In Escrow and Buyers Want to Rent

In Escrow and Buyers Want to Rent

Southern California · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 2 votes

      Hello. We are selling a house in Southern California and the buyers have asked for three extensions, have removed all contingencies, done final walk through. We were supposed to close today and now they are asking to rent from Dec to May in order to have time to improve their credit score. Their credit score is 680/660. They also claim they need time to pay off an IRS obligation due to withdrawing money from 401k after changing jobs. They stated after this, they will be a in a better position to afford the mortgage. 

     They were aware of their credit score and IRS obligation before they put in an offer on our house, so I am not sure I understand this. Also, isn't this credit score a little low for renting to someone? I worked for someone that owned properties in Houston and would feel comfortable being a landlord in TX, but CA has laws that make it more difficult to evict someone. If we were to rent, I would ask for a better credit score and anyway, we want the money from the house sale to buy a house next year. Any advice? Do we get their earnest money at this point? What are our options? 

0Reply
171 views

Most Popular Reply

Chris MasonPro Member
Moderator
Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
7y

They need 6 months to close on this house?

No, they (or you) need to cancel it, and they can go find their dream house in 6 months.

Or they need to simply find a way to close now, and they can look at refinancing in 6 months if they can get their FICO scores up. Rate/term refinance and purchase mortgage rates are identical, so either way they'd be looking at whatever/wherever rates are in 6 months, but this way (close now and look at refinancing) they own the house and it's not your problem if rates go up another 0.5% and their newly improved FICO score is a wash with that. 

Speculation to follow. Every April and October I have a client or two that suddenly can't pay their income tax bill; never occurred to them that if they go into escrow when taxes are due that they will have two big expenses to pay that particular month. Not really a coincidence either: "I had a good year!" is correlated with "I want to buy a house!" and is correlated with "oh crap that's a huge income tax bill!" - causing these things to often all happen at about the same time for escrows that start in April and October.

Going into escrow in October lines up with both this and us currently being in late November.

There are actually a lot of these little seasonal things. Next up: Property taxes are due in December in California. 

See this reply in the discussion

35 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7y

    They need 6 months to close on this house?

    No, they (or you) need to cancel it, and they can go find their dream house in 6 months.

    Or they need to simply find a way to close now, and they can look at refinancing in 6 months if they can get their FICO scores up. Rate/term refinance and purchase mortgage rates are identical, so either way they'd be looking at whatever/wherever rates are in 6 months, but this way (close now and look at refinancing) they own the house and it's not your problem if rates go up another 0.5% and their newly improved FICO score is a wash with that. 

    Speculation to follow. Every April and October I have a client or two that suddenly can't pay their income tax bill; never occurred to them that if they go into escrow when taxes are due that they will have two big expenses to pay that particular month. Not really a coincidence either: "I had a good year!" is correlated with "I want to buy a house!" and is correlated with "oh crap that's a huge income tax bill!" - causing these things to often all happen at about the same time for escrows that start in April and October.

    Going into escrow in October lines up with both this and us currently being in late November.

    There are actually a lot of these little seasonal things. Next up: Property taxes are due in December in California. 

  • Southern California · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 2 votes
    7y
    @Chris Mason ok. This makes sense. Everything seemed fine until recently. They must have just realized about the tax bill. I hope we're able to get their earnest money. They have wasted over a month for usand we moved so we are paying rent and the mortgage. This is actually the second time our house falls out of escrow, the first was because of an error on the part of the lender. We moved after all contingencies were removed and then they informed us they didn't have enough down payment.
  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
    7y

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

  • Lien VuongBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    I think the trouble you're having is perhaps feeling like you've gone too far into the process. At this point you are allowed to cancel the contract and have the right to keep your EMD, that portion goes completely to you and not the agent. You can use your discretion in this if you'd like to share of of that with him or her for their time. Having this right will be the wakeup call for your buyers to not waste anymore of anyone's time through this transaction.

    I Just went through this myself and buyers tried to reneg at the CLOSING TABLE and after some back and forth and I reminded them of the 5% that is in escrow with my name on it and they quickly changed their tone.  

  • Southern California · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 2 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

     You think so? We are not sure we will resign a contract with this agent, haven't decided yet. 

