Everyone thinks they know the best places to invest, Ca, the south east, Cincinnati, your back yard...
But, there is NO city that I hear more contention on than the city of Chicago. The third coast has ample opportunity...and haters. As one of the 20 Amazon finalists we need to re-examine the question, "Chicago, STUD or dud?"
See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in Chicago, IL.
See agentsThere's a lot to like about Chicago, but the tenant friendly laws and high taxes scare many people off. However, Chicago is Chicago. The 3rd largest city in the country. And major employers like McDonalds and Dyson moved into the city (not the burbs, the city). While I agree with a lot of points from @Mike H. (facts are facts), I will call out that Kraft Heinz, ADM, Motorola and the golden arches all moved to Chicago recently.
Young people, especially across the midwest aspire to live in this city and I don't see that changing anytime soon. Summertime Chi is the best city in the country (if not the world), but winters are brutal and the south and west sides have stretches of blight, violence and a lack of hope.
The city is a "choose your own adventure" with plenty of opportunities, blended with many challenges. It's not a stud or a dud, it's anything and everything. It's not as dire or rosy as many want you to believe.
it's a stud. The inventory is extremely dry right now. Not many good deals and a ton of people in the industry are selling junk. But there is some opportunities out there they are just very hard to find. It takes a lot of digging around to find a decent property that can have a good cash on cash return. As far as flipping......a lot of the homes I have seen have needed way too much rehab and or the price is too high from the seller(owner, REO, HUD,etc.....) so yeah it's still a great city to invest in if your not listening to the news and other propaganda. The taxes are ridiculous and need to come down but some properties still cash flow or can be flipped if the DOM and ROI is good. Also Northwest Indiana is a extension of Chicago and has a plethora of opportunities as well but again the problem is the inventory.
Stud! I agree though, you still need to get either a great deal, or an irreplaceable location with tremendous upside...
Meghan, great question. It's ironic because many NY & CA investors are buying deals for 2-4 CAPs at $500 to $2,000 per square foot in their markets, and our MOST expensive deals in Chicago are $300-$400/SF, maybe $500, but many B & C class deals are in the $60-$150/SF range... YES, there are market, tenant, and operational challenges/red tape, but overall, this gives an ability to increase rents after renovation!
In secondary and tertiary markets with no employment growth and low total population numbers, it's possible those property values may not be able to receive very much forced appreciation of value through unit renovation... For example, a Chicagoland property with $800 rents, non-renovated, could potentially derive $1,100 renovated, thus a $300 rent pop, per unit. This same-sized unit in a tertiary market may only be renting for $600 and after renovation could rent for $700...
On a 6-unit building:
$100 * 12 months of rent = $1,200 additional rent * 6 units = $7,200 = at a 7.5% cap is $96,000 in increased value/forced appreciation, where as:
$300 * 12 months = $3,600 additional rent * 6 units = $21,600 at a 7.5% cap is $288,000 in increased value/forced appreciation.
ADDITIONALLY:
In the city of Chicago, there are approx. 77 neighborhoods... There are about 15-20 which are potentially overvalued right now, depending on who you ask and the product type... Intrinsic values for the rest may not even be close to reaching their full potential. This isn't even including the suburbs, there is tremendous potential in the second city/third coast, IMO.
STUD! If you know how to handle a stud.
Cash flow areas of the south side are still selling well below the 2007 market highs although many other areas are at or above 2007 values. Further, as the murder capital and top foreclosure area from 2007, the values are as much artificially depressed now as values were artificially buoyed back at that time. Last, I have been a personal witness to areas of Chicago go from zero to hero and its not over!
Stud!!! "Chicago tops the list as the most affordable metro... It's is the only metro in the country where typical renters spend less than 20% of their annual income on housing."
I guess if you're comparing investing in Chicago to say the coasts, then maybe you could argue its a stud.
But if you were to name the top 5 or 6 areas in the country to invest in and then list your criteria, the Chicago/Illinois market would be the absolute worst of the bunch.
1) Financial condition - worst state in the country.
