Seeking advice for improving returns on my portfolio of 8 units

Seeking advice for improving returns on my portfolio of 8 units

Rental Property Investor · Orlando, FL · Member since 2015 · 353 posts · 269 votes

Hello BP. I have been thinking about how I can improve my rental property portfolio consisting of 8 unit streams. I have been tracking returns on my properties with a spreadsheet I created for myself, and I have identified that 4 of the 8 units I own have been consistently underperforming the rest of the portfolio for 3 years now. I am tracking my returns based on cash flow numbers only (for conservatism reasons - I look at appreciation as icing on the cake).

A little background:

The underperforming units are all part of a small multifamily compound in a lower income neighborhood that I purchased in 2018 that looked great “on paper” but after tracking their performance for a few years, experienced less than expected returns due to one issue or another that has cropped up (more capex up front, tenant that I couldn’t evict for 10 months through covid, multiple vacancies causing turnover costs). They are older units (1960) so I will likely see other capex items sooner rather than later if I kept them for 30+ years. They have very little appreciation potential, which I don’t mind if cash flowing well. These properties have strengths of being very low mortgage cost, room to grow rents over time (they are almost 2% rule), and in a affordable rental class that seems to have a major shortage in today’s world. They still make enough cash flow to allow me to hold them if I choose.

So my questions are for experienced investors who do this sort of purge analysis on their rentals, how long do you typically give underperforming properties a chance to meet potential? Is my 3 year “leash” too short sighted if I decided to cut bait and 1031 exchange into something else newer build in a better neighborhood?

I see both pros and cons to keeping the properties in my portfolio, and I always envisioned keeping everything for 30 plus years, but I am now wondering if I should tweak my expectations. Thanks for your opinions and advice!

1Reply
268 views

Most Popular Reply

Joe VilleneuvePro Member
Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
4y

The duplexes are failures on epic proportion,  Get rid of them ASAP...sooner if possible.  They have absolutely no value, except in the equity which is useless to you...unless you sell.  So SELLLLLLL!!!!!!  EVery month your duplexes gain equity, and lose cash from negative cash flow (yes, $100/month is negative cf...just waiting to happen), they are losing money for you....big time.

Repeat after me.  "Sell, Sell, Sell, Sell,Sell,Sell,....SELLLLLLLL!!!!!!!



See this reply in the discussion

61 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2020 · 984 posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    I put several videos on youtube and there is a wealth of information showing how I do my marketing, crunch numbers, where to get free leads, how to import leads, create mail lists, do telemarketing, bulk email, direct mail and you can download the software for free with no monthly fees and no sales pitches.

    My goal is to have other investors constantly improve the software the same as Share Ware where every investor benefits from each other's efforts.

    You can find my most recent video and additions to the software on youtube by searching

    Free Real Estate Marketing Software blprei 12 05 21 and search for multi-units blprei.

    Hopefully, this does not conflict with BP's terms.

  • Member since 2020 · 984 posts · 1k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Matt Leber:

    @Justin V. Usually takes them about 2 weeks to turn and about 6 weeks to qualify someone. Takes them about a week to get the scope list to me after the tenant move out, I redline items that aren’t needed day-of and then the get their contractors going and it’s done in second week. I’ve seen it go 3 weeks if weekends or holidays get in the way of communication. They don’t start marketing until the unit is turned and showable. We usually get tons of interest bc the units are affordable class less than 800 per month, but a lot of the applicants have issues qualifying due to credit or criminal history or issues submitting all the necessary paperwork. That’s what the PM tells me is the major drag on the full time.

    I’ve considered switching PMs multiple times. I think they’re too slow too. I just always revert back to reminding myself of year 1 for these properties and losing all the original tenants bc they resisted the change from mom and pop collector to PM rules. I have a little fear I could de-rail what actually is working now by rocking the pm boat again.

    I wrote this same post several times stating that I've been renting homes and apartment units since 1965, when I was 15-years old and never did a credit check nor any type of research for one tenant. Since 1965, the only thing we ever ask applicants for is copies of the pay stubs, only the first 1 or 2 pages of their checking account statements and legitimate copies of their rent receipts for the previous 3 months.