  • Southern California · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 2 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Lien Vuong:

    I think the trouble you're having is perhaps feeling like you've gone too far into the process. At this point you are allowed to cancel the contract and have the right to keep your EMD, that portion goes completely to you and not the agent. You can use your discretion in this if you'd like to share of of that with him or her for their time. Having this right will be the wakeup call for your buyers to not waste anymore of anyone's time through this transaction.

    I Just went through this myself and buyers tried to reneg at the CLOSING TABLE and after some back and forth and I reminded them of the 5% that is in escrow with my name on it and they quickly changed their tone.  

     At the closing table??? Eeek. 

    Right, I don't think they took this seriously, and also, they put too much trust into their lender's agent. This has happened both times in escrow for us. The buyer completely trusted whatever the lender told them, who told them what they want to hear. At yhis point, it's the deadest month of the year for Real Estate, so we're probably going to give them 30 days and see if they can make it happen. Then, regroup in the New Year and decide what to do if it doesn't work out. 

  • Lien VuongBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    Well now you have to decide what poker strategy you want, bluff and have them walk or possibly win the hand. If you're open to extending this to them I think you should make a big fuss about it and let them be aware of the repercussions if they do not perform - holding the deposit and walking away with nothing - lender doesnt make money, agents dont make money... Make them see your pain and what you're allowing them to do is really a large sacrifice for you (because it is!!). Buyers are emotional and they will take it more seriously - esp. with that much money at risk. 

  • Southern California · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 2 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Lien Vuong:

    Well now you have to decide what poker strategy you want, bluff and have them walk or possibly win the hand. If you're open to extending this to them I think you should make a big fuss about it and let them be aware of the repercussions if they do not perform - holding the deposit and walking away with nothing - lender doesnt make money, agents dont make money... Make them see your pain and what you're allowing them to do is really a large sacrifice for you (because it is!!). Buyers are emotional and they will take it more seriously - esp. with that much money at risk. 

     It is totally painful, the constant stress of not knowing how long we have to pay the expenses for this house, and waiting to buy the house we really want. Thanks. 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Montgomery, NY · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Lien Vuong:

    I think the trouble you're having is perhaps feeling like you've gone too far into the process. At this point you are allowed to cancel the contract and have the right to keep your EMD, that portion goes completely to you and not the agent. You can use your discretion in this if you'd like to share of of that with him or her for their time. Having this right will be the wakeup call for your buyers to not waste anymore of anyone's time through this transaction.

    I Just went through this myself and buyers tried to reneg at the CLOSING TABLE and after some back and forth and I reminded them of the 5% that is in escrow with my name on it and they quickly changed their tone.  

    As a seller who just had a couple buying my house walk away after months, commitment came, appraisal and every other piece went perfect. They decided to take a job in FL and move not buying the house (days before it would close). I didn't just get the EMD... both parties have to sign and agree to release or. My buyers clearly breached their contract however they fought for their money back. These thing should could take months/years.

    My buyer and I ended up agreeing to a split (not 50:50, but a split between both of us) however I was prepared to ride it out if need be.

    My reason for this post, don't be so certain you will simply "keep" their EMD. There is a chance (probably a good one) they will fight it.

  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:
    Originally posted by @Lien Vuong:

    I think the trouble you're having is perhaps feeling like you've gone too far into the process. At this point you are allowed to cancel the contract and have the right to keep your EMD, that portion goes completely to you and not the agent. You can use your discretion in this if you'd like to share of of that with him or her for their time. Having this right will be the wakeup call for your buyers to not waste anymore of anyone's time through this transaction.

    I Just went through this myself and buyers tried to reneg at the CLOSING TABLE and after some back and forth and I reminded them of the 5% that is in escrow with my name on it and they quickly changed their tone.  

    As a seller who just had a couple buying my house walk away after months, commitment came, appraisal and every other piece went perfect. They decided to take a job in FL and move not buying the house (days before it would close). I didn't just get the EMD... both parties have to sign and agree to release or. My buyers clearly breached their contract however they fought for their money back. These thing should could take months/years.

    My buyer and I ended up agreeing to a split (not 50:50, but a split between both of us) however I was prepared to ride it out if need be.

    My reason for this post, don't be so certain you will simply "keep" their EMD. There is a chance (probably a good one) they will fight it.

