I have seen identical properties next to each other with one producing $63k and the other $140k and the only difference is who is managing it (including self managers).

It's about a dozen, identical one bedroom "modern" cabins that sleep 6.

I was checking some nums, and Calif is tracking identical to Italy in same time frame or stage.

No, material costs sit nearly identical.

Come to find out this guy was a legit guy, but his company identity had been stolen and the "person" I was dealing with was using all of his personal and business info. 

Most of my buildings are identical to this, but make apx $160/m/door profit, so I'm having difficulty seeing how you are getting ~2x the profit from effectively the same buildings. 

I’m closing on a duplex in a couple weeks that is an identical duplex to the one I bought last December.

Competition is high, but in reality, we're on a trajectory to look almost identical to Denver and Austin...i.e. everything in this city is sitting at 50% of value considering a 20-year hold = wealth.

More bluntly, if Zillow's algorithm lines up identically with an appraisal, well, it's more luck than anything else.  

That would give you an identical list but of just those with phones.