For long-term investing, is cashflow or appreciation better?

For long-term investing, is cashflow or appreciation better?

Member since 2019 · 222 posts · 104 votes

I'm not sure of what my opinion is on this, and would like to see what others think on the matter.

Here on BP, the mass majority of advice and articles are focused on cashflow. I see the obvious benefits of cashflow, which are the following:

  • 1) Safer in the case of a downturn. Even if property values tank, people still need a place to rent and rents may even go up.
  • 2) You can easily access the returns from cashflow, and potentially live off of cashflow passively.
  • 3) Since cashflow returns are immediate, you can reinvest those returns quickly as opposed to value locked away in equity.
  • 4) Cashflow properties are often cheaper, meaning a lower barrier for entry.
  • 5) You don't have to worry about buying at the wrong time, as you are profiting immediately.
  • 6) Predictable. You don't know for sure whether a market will appreciate or not, but you can see pretty clearly what will cashflow.

On the flipside, the benefits for appreciation:

  • 1) Higher property values, meaning you can invest more $ with less properties acquired, less time spent buying/managing/maintaining.
  • 2) Maintenance costs, and sometimes taxes, are proportionally lower in a more expensive house. 10 new roofs on a $40k house will cost a lot more than 1 roof on a $400k house.
  • 3) Loans are easier to get and better interest rate. Most banks won't even consider a $40k property, and the few that will charge higher rates or huge origination fees. You can invest more $ into real estate before hitting your 10 conventional loan limit.
  • 4) Tend to be in more desirable areas, meaning lower chances for bad tenants. Also higher chances for rent/ property value growth in the future. Most appreciation markets tend to be in areas with positive growth, whereas many cashflow markets are depressed and losing population and jobs.
  • 5) Though you may not cash flow immediately, after held for long enough it likely will, and will possibly even surpass an equal value of cashflow from cashflow properties.

I think that both make sense for different reasons, with cashflow markets being better for those who are just getting started, and those who want to aggressively scale up using the cashflow from previous properties to buy new ones. Appreciation markets seem like they would favor a more passive investor who can afford to buy and sit back for a decade or two, using the investment as a supplement to their primary income. 

I currently own property in a cashflow market, and am looking at picking up some properties in a mixed market before potentially moving into appreciation. I'd love to hear your thoughts on this complex topic.

4Reply
167 views

Most Popular Reply

Joseph CacciapagliaBusiness Member
Lender · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
5y

The real key to this analysis is your #5 under the appreciation benefits. I think the biggest benefit in most "appreciation" markets is that they tend to also have strong rent growth. I've looked at several "cash flow" versus "appreciation" scenarios over long periods of time, and in many cases the appreciation markets create more cash flow during holding periods longer than 5 years. I believe that anyone that plans to hold properties for the long term would be better off focusing on rent growth and appreciation than they would on year 1 or in-place cash flow.

I also think your discussion on being able to scale up with cash flow faster than appreciation is off base. A lot more of my investor clients scale up through cash-out refinances or 1031's than through cash flow. Let's say you're getting a 12% cash on cash return annually in your cash flow market. If you save every penny of that, it will take you 8+ years to save the same down payment that you made into that particular investment. However, with only a 3% appreciation rate, you'll have enough to put down on a second property with your accumulated equity in 4-5 years.

In reality though, most investors that scale rapidly do so by creating value, using outside income, or using other peoples' money. Neither cash flow nor appreciation on it's own will allow you to snowball your investments very rapidly. 

Joseph Cacciapaglia powered by Morty
See this reply in the discussion

35 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    @Tyler D'Alessandro

    Look for both.

    I don’t recommend a cash flowing asset in a depreciating market.

    Every market is different.

    For me the cash flow has enabled me to upgrade my properties over time without putting in “my” money post acquisition. But the real wealth generation was the appreciation over time.

    Every good deal (to me) will fall somewhere on the CF/appreciation spectrum, so it shouldn’t be one or the other.

  • Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    @Steve Vaughan

    What are your 10x value to cost improvements?