    This is correct; I've had some buyers do some monumentally stupid things, but never had one simply lose their entire EMD without hassle. Varies by state of course, along with state law, but that's been what I've seen in California.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Montgomery, NY · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:
    Originally posted by @Lien Vuong:

    I think the trouble you're having is perhaps feeling like you've gone too far into the process. At this point you are allowed to cancel the contract and have the right to keep your EMD, that portion goes completely to you and not the agent. You can use your discretion in this if you'd like to share of of that with him or her for their time. Having this right will be the wakeup call for your buyers to not waste anymore of anyone's time through this transaction.

    I Just went through this myself and buyers tried to reneg at the CLOSING TABLE and after some back and forth and I reminded them of the 5% that is in escrow with my name on it and they quickly changed their tone.  

    As a seller who just had a couple buying my house walk away after months, commitment came, appraisal and every other piece went perfect. They decided to take a job in FL and move not buying the house (days before it would close). I didn't just get the EMD... both parties have to sign and agree to release or. My buyers clearly breached their contract however they fought for their money back. These thing should could take months/years.

    My buyer and I ended up agreeing to a split (not 50:50, but a split between both of us) however I was prepared to ride it out if need be.

    My reason for this post, don't be so certain you will simply "keep" their EMD. There is a chance (probably a good one) they will fight it.

    This is correct; I've had some buyers do some monumentally stupid things, but never had one simply lose their entire EMD without hassle. Varies by state of course, along with state law, but that's been what I've seen in California.

    I forgot my typical "this varies by area/state" comment, but I would imagine most of the time the party in the wrong doesn't simply sign away their EMD. My case it was literally word for word in the contract what happened they lose their deposit as liquidated damages to me, yet they still were going to fight it.

  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:
    Originally posted by @Lien Vuong:

    I think the trouble you're having is perhaps feeling like you've gone too far into the process. At this point you are allowed to cancel the contract and have the right to keep your EMD, that portion goes completely to you and not the agent. You can use your discretion in this if you'd like to share of of that with him or her for their time. Having this right will be the wakeup call for your buyers to not waste anymore of anyone's time through this transaction.

    I Just went through this myself and buyers tried to reneg at the CLOSING TABLE and after some back and forth and I reminded them of the 5% that is in escrow with my name on it and they quickly changed their tone.  

    As a seller who just had a couple buying my house walk away after months, commitment came, appraisal and every other piece went perfect. They decided to take a job in FL and move not buying the house (days before it would close). I didn't just get the EMD... both parties have to sign and agree to release or. My buyers clearly breached their contract however they fought for their money back. These thing should could take months/years.

    My buyer and I ended up agreeing to a split (not 50:50, but a split between both of us) however I was prepared to ride it out if need be.

    My reason for this post, don't be so certain you will simply "keep" their EMD. There is a chance (probably a good one) they will fight it.

    This is correct; I've had some buyers do some monumentally stupid things, but never had one simply lose their entire EMD without hassle. Varies by state of course, along with state law, but that's been what I've seen in California.

    I forgot my typical "this varies by area/state" comment, but I would imagine most of the time the party in the wrong doesn't simply sign away their EMD. My case it was literally word for word in the contract what happened they lose their deposit as liquidated damages to me, yet they still were going to fight it.

    And had you taken it the whole 9 yards to litigation, how did the amount of the EMD compare to how much you'd have spent on legal fees and lawyers, if you did that much research?

  • Member since 2018 · 5 posts · 4 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Maria Amaro:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

     You think so? We are not sure we will resign a contract with this agent, haven't decided yet. 

    I'm sorry but I don't agree with Russell, assuming your Realtor asked for the standard (here is SoCal at least) pre-approval letter and proof of funds, they did their part. 

    They could have also had their preferred lender cross-qualified the buyer which is recommended.

    But I don't see how your Realtor could have foreseen the buyers wanting to rent the home so that they could raise their credit score.

  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Maria Amaro:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

     You think so? We are not sure we will resign a contract with this agent, haven't decided yet. 

    I'm sorry but I don't agree with Russell, assuming your Realtor asked for the standard (here is SoCal at least) pre-approval letter and proof of funds, they did their part. 

    They could have also had their preferred lender cross-qualified the buyer which is recommended.

    But I don't see how your Realtor could have foreseen the buyers wanting to rent the home so that they could raise their credit score.