The city, county and the state are all in a world of hurt from a finance standpoint. This state has so overpromised on pensions to the govt unions workers, that there is no way under the sun, we're going to be able to meet those without additional increases in property taxes.
2) Property taxes are the #1 highest in the metro areas.
The only reason we're stated to be #2 is because we have all the areas down south with lower taxes. I've got houses in numerous towns across 4 counties. I've got a house assessed at 100k where the tax rate is over 6%. Technically its like 19% but Illinois does some crazy 1/3 thing to market values. So for simplicity sake, the rate is over 6% of market value. Go run your rental profits on those numbers.
And its not getting better - its getting worse. That was an early purchase in a not so great area. But I've got some in small towns in really nice areas and the tax rates in those are almost at 5% too. 5% on 150k house. Again, try running your rental profits on those numbers. Those rates are not going down - they're going up.
3) Lack of Population Growth. Chicago metro is one of the worst cities in the country for population growth over the last 5 years. I think it may have even been dead last.
4) Jobs. Illinois is an impossible position in terms of getting companies to come here. I saw it was listed on amazon's 20. But that was for show. No company in their right mind is coming here. Property taxes. Workman's comp rates. Business and personal income taxes. They're all fairly high and getting worse. And we're still not seeing a light at the end of the tunnel in terms of being out of the mess.
There's a reason that foxconn went up to southern wisconsin. They wanted to be close to chicago to poach some employees. But they did not want to be IN chicago or Illinois.
As it is, we're seeing a lot of companies jumping over the border to Indiana. Better taxes. Better home prices. Better business
5) Landlord laws. This is county specific. But Cook county may be one of the top 5 worst counties in the country for landlord laws. Evictions can take 4 to 6 months easy. If you can sneeze, you can come up with a delay for an eviction hearing. Sheriff's dept is the biggest bottleneck. Even if you get a quick possession order, the sheriff's dept is running 6 to 10 weeks out from actually getting the order to getting tenants out.
So are there areas in Chicago or Illinois where it makes sense to invest? Yes. Definitely. I think there are areas just about anywhere that make sense to invest - provided you're getting a great deal. But in terms of whether Chicago/Illinois is a stud or dud overall? Its an absolute piece of smelly MUD when you compare it to some of the other places to invest.
And we haven't even started on the crime in the south and west sides of the city that are eventually going to move out further and further as well. Just had one of the bloodiest weekends in years for murders.
Article in the Tribune just this week: More than 30 shot, 6 fatally, in most violent weekend of 2018
Mike,
I agree to a point. But there are quite a few cities that are well worth investing in. We sell investors sfr's in a southern suburb of Chicago. Taxes are reasonable, rents are very high and there's a high demand for rental properties. We also do business in Northwest, Indiana. I don't know of one city in Indiana that can match the cash on cash return we get our investors in Illinois. We get them 12% and as high as 15.5%. That Includes costs like maintenance, taxes, vacancy etc. So all of Illinois isn't a "dud." You just have to know where to look.
Stud and dud. There are areas that are really bad and have little to no hope of getting better, population in those neighborhoods are declining and the housing stock is bad. Then there are areas that are growing and doing really well, but still affordable to buy and rent and last you have areas that are way too expensive to both buy and rent.
There's a lot to like about Chicago, but the tenant friendly laws and high taxes scare many people off. However, Chicago is Chicago. The 3rd largest city in the country. And major employers like McDonalds and Dyson moved into the city (not the burbs, the city). While I agree with a lot of points from @Mike H. (facts are facts), I will call out that Kraft Heinz, ADM, Motorola and the golden arches all moved to Chicago recently.
Young people, especially across the midwest aspire to live in this city and I don't see that changing anytime soon. Summertime Chi is the best city in the country (if not the world), but winters are brutal and the south and west sides have stretches of blight, violence and a lack of hope.
The city is a "choose your own adventure" with plenty of opportunities, blended with many challenges. It's not a stud or a dud, it's anything and everything. It's not as dire or rosy as many want you to believe.