  • Rental Property Investor · East Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 10k+ posts · 16k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Max T.:

    @Steve Vaughan

    What are your 10x value to cost improvements?

     Mostly refinishing vs replacing.  Cabinets, countertops, hardwood, decks, fencing  Providing a nice used w/d set that gets $50 more per month in rent. Those are 20x returns.

    10x would be swapping carpet for laminate, sheet vinyl/linoleum for LVP, upgrading faucets and toilets. Easy DIY projects.  

  • Member since 2019 · 222 posts · 104 votes
    5y

    Here is an example of my line of thinking:

    Certain markets, like Orlando, Tampa, etc, are growing incredibly quickly, but there are close to no 1% deals. 

    For comparison, you could buy a 1% deal, or even 2% in a town that is losing population. Take most markets in the midwest for example. You can expect little to no appreciation on most of these houses. 

    Assuming 3.8% appreciation over 30 years (which is average), our Orlando/ Tampa house will have tripled in value. It's logical to assume that rents would follow, and now our Florida house is performing much better than our midwest house whose value and rents have risen much more slowly.

    That being said, this is all in theory, but the logic seems solid. Given a long enough timeframe, would you rather invest in the place that people are going to or the place that people are leaving? It seems like the smarter option to buy properties that scale up into progressively better and better investments over time, than to buy one that starts out better, but fizzles out or stagnates.

  • Member since 2019 · 222 posts · 104 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Max T.:

    @Tyler D'Alessandro

    Look for both.

    I don’t recommend a cash flowing asset in a depreciating market.

    Every market is different.

    For me the cash flow has enabled me to upgrade my properties over time without putting in “my” money post acquisition. But the real wealth generation was the appreciation over time.

    Every good deal (to me) will fall somewhere on the CF/appreciation spectrum, so it shouldn’t be one or the other.

    Do you invest in PA? It seems like you have a few markets there where you can achieve both.

    I'm particulary wary of the advice online to buy in heavy cashflow markets, many of which are depreciating and losing population. I currently own properties in one of these markets and while I doubt I will lose money, I think it could be better spent elsewhere.

    I'm also wary of the heavy appreciation, negative cashflow markets like SF/NYC. I may be missing something, but I don't see how you can expect 6%+ appreciation to continue forever when inflation hovers around 2-3%. It seems more like speculating than investing to me.

    I'm thinking the smartest strategy is to pick an area with good fundamentals for future growth, and bank on an average appreciation rate, while at the very least breaking even monthly. So I'm pretty solidly in the "both" camp as well. 

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    Tyler we're talking the same thing. Appreciation can not last forever. However few sure things that will happen:
    - we will become nation of renter because The Fed is printing money and those money goes to the stock market and ultimately real estate
    - 1% Market in Alabama and STL will be sure going to be 0.8% market in next few years, there're already changes compare to a year ago before covid (before massive low interest rate in history)
    - In your Orlando market, up until 2015, the typical R/V in your market is 0.8;  today it is 0.6-0.7 with affordability index of 31%. This is the same as in Silicon Valley market where affordability is 33% and R/V index is 0.6. 
    - There're MASSIVE BUYING as of today in some cash-flowing market, ask your local PM if want to find out
    - In most cities, the rental yields projection are going to be lower which means appreciation is going up.

    Those High CF market can generate better IRR than appreciating market if executed property.

    Summary: The trick is to  buy in CF market that's going to appreciate could generate buying the same amount of money in an appreciating market that doesnt have CF if executed and chosen wisely. IRR is your friend. There're a certain type of housing that will generate even better IRR. 

    I suggest for this kind of question you analyze yourself based on hard factual data based on some tangile research. If you have to pay, it's worth it. I made my decision based on this. People opinion doesn't generate return but data will generate return. Try to use IRR rather than CF/Appreciation alone.