     It's more of an East Coast thing, just like cross-qualifying the buyer with another lender is more of a SoCal thing - up in the Bay Area listing agents often think it's a red flag for a buyer to be working with multiple lenders or real estate agents. A lot of our "norms" are actually regional norms that we don't realize are only regional.... in Illinois, there are no real estate agents, everyone is a real estate "broker." In Texas they use "options," which are not exactly the same thing as an earnest money deposit. In much of rural California, your earnest money deposit can be $1000 and no one blinks, and it might take 4 weeks to get an appraisal back. In NorCal you never speak to a title officer because it's amalgamated with escrow and they hide behind the escrow officers and are treated as the same entity with a single point of contact; but down in your neck of the words escrow might be with Chicago Title and title might be with ABC Escrow. 

    I've not bothered to get licensed outside of California because just within California is plenty enough regional variation for me to keep track of... I'd blow a gasket if a listing agent asked me to see the buyer's paystubs, but I've never been exposed to East Coast regional norms. 

  • Member since 2018 · 5 posts · 4 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Maria Amaro:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

     You think so? We are not sure we will resign a contract with this agent, haven't decided yet. 

    I'm sorry but I don't agree with Russell, assuming your Realtor asked for the standard (here is SoCal at least) pre-approval letter and proof of funds, they did their part. 

    They could have also had their preferred lender cross-qualified the buyer which is recommended.

    But I don't see how your Realtor could have foreseen the buyers wanting to rent the home so that they could raise their credit score.

     It's more of an East Coast thing, just like cross-qualifying the buyer with another lender is more of a SoCal thing - up in the Bay Area listing agents often think it's a red flag for a buyer to be working with multiple lenders or real estate agents. A lot of our "norms" are actually regional norms that we don't realize are only regional.... in Illinois, there are no real estate agents, everyone is a real estate "broker." In Texas they use "options," which are not exactly the same thing as an earnest money deposit. In much of rural California, your earnest money deposit can be $1000 and no one blinks, and it might take 4 weeks to get an appraisal back. In NorCal you never speak to a title officer because it's amalgamated with escrow and they hide behind the escrow officers and are treated as the same entity with a single point of contact; but down in your neck of the words escrow might be with Chicago Title and title might be with ABC Escrow. 

    I've not bothered to get licensed outside of California because just within California is plenty enough regional variation for me to keep track of... I'd blow a gasket if a listing agent asked me to see the buyer's paystubs, but I've never been exposed to East Coast regional norms. 

    Hi Chris, I’m a little confused by your reply. What’s more of an East Coast thing? 

  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Maria Amaro:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

     You think so? We are not sure we will resign a contract with this agent, haven't decided yet. 

    I'm sorry but I don't agree with Russell, assuming your Realtor asked for the standard (here is SoCal at least) pre-approval letter and proof of funds, they did their part. 

    They could have also had their preferred lender cross-qualified the buyer which is recommended.

    But I don't see how your Realtor could have foreseen the buyers wanting to rent the home so that they could raise their credit score.

     It's more of an East Coast thing, just like cross-qualifying the buyer with another lender is more of a SoCal thing - up in the Bay Area listing agents often think it's a red flag for a buyer to be working with multiple lenders or real estate agents. A lot of our "norms" are actually regional norms that we don't realize are only regional.... in Illinois, there are no real estate agents, everyone is a real estate "broker." In Texas they use "options," which are not exactly the same thing as an earnest money deposit. In much of rural California, your earnest money deposit can be $1000 and no one blinks, and it might take 4 weeks to get an appraisal back. In NorCal you never speak to a title officer because it's amalgamated with escrow and they hide behind the escrow officers and are treated as the same entity with a single point of contact; but down in your neck of the words escrow might be with Chicago Title and title might be with ABC Escrow. 

    I've not bothered to get licensed outside of California because just within California is plenty enough regional variation for me to keep track of... I'd blow a gasket if a listing agent asked me to see the buyer's paystubs, but I've never been exposed to East Coast regional norms. 

    Hi Chris, I’m a little confused by your reply. What’s more of an East Coast thing? 

     Listing agents doing (what we would consider) an unusually high amount of due diligence on the buyer's financials. I too thought it was crazy when I first started reading these forums, then noticed that the folks saying that were always East Coast. I'm guessing lender expectations are just lower there, so listing agents pick up the slack. I find it interesting learning about these regional differences, how something crazy to us might be the norm elsewhere (you need to have a law degree and pass the state bar to function as what we would call an escrow officer?!), and normal stuff to us (no appraisal contingency, anyone?) is crazy elsewhere. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y

    That really sucks! i would be having a nervous breakdown! 