I think that right now it's too early to make that decision. In the winter months it's a dud. Inventory is dry and prices are high. All of the rental properties are tied down and there's no new construction projects opening their doors to tenants (they doesn't typically open up till the summer). If you really want to know the answer, wait until May or June when the market gets a new 'hit' of apartment complexes all over the city. That's when you'll see thousands more rental flood the market. If there's too much inventory management companies will start incentivizing with free TV's, free rent, and whatnot. If there's not enough inventory, the market will climb higher. In my opinion, after seeing the population decline in Chicago for the first time in a very long time, I think the rental market will flatten or even dip due to the lack of people to fill the spaces. Population levels are below 1990 levels but the builders keep on building! I think you'll see more opportunity in renovating than anything else. Interesting conversation though! Thanks for bringing up the discussion
This question seems to get asked once a week here on BP :). It's all based on personal preference. I invest here, I like investing here, and as long as I can keep finding deals I will continue to invest here. A town like Chicago requires patience however. Like Elbert Dockery said up above, it is DRY. Hard to find good flips, hard to find good MU's, hard to find homes for buyers as a Realtor! But with patience and a lot of grunt work you can definitely find good deals and they are definitely worth looking for.
Yes. Several companies moved to Chicago. But all of those companies were already in Illinois. I think the city does have a shot at luring some of the suburbia companies there just because the execs think they can get more workers if they're based downtown - even though it means crazy commutes for their workers.
Where I believe Illinois and Chicago have an extremely difficult problem is in luring jobs from other areas. And far more companies are leaving the state and very few if any are actually relocating here.
Can anybody name a decent sized company that has moved to Illinois in the last 3 or 4 years? I sure can't. I can name a couple that have left though. And its not just companies - its people too. People are leaving the city and the state in droves. Thats when things for investors can get even worse.......
Again, I'm not saying investors can't make money here in Illinois or can't build a portfolio of rentals that do ok. But I don't see how anybody in their right mind can advocate that any area in Illinois would make for a good investment when comparing them to some of the other areas in the country.
If you said is Chicago better than LA to buy and hold rentals? That may be a yes.
But if you were to ask whether it makes sense to invest in Illinois over a handful of other more landlord friendly areas, I would say absolutely not. There is not a single thing to like about Illinois for investors in terms of any of the indicators one would typically use.
The only possible saving grace is that the price to rent ratios are reasonable here. But when you add up taxes and tenant friendly laws in some counties here, you're losing money.
Here's a good article from 2015 and its only gotten worse since then:
Friday, 14 August 2015
Trickle of Companies Leaving Illinois Turning Into a Flood
Here's another:
STILL LEAVING ILLINOIS: AN EXODUS OF PEOPLE AND MONEY
By J. Scott Moody
Jan 3, 2017 - Michael Lucci
MOVING OUT: ILLINOIS HAS COUNTRY’S WORST OUTBOUND RATE IN 2016
@Mike H. Agree wholeheartedly. I believe Chicago is still Chicago (3rd largest metro, densely populated, tourist destination, and an abundance of small multifamily properties). There are going to be opportunities to make money. I am much less optimistic about the state of Illinois as a whole for all the reasons you mentioned.
It's imperative that Chicago and the state begin to attract new companies and stimulate economic and population growth.
Yes. Several companies moved to Chicago. But all of those companies were already in Illinois. I think the city does have a shot at luring some of the suburbia companies there just because the execs think they can get more workers if they're based downtown - even though it means crazy commutes for their workers.
Where I believe Illinois and Chicago have an extremely difficult problem is in luring jobs from other areas. And far more companies are leaving the state and very few if any are actually relocating here.
Can anybody name a decent sized company that has moved to Illinois in the last 3 or 4 years? I sure can't. I can name a couple that have left though. And its not just companies - its people too. People are leaving the city and the state in droves. Thats when things for investors can get even worse.......
Again, I'm not saying investors can't make money here in Illinois or can't build a portfolio of rentals that do ok. But I don't see how anybody in their right mind can advocate that any area in Illinois would make for a good investment when comparing them to some of the other areas in the country.
If you said is Chicago better than LA to buy and hold rentals? That may be a yes.
