Real Estate Agent · Boise, ID · Member since 2017 · 617 posts · 391 votes
As someone who owns and self-manages rental properties here in the Treasure Valley, I thought I'd compare that to what I've personally experienced. Across five of my rentals, monthly rental income has increased 6%, or $665 per month. That's nearly $8,000 in additional annual rental income.
What's interesting is how those increases happened.
Two of my properties had tenant turnover between winter and summer. One increased 14.8% and the other 10.7%. I was able to take advantage of the stronger summer rental market when finding new tenants.
Another property saw a modest 2.4% increase, while my other two properties have long-term tenants whose rents have remained unchanged. I do plan to make adjustments to both next year when their leases come up for renewal.
It's encouraging to see rents moving in this direction, especially with the increases we've seen in property taxes, insurance, and maintenance costs over the past several years.
I'm curious what other investors are experiencing in their markets. Are you seeing similar increases, or are you having to offer concessions to get properties rented?
Full disclosure I work at Nomad so I don’t have my own rentals to compare, but it’s interesting that both of your big jumps came at turnover. That’s always the tradeoff since the gap between tenants is where it can go wrong.
Across about 2,275 turnovers on our end, the median was 30 days from move-out to move-in, but about 1 in 4 took 60+ days. So a 15% bump makes up for a month of vacancy in about 7 months, while a 2 to 3 month gap can eat most of the first year’s increase.
Curious if you’re planning to push the two long-term tenants up to market at renewal or keep it smaller to hold onto them?
That's an interesting metric that a lot of people can overlook. I guess this is something that a small efficient landlord with the proper systems can beat. Both of the properties were leased up with 0 vacancy, both of the tenants moved out prior to the leases being over and with the demand in this market we were able to secure a new tenant and have the lease start when the others ended. When they are up for renewal next year we will analyze the market and see what the numbers are telling us, we will likely increase smaller and keep it just below market to retain.
I do a lot of student rentals in upstate NY. There are pros and cons to that. Turnover is fairly consistent at 2 year lease terms but I’ve been able to increase rents very consistently as a result.
From 2025 to 2026, my portfolio is up 3.67% or $2,875/month. I’m currently resigning college students for 2027-28 (which is crazy). And I’m anticipating similar portfolio wide increases for 2026 to 2027. Not crazy numbers but consistency is king.
Those small tick ups are what allow us to save better for future needs. Have you found a sweet spot as to what the students will absorb without question?
My standing rule: I do not raise rents if students re-sign (helps me avoid excessive turnover each year). So I usually bump rents every 2 years approx $50 per kid. So a 3 bed unit bumps $150/month, a 4 bed unit bumps $200/month, 5 bed bumps $250, 6 bed, $300.
No one seems to bat an eye because the room and board are that much more expensive, my prices save them (and their parents) a ton of money.
Interesting enough I fled PDX for Boise, I used to live in Tigard. I have met a handful of folks that have moved to Boise or the surrounding areas that once lived in PDX. We get a lot of (COW's) California, Oregon, Washington people moving here for lifestyle, retirement, commutter folks just to name a few. With the Micron boom it has been a crazy year of influx. I have a client that works there as a supervisor and the last count he gave me was ~13k employees. It will be interesting to see what this does to the area and what happens when the construction ends (I am being told +/- 10 years) of the current build pace / employment level.