    I think i would be letting buyers know that even if they wait 6 months, the increase of credit score inst going to change their payment much as I am assuming rates will rise in the interim.  Also, by waiting they lose out on 6 months of interest expense deductrion (to help lower taxes), etc.

    And, if they want to rent the house, it needs to cover all expenses....  

    I hope you are able to make it work......

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Montgomery, NY · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:
    Originally posted by @Lien Vuong:

    I think the trouble you're having is perhaps feeling like you've gone too far into the process. At this point you are allowed to cancel the contract and have the right to keep your EMD, that portion goes completely to you and not the agent. You can use your discretion in this if you'd like to share of of that with him or her for their time. Having this right will be the wakeup call for your buyers to not waste anymore of anyone's time through this transaction.

    I Just went through this myself and buyers tried to reneg at the CLOSING TABLE and after some back and forth and I reminded them of the 5% that is in escrow with my name on it and they quickly changed their tone.  

    As a seller who just had a couple buying my house walk away after months, commitment came, appraisal and every other piece went perfect. They decided to take a job in FL and move not buying the house (days before it would close). I didn't just get the EMD... both parties have to sign and agree to release or. My buyers clearly breached their contract however they fought for their money back. These thing should could take months/years.

    My buyer and I ended up agreeing to a split (not 50:50, but a split between both of us) however I was prepared to ride it out if need be.

    My reason for this post, don't be so certain you will simply "keep" their EMD. There is a chance (probably a good one) they will fight it.

    This is correct; I've had some buyers do some monumentally stupid things, but never had one simply lose their entire EMD without hassle. Varies by state of course, along with state law, but that's been what I've seen in California.

    I forgot my typical "this varies by area/state" comment, but I would imagine most of the time the party in the wrong doesn't simply sign away their EMD. My case it was literally word for word in the contract what happened they lose their deposit as liquidated damages to me, yet they still were going to fight it.

    And had you taken it the whole 9 yards to litigation, how did the amount of the EMD compare to how much you'd have spent on legal fees and lawyers, if you did that much research?

    Had many conversations with my attorney about it. His honest opinion was to agree and split to avoid retainer, lawsuit, etc. I played the "have the buyer make the first lawsuit move", being they were moving 1000 miles away I played it a certain way and it worked. Just retainer alone was $2500 if I sued them...

  • Member since 2018 · 5 posts · 4 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Maria Amaro:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

     You think so? We are not sure we will resign a contract with this agent, haven't decided yet. 

    I'm sorry but I don't agree with Russell, assuming your Realtor asked for the standard (here is SoCal at least) pre-approval letter and proof of funds, they did their part. 

    They could have also had their preferred lender cross-qualified the buyer which is recommended.

    But I don't see how your Realtor could have foreseen the buyers wanting to rent the home so that they could raise their credit score.

     It's more of an East Coast thing, just like cross-qualifying the buyer with another lender is more of a SoCal thing - up in the Bay Area listing agents often think it's a red flag for a buyer to be working with multiple lenders or real estate agents. A lot of our "norms" are actually regional norms that we don't realize are only regional.... in Illinois, there are no real estate agents, everyone is a real estate "broker." In Texas they use "options," which are not exactly the same thing as an earnest money deposit. In much of rural California, your earnest money deposit can be $1000 and no one blinks, and it might take 4 weeks to get an appraisal back. In NorCal you never speak to a title officer because it's amalgamated with escrow and they hide behind the escrow officers and are treated as the same entity with a single point of contact; but down in your neck of the words escrow might be with Chicago Title and title might be with ABC Escrow. 

    I've not bothered to get licensed outside of California because just within California is plenty enough regional variation for me to keep track of... I'd blow a gasket if a listing agent asked me to see the buyer's paystubs, but I've never been exposed to East Coast regional norms. 

    Hi Chris, I’m a little confused by your reply. What’s more of an East Coast thing? 

     Listing agents doing (what we would consider) an unusually high amount of due diligence on the buyer's financials. I too thought it was crazy when I first started reading these forums, then noticed that the folks saying that were always East Coast. I'm guessing lender expectations are just lower there, so listing agents pick up the slack. I find it interesting learning about these regional differences, how something crazy to us might be the norm elsewhere (you need to have a law degree and pass the state bar to function as what we would call an escrow officer?!), and normal stuff to us (no appraisal contingency, anyone?) is crazy elsewhere. 

