Every time I list a place, there are inevitably moms, sisters, etc., who are contacting me 'because [son/sibling/parent etc] is busy' (or sometimes away). I find this a little odd and kind of off-putting. Like you're too busy to take 2 minutes to talk to me? And you're going to live in a place you haven't even seen? I get that they want to scout, but sometimes they seemingly want to complete the whole process for them. A co-signer is fine, and I've had those pan out OK; generally not an ideal sign either, but OK.
I say that's fine if just you come to check it out, but we need to meet the actual tenant at some point 'to make sure they like it' (and to make sure they're OK). After that point either the person never shows, or they delay the process too long and it gets rented to someone else. In at least one case I think the tenant might have been mentally ill/had dementia and the family member didn't want that to be known, which is understandable.
Is this a red flag for people? It pretty much is for me at this point - has it ever turned out good/bad for you?
Yes, this is extremely common. I tell them they can look at it on behalf of whomever, but the actual individual needs to complete the application and communicate with us. We don't communicate with outsiders about someone's application or their lease.
Investor · Shelton, WA · Member since 2017 · 6k+ posts · 6k+ votes
3y
Generally I eliminate these peopl early. On two occasions I went the distance, both times it was a daughter scouting for mother. Both went through the screening process of mom’s and daughters. Both moms are still tenants and have been a few years. I accepted one daughter as co-signer. The other was not needed. So yeah worked great!
Rental Property Investor · Youngstown, OH · Member since 2023 · 128 posts · 124 votes
3y
Seconding Bjorn. At face value, it's a red flag to me, and I don't think it'd be unreasonable to simply eliminate them from the get go. But depending on the circumstances, I can be open-minded. I've had a father scope out a unit for their college student, and that was one of the best tenants I had. A little hard on the property, but they always paid on time, and never bothered me.
Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
3y
Aloha,
Usually it depends on the relationship between prospective tenant and their helper. If it is a Parent that plans on being the primary payer narrowing the field for their college student, I will allow it. If it is a son/daughter looking for an elderly parent or disabled family member, OK. If it is just a friend and the primary "can't take off work", it is always a no. It will just lead to problems with scheduling EVERYTHING from that point forward...signing the paperwork; move in inspection; any service requests; and probably paying the rent too. And I do not do multiple showings for a roommate situation...all need to be present at once. Pretty much anything else is a no. As you implied, they just are not serious enough about renting if they cannot even coordinate a showing. We also NEVER rent, or even accept an application sight un-seen by at least the primary tenant.
Deal with this all the time. It's typically the most sober individual of the group that wants to move in on behalf of the others. I find most times these are just a big waste of time. I'm a busy guy...like really busy. I always find time to take care of things. Mama working a 6 hour part time shift at dollar general and needing her afternoon nap cuz she's tired and I'm looking for her doesn't pull at my sympathy strings like they think it will
Yes, this is extremely common. I tell them they can look at it on behalf of whomever, but the actual individual needs to complete the application and communicate with us. We don't communicate with outsiders about someone's application or their lease.
My general policy is to be open-minded and give people a fair shake. So I do continue to entertain these scenarios, but yeah, it generally ends up being a waste of time. If I had more units I'd probably have had at least one success story by now.
In my experience, the problem people sort themselves out of the process 95% plus of the time (don't respond to messages, don't show up, try to show up an hour late as I sat there with thumb up my A, lie on application, regale me with tales about battling all their past landlords, explain how they're going to leave early and violate their current lease, ask what happens if they break this lease early, etc.; which it goes without saying all equate to instant No's).