HVAC vs Mini split system

HVAC vs Mini split system

Member since 2021 · 16 posts · 6 votes

Hello,

I am remodeling my multi family house (3 flats) to modern. Currently has window A/C and radiator 2 of the units. One of the unit already has central AC.

I’m really interested in HVAC, however no existing ductwork on 2 of the units.  If I need to do HVAC have to demolition ceiling, I’m okay with that. But is it worth it or split system work the same? Cost?
would split system work the same heating and cooling? I live in Chicago area I need split system to work heating the same as the cooling. Would it look modern with split system. How about in long run with split system. Any suggestions? Also any referrals who can install, with great cost.

Thank you!

5Reply
468 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Broker · Salt Lake City & Oklahoma City · Member since 2018 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
5y

Word on the street is that Split systems (common in . . . . a LOT of places other than the US) operate at a lower energy consumption rate per heating unit and cooling unit.  Means, they draw significantly less electricity to cool or heat than an electric-powered HVAC unit.  They are also simpler over the life of the unit to maintain because there are just three main components instead of four(+) with HVAC.  

It would definitely be something to consider IMO.

See this reply in the discussion

28 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Dean ValadezPro Member
    Investor · Member since 2023 · 64 posts · 11 votes
    2y

    It's been 3 years since this post first originated and am wondering if opinions/thoughts have changed. I have a 4 unit property that has forced air heat but no a/c. My tenants just use window units for a/c. The property is in WI so 80-90 degree humid days for about 2 months out of the year, another 2 months are warm/hot but not as bad. 

    I talked with an HVAC guy about mini-splits and he would charge $3500 per split. Ugg. So for 4 units that's $14k. He said since there is already forced air for the furnaces, he recommended central a/c, which is $4300. For 4 units, that's $17,200. Either way, I can't see the ROI on either of those options. (This HVAC guy did not recommend minis as he said they can go into disrepair in 3-5 years, as opposed to central a/c which lasts about 20 years.)

    Does anyone have other thoughts? Is it really $3500 for a mini-split and installation? I will call other HVAC companies but I wanted to hear from the BP community as well.

  • Investor · Glen Burnie, MD · Member since 2014 · 36 posts · 6 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Dean Valadez:

    It's been 3 years since this post first originated and am wondering if opinions/thoughts have changed. I have a 4 unit property that has forced air heat but no a/c. My tenants just use window units for a/c. The property is in WI so 80-90 degree humid days for about 2 months out of the year, another 2 months are warm/hot but not as bad. 

    I talked with an HVAC guy about mini-splits and he would charge $3500 per split. Ugg. So for 4 units that's $14k. He said since there is already forced air for the furnaces, he recommended central a/c, which is $4300. For 4 units, that's $17,200. Either way, I can't see the ROI on either of those options. (This HVAC guy did not recommend minis as he said they can go into disrepair in 3-5 years, as opposed to central a/c which lasts about 20 years.)

    Does anyone have other thoughts? Is it really $3500 for a mini-split and installation? I will call other HVAC companies but I wanted to hear from the BP community as well.

     It's hard to say if his quote is a fair price without a bit more detail about the systems they quoted.  Does this quote include equipment and labor?  Were they single-zone systems or multi-zone, if multi-zone how many head units?  What size systems and brand/models?  We actually sell HVAC equipment with 12 locations.  If those are single-zone I would say the quote is high.  As an example, in our area, we could get you a single-zone installed for as little as $1,339 for a 12,000 BTU system and about $1,950 for a 24,000 BTU system.

    As far as dependability goes, mini splits can last 20 or more years as well.  The major reason they fail is usually poor installation.  As with any system quality install and regular preventive maintenance are required.  I think the benefit of a mini split system over a central are the energy efficiency the offer, the individual control over zone cooling/heating, simpler maintenance, quite operation.

    In the end it comes down to what makes sense in your situation, but I will say that there is a lot of fear mongering among a lot of HVAC companies to push people to either central systems or if they do mini splits, then into the higher priced systems.  The truth is that many mini-split brands now have good support and available parts for any needed maintenance/repairs should you need them.  Just be sure to look into the support offered by the brand.  Obviously if you order a system from Amazon or some other place you may or may not get good support.

  • Dean ValadezPro Member
    Investor · Member since 2023 · 64 posts · 11 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Chad Huffer:
    Quote from @Dean Valadez:

    It's been 3 years since this post first originated and am wondering if opinions/thoughts have changed. I have a 4 unit property that has forced air heat but no a/c. My tenants just use window units for a/c. The property is in WI so 80-90 degree humid days for about 2 months out of the year, another 2 months are warm/hot but not as bad. 

    I talked with an HVAC guy about mini-splits and he would charge $3500 per split. Ugg. So for 4 units that's $14k. He said since there is already forced air for the furnaces, he recommended central a/c, which is $4300. For 4 units, that's $17,200. Either way, I can't see the ROI on either of those options. (This HVAC guy did not recommend minis as he said they can go into disrepair in 3-5 years, as opposed to central a/c which lasts about 20 years.)

    Does anyone have other thoughts? Is it really $3500 for a mini-split and installation? I will call other HVAC companies but I wanted to hear from the BP community as well.

     It's hard to say if his quote is a fair price without a bit more detail about the systems they quoted.  Does this quote include equipment and labor?  Were they single-zone systems or multi-zone, if multi-zone how many head units?  What size systems and brand/models?  We actually sell HVAC equipment with 12 locations.  If those are single-zone I would say the quote is high.  As an example, in our area, we could get you a single-zone installed for as little as $1,339 for a 12,000 BTU system and about $1,950 for a 24,000 BTU system.

    As far as dependability goes, mini splits can last 20 or more years as well.  The major reason they fail is usually poor installation.  As with any system quality install and regular preventive maintenance are required.  I think the benefit of a mini split system over a central are the energy efficiency the offer, the individual control over zone cooling/heating, simpler maintenance, quite operation.

    In the end it comes down to what makes sense in your situation, but I will say that there is a lot of fear mongering among a lot of HVAC companies to push people to either central systems or if they do mini splits, then into the higher priced systems.  The truth is that many mini-split brands now have good support and available parts for any needed maintenance/repairs should you need them.  Just be sure to look into the support offered by the brand.  Obviously if you order a system from Amazon or some other place you may or may not get good support.


     Thanks, Chad. That info is good to know. What model mini-split do you recommend? The quote I received was for equipment and labor, and for a single-zone. I don’t know the brand/model he would use and I should have asked. 
    For whatever brand/model you recommend, what is the cost of that mini? 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.