    Aah I see. Thank you for clarifying.

    I’m curious to know what kind of due diligence an agent can take to foresee a buyer wanting to rent in order to raise their FICO score.

  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    Walk away from this buyer.

  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Maria Amaro:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

     You think so? We are not sure we will resign a contract with this agent, haven't decided yet. 

    I'm sorry but I don't agree with Russell, assuming your Realtor asked for the standard (here is SoCal at least) pre-approval letter and proof of funds, they did their part. 

    They could have also had their preferred lender cross-qualified the buyer which is recommended.

    But I don't see how your Realtor could have foreseen the buyers wanting to rent the home so that they could raise their credit score.

     It's more of an East Coast thing, just like cross-qualifying the buyer with another lender is more of a SoCal thing - up in the Bay Area listing agents often think it's a red flag for a buyer to be working with multiple lenders or real estate agents. A lot of our "norms" are actually regional norms that we don't realize are only regional.... in Illinois, there are no real estate agents, everyone is a real estate "broker." In Texas they use "options," which are not exactly the same thing as an earnest money deposit. In much of rural California, your earnest money deposit can be $1000 and no one blinks, and it might take 4 weeks to get an appraisal back. In NorCal you never speak to a title officer because it's amalgamated with escrow and they hide behind the escrow officers and are treated as the same entity with a single point of contact; but down in your neck of the words escrow might be with Chicago Title and title might be with ABC Escrow. 

    I've not bothered to get licensed outside of California because just within California is plenty enough regional variation for me to keep track of... I'd blow a gasket if a listing agent asked me to see the buyer's paystubs, but I've never been exposed to East Coast regional norms. 

    Hi Chris, I’m a little confused by your reply. What’s more of an East Coast thing? 

     Listing agents doing (what we would consider) an unusually high amount of due diligence on the buyer's financials. I too thought it was crazy when I first started reading these forums, then noticed that the folks saying that were always East Coast. I'm guessing lender expectations are just lower there, so listing agents pick up the slack. I find it interesting learning about these regional differences, how something crazy to us might be the norm elsewhere (you need to have a law degree and pass the state bar to function as what we would call an escrow officer?!), and normal stuff to us (no appraisal contingency, anyone?) is crazy elsewhere. 

    Aah I see. Thank you for clarifying.

    I’m curious to know what kind of due diligence an agent can take to foresee a buyer wanting to rent in order to raise their FICO score.

     I vet the buyer, the buyers agent, and the lender. I want to know the buyers ficos, I want a financial information sheet on them, and I want proof of funds. I want to know how many offers they have made on other properties, how many they lost out on, if any contracts have fallen apart and why. 

    Im equally vetting the buyers agent and their lender. Are they using some chop shop internet lender, or are they using a lender who has a reputation for closing, closing on time and closing without issue. Has the lender preunderwritten the buyer. Have they verified assets. How long have they been working with the buyer. Are they the actual lender doing this deal or are the buyers going to shop around and end up with a hack lender. With the agent, does the agent have a strong reputation for closing. Are they able to keep their clients expectations for the process realistic. Or are they some hack who has nonserious buyers who squirm out of deals. Are they going to keep this with the lender I vetted or allow their clients to shop around. (If they are shopping around, better believe there is going to be a nonrefundable EMD involved)

    Maybe you guys dont do that on the west coast like Chris said, but the vetting of the buyers, their agent, their lender is one of the most important aspects of my job on the listing side.  If I let a property go under contract, then have it fall apart and need to come back to the market, I literally could be responsible for tens of thousands of dollars of damage to my client. Im not going to cost my client $25k on a lower sales price because I didnt vet all the players involved. And often, I dont need to do much vetting because Im going to work with the other strong agents and lenders in the market time and time again. Reputation is paramount in this business.

  • Rental Property Investor · Ithaca, NY · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y
    @Maria Amaro I’d make them buy the house, a deal is a deal and they are under contract. I wouldn’t rent to them either, if they are messing around now whats stopping them from messing with you as renters? Cancel the deal, return their deposit, fire your agent, and start over.
  • Rental Property Investor · New York, NY · Member since 2015 · 85 posts · 28 votes
    7y
    @Maria Amaro this sounds like a personal matter for the buyers and you aren‘t runnIng a charIty. They understood what their credit scores were long ago in the process and you shouldn’t be inconvenienced for any of this. In terms of earnest money, you need to go over the contract and see where you stand.
  • Southern California · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 2 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jorge Casas:
    Originally posted by @Maria Amaro:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

    Why did your agent allow you to go under contract with these buyers? Did he do absolutely zero due diligence on them? They really dropped the ball on this.

