Seller-financed 2nd + DSCR first on two Ponca City, OK duplexes (4 units).

HaveFinancingRefinance
Classifieds

Seller-financed 2nd + DSCR first on two Ponca City, OK duplexes (4 units).

Investor · Grants Pass, OR · Member since 2020 · 45 posts · 13 votes

Does this structure make sense to you?

We own two side-by-side duplexes at 100 and 108 S Osage St in Ponca City, OK (Kay County). Each building has an upper unit on a long-term lease and a lower unit run as a furnished mid-term rental for refinery, wind and solar workers. They sit on separate parcels, so they can be sold together or one at a time.

We’ve been trying to refinance our extended construction loans, and the refi math is ugly. We’d bring a little over $20K to closing for a new ~$455K loan at around 9.875%. Interest alone on that is roughly $3,740 a month, and a 30-year amortizing payment would be about $3,950 a month (my estimate). That is close to all of the roughly $48,200 a year the properties produce. We’d be paying a lot to stay in a deal that barely cash flows after debt service.

So we’re looking at selling with a “stack” structure instead, and I’d like this group to poke holes in it. Here are the numbers at our original $550K asking price for both buildings:

  • Purchase price: $550,000

  • DSCR first mortgage (75% LTV): $412,500

  • Seller-financed 2nd (us): $80,000

  • Buyer cash in: $57,500

  • Cash to us at closing: about $470,000

  • Payoff on our existing loans: about $458,000

  • Cash left to us: about $12,000, before closing costs

  • Our $80K note at 7% interest-only pays about $467 a month, with principal due on a negotiated date

The buyer gets in with about 10.5% down instead of 25%, and the properties show roughly an 8.76% cap rate on current numbers. We’d clear our debt and convert $80K of equity into a performing, secured note. We’d even look at sharing closing costs with a qualified buyer if the numbers still work for us.

What we’re unsure about, and where I’d like your experience:

  1. Do DSCR lenders in your market allow a seller-carried 2nd behind their first? Which ones, and what combined LTV do they cap at? This structure puts the buyer at about 89.5% combined.

  2. What do you want on a seller 2nd? Would you subordinate, require a balloon, or insist on a personal guarantee or cross-collateralization? What interest rate would you ask for?

  3. Has anyone had a lender balk at a down payment that was borrowed or covered by short-term funds? We want everything fully disclosed to the lender and title, with nothing hidden.

  4. If you’re a buyer, would you take this deal at $550K, or what price and terms make it attractive?

  5. Has anyone marketed seller financing up front and seen it bring in better buyers? We’ve had plenty of tire-kickers and very few serious ones.

We’re open to offers and to structure ideas, and we’ll share the P&Ls, leases and photos with serious buyers. Our loans have matured, so we’re motivated to get this resolved quickly. Comment here or send us a message.

1Reply
241 views

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2026 · 66 posts · 13 votes
    2d

    Hi Sally, good question. Some DSCR lenders allow a seller-carried 2nd, but it depends on the program and the combined LTV. I'm a mortgage broker; if you keep the buildings, I can look at a DSCR or bridge refi to take out the construction loans, and I can help a future buyer line up financing too. What's the current payoff, and are all four units leased? – Stephen

  • Erik EstradaBusiness Member
    Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2d

    Sally, the hard part is the 89.5% combined LTV. Most DSCR programs either don't allow a seller-carried 2nd on a purchase or cap the combined LTV around 80-85%, so at 75/14.5/10.5 most will decline it as written.

    A few other things DSCR underwriting will catch:

    • Borrowed down payment. The buyer's funds generally must be their own and sourced. Unsecured borrowed money for the down payment is usually a no.

    • The 2nd payment. Some lenders count the seller note's payment in the DSCR, and an interest-only balloon note may need a minimum term.

    • Mid-term furnished units. Many DSCR lenders use long-term market rent from the appraiser (the 1007), not your furnished mid-term income, so the DSCR could come in lower than your P&L shows.

    • Subordination. The 2nd has to be fully subordinate to the first and recorded, and disclosed to the lender and title like you said.

    A structure more lenders will take is a 75% first, a 5-10% seller 2nd, and the buyer putting down 15-20%. Two separate parcels also give a buyer the option to finance one duplex at a time.

    LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
  • Lender · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2024 · 75 posts · 19 votes
    2d

    Refinancing a tight deal like that can squeeze the numbers fast. We arrange DSCR financing through Royal Partners and can guide you on the cleanest route. We have several other options available as well. DM us if you want a hand with it, or email us more details at [email protected].

  • Lender · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2026 · 30 posts · 20 votes
    2d

    Sally, Erik covered what the buyer's lender will push back on, so here's the seller side, since you'd be the one sitting in second.

    • Record the note and mortgage, and get the subordination agreement in front of the first lender early. Many DSCR lenders use their own form and won't give you notice of default or a right to cure, so ask.

    • Require taxes and insurance to be escrowed with the first. If those lapse, your collateral is at risk before your payment ever goes late.

    • Set the balloon at or beyond the first lender's minimum term, and add a due-on-sale and a cross-default to your note, so a default on the first is a default on yours.

    • Keep cash set aside. If the buyer stops paying the first, curing it to protect your $80K is on you.

    Before you decide to sell, get one more refi quote from a local bank that keeps its loans in-house, on both parcels together, with 12 months of bank statements showing the mid-term income. Some of those banks will count that income when a DSCR lender won't. Have you priced selling one duplex and refinancing the other?

  • Devin PetersonBusiness Member
    Lender · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2022 · 2k+ posts · 701 votes
    1d

    Sally, on a $550K purchase with a $412,500 DSCR first (75% LTV), an $80K seller second, and $57,500 down (~89.5% CLTV), many DSCR lenders will not allow subordinate seller financing on a purchase at all. Programs that do usually cap combined LTV well below ~90% and still require the buyer to bring a minimum down payment from their own funds—not borrowed.

    Disclose the note in the purchase contract up front so appraisal and title reflect it. The second must be fully subordinate, often with a minimum term (no balloon inside a few years), and its payment is frequently counted in DSCR. At ~$467/month interest-only plus the first, that can push DSCR under 1.0 on a 4-unit.

    Alternatives to compare: a larger buyer down payment with a smaller carry-back; seller carrying first or full seller finance with the buyer refinancing later; or a carry-back recorded after a seasoning period—but never hide a later note from the lender.

  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 263 posts · 99 votes
    1d

    Hi Sally, thank you for laying the whole picture out so plainly. From the buyer side, the first thing I look at is whether the first lender has approved the second in writing, and whether the P and L and the leases are complete and match what was shared. That paper trail is what tells me if it can actually close. I am still learning this side of it, so I appreciate you sharing it this openly.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.