But if you were to ask whether it makes sense to invest in Illinois over a handful of other more landlord friendly areas, I would say absolutely not. There is not a single thing to like about Illinois for investors in terms of any of the indicators one would typically use.
The only possible saving grace is that the price to rent ratios are reasonable here. But when you add up taxes and tenant friendly laws in some counties here, you're losing money.
Here's a good article from 2015 and its only gotten worse since then:
Friday, 14 August 2015
Trickle of Companies Leaving Illinois Turning Into a Flood
Here's another:
STILL LEAVING ILLINOIS: AN EXODUS OF PEOPLE AND MONEY
By J. Scott Moody
Jan 3, 2017 - Michael Lucci
MOVING OUT: ILLINOIS HAS COUNTRY’S WORST OUTBOUND RATE IN 2016
Houston is quickly replacing Chicago, Pennsylvania has replaced Illinois in population as well. Everyone here has some really good points, I also dare to ask the question if the rest of the state continues to fail how will Chicago stand?
....with our head held high and our middle finger raised in the air like a true Chicagoan
Yes. Several companies moved to Chicago. But all of those companies were already in Illinois. I think the city does have a shot at luring some of the suburbia companies there just because the execs think they can get more workers if they're based downtown - even though it means crazy commutes for their workers.
Where I believe Illinois and Chicago have an extremely difficult problem is in luring jobs from other areas. And far more companies are leaving the state and very few if any are actually relocating here.
Can anybody name a decent sized company that has moved to Illinois in the last 3 or 4 years? I sure can't. I can name a couple that have left though. And its not just companies - its people too. People are leaving the city and the state in droves. Thats when things for investors can get even worse.......
Again, I'm not saying investors can't make money here in Illinois or can't build a portfolio of rentals that do ok. But I don't see how anybody in their right mind can advocate that any area in Illinois would make for a good investment when comparing them to some of the other areas in the country.
If you said is Chicago better than LA to buy and hold rentals? That may be a yes.
But if you were to ask whether it makes sense to invest in Illinois over a handful of other more landlord friendly areas, I would say absolutely not. There is not a single thing to like about Illinois for investors in terms of any of the indicators one would typically use.
The only possible saving grace is that the price to rent ratios are reasonable here. But when you add up taxes and tenant friendly laws in some counties here, you're losing money.
Here's a good article from 2015 and its only gotten worse since then:
Friday, 14 August 2015
Trickle of Companies Leaving Illinois Turning Into a Flood
Here's another:
STILL LEAVING ILLINOIS: AN EXODUS OF PEOPLE AND MONEY
By J. Scott Moody
Jan 3, 2017 - Michael Lucci
MOVING OUT: ILLINOIS HAS COUNTRY’S WORST OUTBOUND RATE IN 2016
Houston is quickly replacing Chicago, Pennsylvania has replaced Illinois in population as well. Everyone here has some really good points, I also dare to ask the question if the rest of the state continues to fail how will Chicago stand?
Chicago and IL are not growing and that should be concerning, but it's not doom and gloom. Most Midwest cities lost massive population 20-30 years ago and Chicago was able to stay strong. Unlike most of those other cities, Chicago has an appeal that no other city can touch and I'd argue Summertime Chi is the best city in the country. Ultimately, Chicago needs job creation and tax reform to help turnaround some of the population trends.
@John Casmon @Todd Dexheimer @Brie Schmidt @Mike H. @Elbert D. I recognize each of you as local experts in the Chicago area as I’ve read many of your posts on BP and I always appreciate your input. I’ve read and heard a few times that certain areas in the Chicago MSA are seeing big population declines while other areas are growing and doing very well. Can you list some of the areas that are experiencing solid population growth? My good friend @Shane Barker and I have been analyzing various potential rental properties for the last few months but don’t want to pull the trigger on an area that’s declining.
Chicago is NOT declining...last number I heard was 55 cranes actively building in Chicago. Vacancy rate remains low. The south side is rip roaring hot along with some of the fringe west side neighborhoods. The trend seems to be a small exodus from the southside in poorer neighborhoods to the burbs because of schools being shut down and the gentrification (I'm sorry...there's a whole foods in Englewood....IN ENGLEWOOD!!!!!) This leads me to see growth and a greater urban spread of development.