    Then, we try to have 3 meetings with every applicant. We meet with them to show the rental units, meet a 2nd time at our office to give them an application and meet with them a 3rd time to sign a lease, but before we sign the lease we have a lengthy discussion and if the vibes are not right we come up with reasons why we don't want to sign the lease, on that day, and we blow them off. Sometimes, it turns into 4 meetings.

    The purpose for the multiple meetings is when you give applicants enough time and enough rope the bad applicants' lips always get loose and they hang thelr self with statements that are warning signs and red flags. You cannot find this same information by looking at printouts from credit reporting companies and not all people with criminal records are bad people. Some really bad people are just better than others about not getting caught and some people with criminal records did their bad during the early years of their life, grew up and changed for the better.

    We have very few problems with tenants because our lease agreement is about 21 or 24 pages and we go through everything that is important to us before signing the lease and then read every word on the lease to the tenant, slowly, and seek confirmation and agreement from the applicant during the signing.

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    @Joe Villeneuve I dont know, I will think about it - but how often do you here any other business snidely stating "my customer pays my mortgage?"  why does it even need to be said at all? whats  purpose does the phase serve?  Customers "pay" the expenses of all businesses but most businesses are smart enough not to rub their customers noses in it ;)   LLing seems to be one of the only business models where what your customer thinks of you  does not seem to matter. 

    The pandemic has really ramped up the anti LL sentiment and I honestly think we should take this issue more seriously. 

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Mary M.:

    @Joe Villeneuve I dont know, I will think about it - but how often do you here any other business snidely stating "my customer pays my mortgage?"  why does it even need to be said at all? whats  purpose does the phase serve?  Customers "pay" the expenses of all businesses but most businesses are smart enough not to rub their customers noses in it ;)   LLing seems to be one of the only business models where what your customer thinks of you  does not seem to matter. 

    The pandemic has really ramped up the anti LL sentiment and I honestly think we should take this issue more seriously. 

    Why do I say it? It is directed to REI explaining how and why their cost, and only cost, should be as small a DP as possible. Kind of important, don't ya think?

    Besides, I don't see how I'm rubbing tenant's noses in anything...particularly on a site setup for REI. Maybe I should always add a disclaimer stating my message "is for REI's eyes only".

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Well, you can say "all expenses are covered by your income"  (using the lowest downpayment is not always the best strategy but that is a discussion for a different thread)

    As for this being a REI site - you honestly dont know this site is used as a source of anti LL rhetoric? Also tenants can and do look up their LLs on google - and guess what pops up?

  • Member since 2020 · 984 posts · 1k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Mary M.:

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Well, you can say "all expenses are covered by your income"  (using the lowest downpayment is not always the best strategy but that is a discussion for a different thread)

    As for this being a REI site - you honestly dont know this site is used as a source of anti LL rhetoric? Also tenants can and do look up their LLs o google - and guess what pops up?

    I don't think tenants will  have resentment if you told them the rent they pay helps the landlord pay down the mortgage because most people on this planet, including many real estate investors, don't have a clue in regards to what that statement equates to. Don't forget that tenants already have resentment toward their landlords due to the bad ways a high percent of landlords treat their tenants with total disrespect and hatred for tenants and tenants already have a built-in belief that landlords are getting rich from the high rents they collect with an unpleasant demand every month with little regards for the condition of rental units and deferred maintenance. 

    We have many tenants who deliver their rent payments every month with a smile on their face and many tenants with a disgruntled look on their face like we landlords are ruthless for wanting to collect our rents. It is all part of dealing with the different way humans thoughts and emotions and I'm not going to give those thoughts or emotions one second of thought because I need to stay focused on what I need to to and not worry about what the tenants think.

  • Chicago · Member since 2018 · 216 posts · 165 votes
    4y

    1. You need to stop  comparing a duplex to a single family homes. 

    2. Why do you say no real appreciation in sight? My apartment buildings have not been cash flowing as projected but I keep rehabbing and improving units and pushing new tenants to market rates so I am increasing the value of the buildings. The appreciation -- helped by gentrification --  has been insane. Like a doubling of value of one building in less than two years. So what is the neighborhood like? Is it in the path of gentrification? Are you sure it will not gentrify or even appreciate that much in the future? 

