Advice on Possible Off-Market Sale in San Antonio

Advice on Possible Off-Market Sale in San Antonio

AL · Member since 2019 · 1 post · 0 votes

My husband and I bought a new construction house in 2022 in the far west side of San Antonio and after only 1 year we got orders to PCS (we are military). We've held onto the house as a rental but, after assessing our long-term family priorities, have decided we don't want to keep this house. Our tenants just renewed and are committed through April 2027. I am a novice "investor" (clearly just fell into it) - is it possible for me to do an off-market sale to another investor that could just assume the lease with our current tenants? If anyone has done this before, would love to understand:

- how did you market this? are there websites for this type of thing? 

- did both parties use an agent and what type of fees did they charge? 

- what would communication / disruption to my current tenants look like? 

The reality is I can just wait for the tenants to vacate and then put the house on the market but figured since I have ~1 year (and they are really easy tenants) I could try and find a niche buyer in the meantime. Really appreciate any advice!

0Reply
187 views

Investor-friendly agents in San Antonio, TX

See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in San Antonio, TX.

Most Popular Reply

Wholesaler, Rehabber and Landlord · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
7mo

If the tenants are easy to deal with, I would just wait until they do not want to lease again. If they plan on staying, increase the rent a bit. Keep them another year. Keep them there until they want to leave. THEN put it on the market. The market is not the greatest right now. Interest rates have gone up a bit, LOTS of inventory of newer homes.

To get the best price on a sale, I would go with a realtor. You are exposing the house to many more people. Again, do this after the people get out.

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Flipper/Rehabber · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2018 · 18 posts · 2 votes
    7mo

    Yes it is possible to sell directly to investor with a tenant in Place. I invest in SA. Feel free to reach out

  • San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 7 posts · 1 vote
    7mo

    I can help you with this I know a guy with experience buying like this and would love to help you find an investor shoot me a text 9036505077

  • Wholesaler, Rehabber and Landlord · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7mo

    If the tenants are easy to deal with, I would just wait until they do not want to lease again. If they plan on staying, increase the rent a bit. Keep them another year. Keep them there until they want to leave. THEN put it on the market. The market is not the greatest right now. Interest rates have gone up a bit, LOTS of inventory of newer homes.

    To get the best price on a sale, I would go with a realtor. You are exposing the house to many more people. Again, do this after the people get out.

  • Realtor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2023 · 286 posts · 42 votes
    6mo

    - how did you market this? are there websites for this type of thing?

    Yes. There are 1,000s of ways to market your property as is. Video photo content, signage, where ever you can break through the noise! Very dynamic process. Not something you will be able to do on your own time, if your objective is to let go of the property fast. 
    There are multiple firms and brokerages with their own respective public and off market listings either attainable on their business website or independent marketplace systems already in place ready to solve your SOLD.

    - did both parties use an agent and what type of fees did they charge?

    Traditional listing agent will want to charge you 3% - 6% to help you cut through the noise based on their respective specialties. Professionals in the off market arena will help you close FAST with cash wired to you at closing, and leave it to buyer to cover the respective closing cost.

    You can elect as the seller to help cover buyer's closing cost as an incentive to appeal to more buyers, or have buyer cover your closing cost. Title service is a part of that, and TX title policy is dependent on the agreed price.

    - what would communication / disruption to my current tenants look like?

    Hardly none. The arrangement will involve collecting your existing lease agreement copies and disclosing to prospective ready-buyers. It will be the buyer's responsibility to honor the leaseback following closing. Important thing for you is to get it SOLD and make enough over whatever dollar amount you owe on the property.

  • Real Estate Agent · Temple, TX · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 700 votes
    6mo

    The "wait until tenants don't renew" advice ignores that you're military and a second PCS can wipe out the timing window entirely. Off-market sale to an investor with the lease assumed is real and it works — the buyer pool is just smaller and you give up some price. What an investor actually pays for a tenant-occupied SFH on a 12-month lease is usually 92-96% of vacant comps, because they're trading market exposure for instant cash flow and no make-ready. If your house comps at $325K vacant, expect $300-310K from a serious investor. The websites that work forthis are Roofstock and the BP Marketplace, but the better path is local — post in the closest active investor-focused FB group and price it 3-4% under the last sold comp on your street. You'll get 2-4 offers in a week. On agents: list-side fee is negotiable on a tenant-occupied off-market because there's no MLS exposure work. 1-1.5% is fair if the agent is just papering the contract. Buyer agent will still expect 2.5-3% unless the buyer's a direct investor with no agent.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.