Yes. Several companies moved to Chicago. But all of those companies were already in Illinois. I think the city does have a shot at luring some of the suburbia companies there just because the execs think they can get more workers if they're based downtown - even though it means crazy commutes for their workers.
Where I believe Illinois and Chicago have an extremely difficult problem is in luring jobs from other areas. And far more companies are leaving the state and very few if any are actually relocating here.
Can anybody name a decent sized company that has moved to Illinois in the last 3 or 4 years? I sure can't. I can name a couple that have left though. And its not just companies - its people too. People are leaving the city and the state in droves. Thats when things for investors can get even worse.......
Again, I'm not saying investors can't make money here in Illinois or can't build a portfolio of rentals that do ok. But I don't see how anybody in their right mind can advocate that any area in Illinois would make for a good investment when comparing them to some of the other areas in the country.
If you said is Chicago better than LA to buy and hold rentals? That may be a yes.
But if you were to ask whether it makes sense to invest in Illinois over a handful of other more landlord friendly areas, I would say absolutely not. There is not a single thing to like about Illinois for investors in terms of any of the indicators one would typically use.
The only possible saving grace is that the price to rent ratios are reasonable here. But when you add up taxes and tenant friendly laws in some counties here, you're losing money.
Here's a good article from 2015 and its only gotten worse since then:
Friday, 14 August 2015
Trickle of Companies Leaving Illinois Turning Into a Flood
Here's another:
STILL LEAVING ILLINOIS: AN EXODUS OF PEOPLE AND MONEY
By J. Scott Moody
Jan 3, 2017 - Michael Lucci
MOVING OUT: ILLINOIS HAS COUNTRY’S WORST OUTBOUND RATE IN 2016
Houston is quickly replacing Chicago, Pennsylvania has replaced Illinois in population as well. Everyone here has some really good points, I also dare to ask the question if the rest of the state continues to fail how will Chicago stand?
Chicago and IL are not growing and that should be concerning, but it's not doom and gloom. Most Midwest cities lost massive population 20-30 years ago and Chicago was able to stay strong. Unlike most of those other cities, Chicago has an appeal that no other city can touch and I'd argue Summertime Chi is the best city in the country. Ultimately, Chicago needs job creation and tax reform to help turnaround some of the population trends.
Agreed Summertime Chi is the one of the best and the people of the city continue to keep it alive. The city itself will continue to be one of the top cities. Still, the rest of the state sans Champaign-Urbana is looking mighty rough
Chicago is NOT declining...last number I heard was 55 cranes actively building in Chicago. Vacancy rate remains low. The south side is rip roaring hot along with some of the fringe west side neighborhoods. The trend seems to be a small exodus from the southside in poorer neighborhoods to the burbs because of schools being shut down and the gentrification (I'm sorry...there's a whole foods in Englewood....IN ENGLEWOOD!!!!!) This leads me to see growth and a greater urban spread of development.
I'm wondering if/ when this trend will begin in STL? Or is STL a different beast overall. The Westside (now west downtown) and the southside will grow as people look for the cheaper housing solutions and the burbs will just get worst. Young people want to live in cities where they don't need cars, they can train and bike to work school and party
Since 1990 the City of Chicago went from 2,786,000 people to 2,705,000 - a loss of 81,000 people in 25 years and a 3% loss. Since 1990 the metro area of Chicago went from 8,239,820 people to 9,504,753 in 2016 - an increase of 1,264,933 people in 25 years and a 116% increase
Blanket market stats are not relevant in large markets.
I look at things from a macro level - Even a zip code is too big of an area to be taking stats at face value
Take the 60618 zip code in Bell School District - it has one of the fastest declining populations in the city. Why? Because what once was an area with 70% of the housing stock being 2-4 units it is now less than 50% because developers are converting the 2-4 buildings to SFH and selling them to Cubs and Blackhawks players with kids who want to go to a top rated school. So there is a decline in population because the number of housing units is declining, thus limiting the supply and increasing price. Now there are less 2-4 units so supply is low and those prices are going up, but we have a surplus of SFH and prices are not increasing. Throw in condos and that is a whole different market.
