Seller-financed 2nd + DSCR first on two Ponca City, OK duplexes (4 units).
Does this structure make sense to you?
We own two side-by-side duplexes at 100 and 108 S Osage St in Ponca City, OK (Kay County). Each building has an upper unit on a long-term lease and a lower unit run as a furnished mid-term rental for refinery, wind and solar workers. They sit on separate parcels, so they can be sold together or one at a time.
We’ve been trying to refinance our extended construction loans, and the refi math is ugly. We’d bring a little over $20K to closing for a new ~$455K loan at around 9.875%. Interest alone on that is roughly $3,740 a month, and a 30-year amortizing payment would be about $3,950 a month (my estimate). That is close to all of the roughly $48,200 a year the properties produce. We’d be paying a lot to stay in a deal that barely cash flows after debt service.
So we’re looking at selling with a “stack” structure instead, and I’d like this group to poke holes in it. Here are the numbers at our original $550K asking price for both buildings:
Purchase price: $550,000
DSCR first mortgage (75% LTV): $412,500
Seller-financed 2nd (us): $80,000
Buyer cash in: $57,500
Cash to us at closing: about $470,000
Payoff on our existing loans: about $458,000
Cash left to us: about $12,000, before closing costs
Our $80K note at 7% interest-only pays about $467 a month, with principal due on a negotiated date
The buyer gets in with about 10.5% down instead of 25%, and the properties show roughly an 8.76% cap rate on current numbers. We’d clear our debt and convert $80K of equity into a performing, secured note. We’d even look at sharing closing costs with a qualified buyer if the numbers still work for us.
What we’re unsure about, and where I’d like your experience:
Do DSCR lenders in your market allow a seller-carried 2nd behind their first? Which ones, and what combined LTV do they cap at? This structure puts the buyer at about 89.5% combined.
What do you want on a seller 2nd? Would you subordinate, require a balloon, or insist on a personal guarantee or cross-collateralization? What interest rate would you ask for?
Has anyone had a lender balk at a down payment that was borrowed or covered by short-term funds? We want everything fully disclosed to the lender and title, with nothing hidden.
If you’re a buyer, would you take this deal at $550K, or what price and terms make it attractive?
Has anyone marketed seller financing up front and seen it bring in better buyers? We’ve had plenty of tire-kickers and very few serious ones.
We’re open to offers and to structure ideas, and we’ll share the P&Ls, leases and photos with serious buyers. Our loans have matured, so we’re motivated to get this resolved quickly. Comment here or send us a message.