    3. If you truly can't get value out of it maybe you should sell it. But I read about a really smart guy who buys anything as long as it pays for itself and he holds these things and natural appreciation has made him a multi-millionaire. 

  • Investor · Lake Worth, FL · Member since 2016 · 233 posts · 140 votes
    4y

    @Matt Leber sounds like not only is your cash on cash low but your cash on equity is very low. In this case, selling is the way to go as a cash out refinance will make your cash flow negative.

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    @Account Closed - tenants absolutely resent LLs when they say their rent is paying their mortgage...  you should read some of the tenant groups on FB for examples of how hated we are...  its not good....  and why should you care? because tenants are a powerful lobby group and they can and do change the laws to protect themselves....

  • Member since 2020 · 984 posts · 1k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Mary M.:

    @Account Closed - tenants absolutely resent LLs when they say their rent is paying their mortgage...  you should read some of the tenant groups on FB for examples of how hated we are...  its not good....  and why should you care? because tenants are a powerful lobby group and they can and do change the laws to protect themselves....

     I don't understand why. 

    Technically, you, I and everyone on this planet pays down the mortgage for every business we do business with. Is blissful ignorance the reason tenants get angry with their landlords and if that is the reason then who should care about what ignorant tenants think. 

    As landlords, we can't utilize our energy worrying about what tenants think, whether or not they are having a hard time paying the rent, or whether or not they are physically ill or lose their job because we landlords have our own burdens to worry about e.g. major expenses, increases in insurance, property taxes, non-paying tenants, liable lawsuits and we have our own personal problems, illnesses and griefs to deal with. Owning rental units has to be treated solely as a business with no personal tied or personal worries about tenants. 

    As for the worries landlords have, I am worried about the new law in California that requires landlords to get balconies inspected and retrofitted within the next year and the inspection has to be performed by some sort of engineer. I have two apartment buildings with more than 600 feet of 2nd floor balcony at each buildings and am worried about some crazy retrofitting job that could cost tens of thousands of dollars. About 15 years ago, I spent about $60,000 at each property changing all the beams and installed 600 lineal feet of ceramic tile for one balcony and all aluminum flooring on another. Do the tenants worry about whether or not I have enough money to pay those bills like some landlords worry about whether or not tenants can afford rent increases.

  • Rental Property Investor · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2016 · 214 posts · 132 votes
    4y

    @Matt Leber

    Good to know. Thank you for the details. What kind of things do you typically end up needing to repair at the turns? Are you unable to list the units prior to move out due to unpredictable move outs and a pattern of improper notice?

    I’m probably in b/b+ areas with typically good tenants who have always moved out or renewed at lease end and are generally easy on the properties. It enables the one day turn which is typically just small hole patching, touch up paint, clean with assistance from a robot vacuum, rekey quickset smart key locks, shampoo/swiffer floors as needed and small stuff (broken blinds & detector batteries). Ive had Inherited tenants with rough units where I didn’t trust them to move out on time (or on a planned date) or with proper notice, so I’ve typically planned some down time and reno work before listing, but that’s always a 1 off and then the rest of the turnovers have been smooth.

    I get the not wanting to rock the boat, but you already have so swapping from 1 pm to another shouldnt be too hard: now send the checks here and email this person. I tend to have a better time with tenants placed by myself or my pm. I have 6 sets of inherited tenants out or 20 units currently with 2 sets not likely to last. It’s usually an opportunity to put a little work in and raise rents to market when they decide to leave.

    What reasons have tenants given for leaving? With jack o.‘s post acting as reinforcement I feel like either your current pm isn’t screening hard enough for you, something is driving them away (area, pm, or conditions of property), or it’s the market/rental class you are in being a pain (I’m not at all familiar with other rental classes btw… )

    I also think you have to take the covid no-payer as an outlier and exclude him from your analysis. Chalk it up to bad luck.

    Look forward to hearing more.

    - Justin

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.