Even in the same school district houses west of western sell for a few hundred thousand dollars less. Go north of irving park road in the same zip code is a different school district and a totally different market.
So I would not even use stats to look at home sales in this zip code, the condo, SFH, and 2-4 unit markets are completely different and looking at a "days on market" stat or "average home price" includes all of those could lead you to make an investing mistake.
The city center now is growing faster than ever, having gained an estimated 42,423 people from 2010-15. But the population of the non-lakefront South Side is dropping even quicker, falling about 50,000 in the same period. So you need to look at the areas specifically to understand what is going on.
Since 1990 the City of Chicago went from 2,786,000 people to 2,705,000 - a loss of 81,000 people in 25 years and a 3% loss. Since 1990 the metro area of Chicago went from 8,239,820 people to 9,504,753 in 2016 - an increase of 1,264,933 people in 25 years and a 116% increase
Blanket market stats are not relevant in large markets.
I look at things from a macro level - Even a zip code is too big of an area to be taking stats at face value
Take the 60618 zip code in Bell School District - it has one of the fastest declining populations in the city. Why? Because what once was an area with 70% of the housing stock being 2-4 units it is now less than 50% because developers are converting the 2-4 buildings to SFH and selling them to Cubs and Blackhawks players with kids who want to go to a top rated school. So there is a decline in population because the number of housing units is declining, thus limiting the supply and increasing price. Now there are less 2-4 units so supply is low and those prices are going up, but we have a surplus of SFH and prices are not increasing. Throw in condos and that is a whole different market.
Even in the same school district houses west of western sell for a few hundred thousand dollars less. Go north of irving park road in the same zip code is a different school district and a totally different market.
So I would not even use stats to look at home sales in this zip code, the condo, SFH, and 2-4 unit markets are completely different and looking at a "days on market" stat or "average home price" includes all of those could lead you to make an investing mistake.
The city center now is growing faster than ever, having gained an estimated 42,423 people from 2010-15. But the population of the non-lakefront South Side is dropping even quicker, falling about 50,000 in the same period. So you need to look at the areas specifically to understand what is going on.
This is why it pays to get to know people that are working in specific areas who have in-depth knowledge of the circumstances in those areas. Almost no writer will detail out what circumstances are causing changes in Chicago or any city for that matter.
Hmm. Meghan, I'm going to have strongly disagree with your comment that "Chicago is not declining". Chicago is very much in a decline no matter how you cut it. Population. Job growth. Taxes - which I view as being a contributor to a decline.
But Ryan, I think that maybe the issue here. Your post asked about population growth. I would suggest that population growth or decline doesn't tell the entire story. And I would also ask what your intentions are for your investing.
If you're looking to flip, then the chicago land area definitely has some areas that you can do well in. People still have money here.
But if you're looking for long term buy and hold, then I just don't see any reason why someone would want to invest in any of the chicago land areas out here. There are two main reasons why:
1) Businesses are NOT coming to Illinois. We've had a few suburban hq's jump back to the city. But Illinois is not going to win any big job generation companies. The taxes are an absolutely nightmare - both in terms of corporate, individual and property taxes. We have the highest property taxes in the country. Thats an absolute fact.
Jobs are leaving the state and heading over the border. I know several that have given up on this state and jumped over the border to indiana. And I'm sure there are quite a few more that have done the same thing to wisconsin, iowa and missouri. Nobody is coming to Illinois.
2) Individuals are tired of the terrible commute, the terrible weather and the crazy high property taxes here. Again, I know quite a few people that have given up and jumped the border to indiana and/or have simply left for other states. Now some of this may be midwest related but a majority of the reasons I hear are property taxes and govt nonsense.
I can't remember the last time someone actually moved to Illinois from somewhere.