  • Rental Property Investor · NJ and PA · Member since 2019 · 206 posts · 105 votes
    5y

    I haven't seen any discussion on @Tyler D.'s #4 on the appreciation side: "Tend to be in more desirable areas, meaning lower chances for bad tenants." This is very important, but not necessarily an argument against focusing on cash flow. To me, it's an argument for carefully defining cash flow, where your formula includes the costs of less desirable areas and less responsible tenants: turnover (which means vacancy and paint, cleaning, etc. at a minimum), and more likely eviction. If you bake those into the cash flow calculation, you'll quickly find the properties that appear superficially to cash flow the best, actually do not.

  • Member since 2019 · 222 posts · 104 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Carlos Ptriawan:

    Tyler we're talking the same thing. Appreciation can not last forever. However few sure things that will happen:
    - we will become nation of renter because The Fed is printing money and those money goes to the stock market and ultimately real estate
    - 1% Market in Alabama and STL will be sure going to be 0.8% market in next few years, there're already changes compare to a year ago before covid (before massive low interest rate in history)
    - In your Orlando market, up until 2015, the typical R/V in your market is 0.8;  today it is 0.6-0.7 with affordability index of 31%. This is the same as in Silicon Valley market where affordability is 33% and R/V index is 0.6. 
    - There're MASSIVE BUYING as of today in some cash-flowing market, ask your local PM if want to find out


    Those High CF market can generate better IRR than appreciating market if executed property.

    Summary: The trick is to  buy in CF market that's going to appreciate could generate buying the same amount of money in an appreciating market that doesnt have CF if executed and chosen wisely. IRR is your friend. There're a certain type of housing that will generate even better IRR. 

    I suggest for this kind of question you analyze yourself based on hard factual data based on some tangile research. If you have to pay, it's worth it. I made my decision based on this. People opinion doesn't generate return but data will generate return. Try to use IRR rather than CF/Appreciation alone.

    I am not sure what you are trying to say. If any type of hyperinflation occurs, you're going to see properties hyperappreciate, not the other way around. 

    Orlando's RTV is lower because it is a crazy hot market, and there is a ton of competition bidding up prices. 0.6% sounds optimistic for the Bay Area, maybe if you're buying a property in the hood.

    Why would lower rental yields mean more appreciation?

    I think your definition of a "cashflow market" is not the heavy cashflow midwest markets that I was mentioning earlier. Aside from Columbus, most of them are not appreciating. If you're talking mixed markets, I agree that you can have both, but you will sacrifice some initial cashflow for that appreciation on the back end.

  • Member since 2019 · 222 posts · 104 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Gary Parilis:

    I haven't seen any discussion on @Tyler D.'s #4 on the appreciation side: "Tend to be in more desirable areas, meaning lower chances for bad tenants." This is very important, but not necessarily an argument against focusing on cash flow. To me, it's an argument for carefully defining cash flow, where your formula includes the costs of less desirable areas and less responsible tenants: turnover (which means vacancy and paint, cleaning, etc. at a minimum), and more likely eviction. If you bake those into the cash flow calculation, you'll quickly find the properties that appear superficially to cash flow the best, actually do not.

     Definitely. I learned this lesson (luckily not the hard way), when I first started looking at the highest cashflowing cities like Detroit, and random cities in the boonies without a whole lot of jobs/ opportunity around. 

    I found myself many properties that had beautiful paper returns but would require managing destructive tenants, crime-infested areas, etc to get that return. 

    Sidenote: As much as I would like to get into multifamily to scale quicker, I strongly prefer SFH for this reason as well. Less tenant turnover and they will treat it more like home.

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    Tyler, reduce rental yield means higher and increasing appreciation as the profit factor for new investors reduced. The difficulty in our conversation here is I'm referring to a particular set of data that only a few subscribers can read while you are not reading this.

    I think you're too much into opinion while analyzing past observation -- it's not wrong but it's not accurate either--, while in reality, things are started to change especially due to low-interest rates and massive refinance in the market. Use data whenever possible.

    You could take a look at the Zillow home index. Most  CF neighborhoods already appreciating and has a better future projection. When you're buying at the right time and the right location, you're all set.

    I'm only trying to say 'there's a potential goldmine out there but most people don't see it yet until too late'. You need to factor more macroeconomic and analyze the future. They're the actual engine growth for appreciation and job markets.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.