Real Estate Agent · Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2022 · 88 posts · 74 votes
I'm Marco Fiore, a multifamily investment specialist with eXp Realty based right here in Cincinnati. I work exclusively with real estate investors and I live and breathe this market daily. I have access to both on and off-market deals across all price points and I'm always happy to share deal flow, run numbers, or just talk Cincinnati real estate with fellow investors.
Not here to pitch anyone — just genuinely love talking shop with people who are in the trenches of this market like I am.
Drop your thoughts below — I read and respond to every comment. Let's build something useful here for the Cincinnati investing community. 👇
I don't see how small deals 2-12 doors) can cash flow a reasonable ROI based on prices and mortgage rates for a stabilized project. I see door prices for anything nice at ~120-160k. Ohio real property tax is confiscatory. It is increased to sale price. And rents for those units at 900-1200. I don't think that works. If the units can be increased or upgraded they may work but if you use real world numbers for vacancies and costs I am not seeing it.
Hi @Marco Fiore, great to meet you. Always good to see brokers who are actively in the trenches with investors instead of just sitting on the listing side.
From a lender’s perspective, Cincinnati has been an interesting multifamily market because it sits in that middle tier where:
pricing is still relatively accessible compared to coastal markets
but underwriting has tightened significantly with today’s debt costs
The deals that are actually getting financed right now are the ones that:
still show DSCR coverage at today's rates (not pro forma rates)
have realistic rent comps (not aggressive “post-renovation optimism”)
include reserves for taxes, insurance, and capex—not just purchase and rehab
One thing I’m seeing consistently in lending is that investors who can source true off-market or lightly marketed deals with operational upside are the ones getting the best leverage and terms.
Cincinnati in particular still has pockets where:
small-to-mid multifamily (5–25 units) pencils better than larger assets
value-add opportunities exist with mom-and-pop ownership
and refinance exits are still viable if basis is strong going in
Curious what you’re seeing on your side—are most of your buyers still targeting value-add plays, or shifting more toward stabilized cash-flowing assets given where rates are today?
I don't see how small deals 2-12 doors) can cash flow a reasonable ROI based on prices and mortgage rates for a stabilized project. I see door prices for anything nice at ~120-160k. Ohio real property tax is confiscatory. It is increased to sale price. And rents for those units at 900-1200. I don't think that works. If the units can be increased or upgraded they may work but if you use real world numbers for vacancies and costs I am not seeing it.
I don't see how small deals 2-12 doors) can cash flow a reasonable ROI based on prices and mortgage rates for a stabilized project. I see door prices for anything nice at ~120-160k. Ohio real property tax is confiscatory. It is increased to sale price. And rents for those units at 900-1200. I don't think that works. If the units can be increased or upgraded they may work but if you use real world numbers for vacancies and costs I am not seeing it.
Yeah it's super tight right now. I think this is the first time ever i've had more active in state than out of state clients. I still see things that work for out of state clients at times, but it's RARE in Cincinnati
Being in the trenches is what it is all about! Some agents hate being on the buy side but I think it is much more fun. There are deals to be had and they are out there. Buyers are definitely being more cautious in this market.