So if you're truly looking for indicators as to whether Illinois is some great place to invest, I would tell you thats simply not possible here. Not right now anyway. And this state, city and county are ALL still woefully under water with their obligations (i.e. pensions).
For far too long, these stupid politicians have simply over promised the fat cat unions more money than what the state can afford to pay. And now we're stuck. There are going to be some more tax increases coming to catch us back up. But we're already maxed out. You add a couple more increases and you're really going to see people leave.
So, to you Ryan, I would suggest that flipping might be ok here but if you're looking at finding an area with great fundamentals, the last state I would be looking at right now is Illinois. Why not go to the states that actually have good fundamentals. Indiana, Texas, etc.
btw: The landlord laws in cook county are some of the absolute worst in the country. Evictions take 4 to 5 months and can go even longer. In indiana, its 4 to 6 weeks. And if you don't think the residents of cook county know how long they can go without paying and/or how to stretch it out longer, good luck.
So again, if you're flipping, that really isn't a concern either. But if you're looking to buy and hold, then cook county would be the last place I'd recommend anyone from out of state look to invest in. Doesn't mean you can't make money there. And if you live here, then you're somewhat captive.
But for someone to look at areas to invest in from out of state, there is no way that they should be looking to chicago. Every single indicator you'd want to see as a buy and hold investor would be negative here.
btw: The exodus in the south side and lower priced areas is NOT because of gentrification. That doesn't hold water. The middle class people in those areas are not leaving because they're getting bought out. They're leaving because they're tired of fearing being shot. And because property taxes are too high and wage growth has been non existent.
The tribune, again, has had some great articles on the exodus. And gentrification is NOT the reason any of these people are moving out of state. The one article mentioned how chicago's home prices are not going up at all. Why? Because property taxes are rising so fast and creating a drag on prices.
I'm not sure what some of the other people on this board are reading. But anybody that thinks chicago is a great place to invest in isn't basing that on any reality that I'm aware of. The number of cranes in the city doesn't mean a thing unless you're suggesting people should invest in million dollar condos or office buildings downtown. Or maybe if you're a big time developer or something. Then that makes perfect sense.
But for small time investors, this may be the worst area to target of any area in the country right now. Just read the articles. There isn't anything good to point to. High property taxes. Stagnant home prices. Low job and wage growth. Extremely unfavorable landlord laws.
In fact, there's a series of articles the tribune is running right now showing some of the basic reasons people are leaving.
Illinois exodus: When living here no longer makes financial sense
"As part of a series on the accelerating exodus from Illinois, we’re tracking down expatriates (and potential expats) and telling their stories. From millennials to retirees, their narratives follow the same thread: Illinois is losing its promise as a land of opportunity. Government debt and dysfunction contribute to a weak housing market and a stagnant jobs climate. State and local governments face enormous pension and other obligations. Taxes have risen sharply; many Illinois politicians say they must rise more.
People are fleeing. Last year’s net loss: 33,703. Among those who’ve left in recent years:
Niedzwiecki, an accountant fresh out of college, worked in Libertyville for several years and then at a downtown location. Sure, it would have been nice to live in Lakeview or Bucktown with other 20-somethings, but she couldn’t afford it. So she endured a daily commute from the suburbs and tried to build a life.
It never happened. After years of watching her paycheck get sapped by rising rent and taxes, and after exploring options to buy a house and realizing she couldn’t afford that either, she moved back to Wisconsin. She got a better-paying job, left her $850-per-month basement apartment in the suburbs and bought a $148,000 two-bedroom condo in Madison with parking and a washer and dryer. Her property taxes are about $2,800 annually.
“I just felt like I was never going to get ahead in Illinois,” she said. “Six years of living there proved that.”
The Woodstock home they built in 2006 for $390,000, into which they put another $35,000, was losing value. This was to be the house where the Felzes would host grandchildren and putz in the yard. Instead, rather than put their retirement finances in further peril, they sold it in 2016 for $310,000. The property tax bill had climbed from $7,658 in 2007 to $8,340 in 2015. That’s not a huge rate of increase. But had their housing value remained at the purchase price, the taxes would have been nearly $12,500. A falling Illinois home value kept a high Illinois tax bill from rising higher.