     You think so? We are not sure we will resign a contract with this agent, haven't decided yet. 

    I'm sorry but I don't agree with Russell, assuming your Realtor asked for the standard (here is SoCal at least) pre-approval letter and proof of funds, they did their part. 

    They could have also had their preferred lender cross-qualified the buyer which is recommended.

    But I don't see how your Realtor could have foreseen the buyers wanting to rent the home so that they could raise their credit score.

     It's more of an East Coast thing, just like cross-qualifying the buyer with another lender is more of a SoCal thing - up in the Bay Area listing agents often think it's a red flag for a buyer to be working with multiple lenders or real estate agents. A lot of our "norms" are actually regional norms that we don't realize are only regional.... in Illinois, there are no real estate agents, everyone is a real estate "broker." In Texas they use "options," which are not exactly the same thing as an earnest money deposit. In much of rural California, your earnest money deposit can be $1000 and no one blinks, and it might take 4 weeks to get an appraisal back. In NorCal you never speak to a title officer because it's amalgamated with escrow and they hide behind the escrow officers and are treated as the same entity with a single point of contact; but down in your neck of the words escrow might be with Chicago Title and title might be with ABC Escrow. 

    I've not bothered to get licensed outside of California because just within California is plenty enough regional variation for me to keep track of... I'd blow a gasket if a listing agent asked me to see the buyer's paystubs, but I've never been exposed to East Coast regional norms. 

    Hi Chris, I’m a little confused by your reply. What’s more of an East Coast thing? 

     Listing agents doing (what we would consider) an unusually high amount of due diligence on the buyer's financials. I too thought it was crazy when I first started reading these forums, then noticed that the folks saying that were always East Coast. I'm guessing lender expectations are just lower there, so listing agents pick up the slack. I find it interesting learning about these regional differences, how something crazy to us might be the norm elsewhere (you need to have a law degree and pass the state bar to function as what we would call an escrow officer?!), and normal stuff to us (no appraisal contingency, anyone?) is crazy elsewhere. 

    Aah I see. Thank you for clarifying.

    I’m curious to know what kind of due diligence an agent can take to foresee a buyer wanting to rent in order to raise their FICO score.

     I vet the buyer, the buyers agent, and the lender. I want to know the buyers ficos, I want a financial information sheet on them, and I want proof of funds. I want to know how many offers they have made on other properties, how many they lost out on, if any contracts have fallen apart and why. 

    Im equally vetting the buyers agent and their lender. Are they using some chop shop internet lender, or are they using a lender who has a reputation for closing, closing on time and closing without issue. Has the lender preunderwritten the buyer. Have they verified assets. How long have they been working with the buyer. Are they the actual lender doing this deal or are the buyers going to shop around and end up with a hack lender. With the agent, does the agent have a strong reputation for closing. Are they able to keep their clients expectations for the process realistic. Or are they some hack who has nonserious buyers who squirm out of deals. Are they going to keep this with the lender I vetted or allow their clients to shop around. (If they are shopping around, better believe there is going to be a nonrefundable EMD involved)

    Maybe you guys dont do that on the west coast like Chris said, but the vetting of the buyers, their agent, their lender is one of the most important aspects of my job on the listing side.  If I let a property go under contract, then have it fall apart and need to come back to the market, I literally could be responsible for tens of thousands of dollars of damage to my client. Im not going to cost my client $25k on a lower sales price because I didnt vet all the players involved. And often, I dont need to do much vetting because Im going to work with the other strong agents and lenders in the market time and time again. Reputation is paramount in this business.

     That's a lot of responsibility for the listing agent compared to here. We tried to cross qualify buyers and I believe we offended one potential buyer by doing that. 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Montgomery, NY · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    @Maria Amaro are they asking because they "want" to wait or are they not qualified without waiting therefore they can't buy the house without this rent period (although will it even help them enough to buy)? If they want to, I'd say tough and make them close on their commitment. If they don't qualify for the mortgage and can't buy the house, I would most likely not risk them somehow being able to in a few months and move on to a new buyer.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.