-add is where the opportunity is. Buildings that already cash flow on day one get bid up fast. The buildings that need work and have long-term tenants paying well below market are where you can still create real equity. Just budget plenty of time to get rents to market. You can't always do it all at once, and you'll need to treat existing tenants fairly.

    On ADUs, it's a big opportunity, but check the rules carefully before you count on that extra unit in your numbers. The city has opened up more areas for coach houses and garden units, but whether you can add one depends on the zoning and the specific location. And finishing out a basement unit legally usually costs more and takes longer than people think.

    Curious what you're seeing for cap rates and rents on the 2 to 4 unit stuff you've been looking at.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.