In Colorado, taxes on their home, valued at $510,000 and climbing, are about $4,000 a year.
------------------------
The Carpenters sold their three-bedroom, two-bathroom Naperville home for not much more than the purchase price 13 years earlier. While the property taxes climbed annually, reaching nearly $9,000 by the time they sold, the value of the home remained flat. That’s an alarming trend throughout the Chicagoland area. Home values have not kept pace with skyrocketing property taxes.
In 2016, the year they left for Texas, Illinois lost a net 37,508 residents, more than any state in the country. The Heards packed up their Dodge Durango with what was left of their belongings and made their way to Fairview, about 30 minutes north of Dallas in a state with no income tax.
James Heard wrote a letter to Gov. Bruce Rauner when they moved, explaining why they had to go. Their property taxes had risen from about $1,600 when they bought their five-bedroom Homer Glen home in 1996 to nearly $10,000 by the time they left. They sold their house for $325,000 and made a little money. But the value of the home did not keep pace with the property taxes owed.
“I was paying more than my fair share,” he said. “I don’t see any way out (for Illinois). People making $100,000 or more are just going to leave. They’re all looking at northwest Indiana to get away from the taxes.”
Everyone thinks they know the best places to invest, Ca, the south east, Cincinnati, your back yard...
But, there is NO city that I hear more contention on than the city of Chicago. The third coast has ample opportunity...and haters. As one of the 20 Amazon finalists we need to re-examine the question, "Chicago, STUD or dud?"
Chicago is an outstanding area to invest.
Crime in Chicago is very much neighborhood, and even block, specific. It has become trendy for certain media outlets to attempt to make political statements by portraying the entire city as a war zone, but this is really far from the truth. The majority of the violence occurs in a few specific neighborhoods where rival gangs have been in bloody turf wars. The majority of the victims are gang members. Many people simply avoid these neighborhoods to avoid these issues. The vast majority of the city is very safe.
Chicago's landlord laws certainly are tenant friendly, but in many areas, the supply/demand curves heavily favor the landlord and this somewhat negates this issue. My properties are in A/B class areas, so my experiences are different than some, but my property manager, for example, has a blanket policy of not accepting anyone with an eviction on their record, period, no exceptions. Because vacancies receive so many applications, landlords can be choosy and avoid tenants with a negative history. Tenants are also very aware that if they're ever evicted, they're essentially screwed in the future. I had a tenant who lost her job and stop paying rent, as soon as we began the eviction process, she moved out the following Saturday to avoid an eviction on her record. We were able to get the unit cleaned and rented again within a week and lost less than one month's rent from the situation...and this was in the slow rental season.
There are certainly issues with unpaid pensions due to political incompetency decades ago, both in local and state government. There have been some creative ways to solve some of these problems, as well, however...unfortunately the county caved and overturned the obesity tax, but the city and the state will continue to find ways to manage the situation. Chicago's property taxes are relatively very low, so even if we do get hit with some property tax hikes, they'll still be very manageable. For example, I pay $4800 for a three unit property worth about 450K. From what my friends tell me in comparable cities on the coasts, that sort of number is unheard of in places like NYC, Boston, Seattle, etc. Additionally, I calculate my #'s factoring in an increase in property taxes going forward and the numbers still work out very well...especially because rents have been going up at a rate faster than property taxes. A unit I rented for $1280 just two years ago now rents for $1450. With these sort of rent increases, I can weather a 10% property tax increase without much of an issue.
The population of the city is growing, but it is also changing. As a whole, lower and working class people are leaving the city, while yuppies are moving into the city at a slightly faster rate. The city is absolutely booming in terms of growth from yuppies, fueled by a booming tech industry, as well as the relocation of corporate headquarters into the city. Moving to Chicago is still the chic thing to do for graduates of Big Ten and other mid-western colleges and universities and thousands of them come flooding in each year.
As a whole, the city is a great place to invest right now. There are 50 high rises under construction in Chicago right now. There's a reason why big players nationally are investing heavily into the city.