Should I sell my single-family rental that's up 30%?

Should I sell my single-family rental that's up 30%?

Real Estate Agent · El Segundo, CA · Member since 2016 · 2 posts · 0 votes

I own a single family home in El Segundo, CA (Los Angeles) that I purchased 3 years ago.  I lived in it for 2 years as my primary residence and have been renting it for one year.  It currently rents for enough to cover it's costs and has a great note of 3.75%.  I'm not really making anything on it.  I purchased the property for $815,000 and I believe I could sell it for $1,150,000.  My plan was always to buy, hold and rent, but with this amount of gain, the uncertainty of the current market, and the $500,000 tax exemption (married), I'm very tempted to sell and take the tax free cash.

I like the idea of having the cash in hand, especially if the market turns, to pick up another investment (ideally multi-family). But, I also like the BRRRR strategy.

What would you do?

0Reply
39 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2017 · 453 posts · 254 votes
    9y

    @Tommy Ostendorf I think you have to really look at if as how you value your time. If you're able to rent it out to where you have cash flow of say at least $200 I personally would keep it. But if it just is not possible to get it to cash flow then you have to look at it from a point of view of what you want. Would you like short term cash with a 30% profit, or would you rather hold it for 27 more years and have it cash flowing very nicely during your retirement. Taking a profit never hurt anyone but it is all about your goals and how you value your time. If it is causing you just to break even on the bills and not even allowing you to build up a reserve for future cap expenses then I would be more inclined to sell and try to get a multifamily property that will cash flow for me now and even more so in the future. hope that helps. 

  • Investor · Hampton, VA · Member since 2017 · 49 posts · 86 votes
    9y

    It depends on what you mean by "enough to cover it's costs." If you own this property for the next ten to fifteen years then you're going to run into larger cost than just the mortgage payment. In that time you will probably have to replace or do major repair to the HVAC system. You'll probably have at least one major plumbing issue to repair. You also have turnover cost between tenants (repainting, cleaning, etc.) and the time commitment of qualifying tenants every time you have a vacancy. If you're including all of these cost and the rent is still enough to cover them than I might hold onto it. But if you're not I would sell and try to make a better buy with investment returns in mind. I know when I bought my house to live in I thought nothing about it's investment potential.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.