Jackson, NJ · Member since 2017 · 168 posts · 48 votes
Hi All - first time this is happening to me, so looking for some helpful advice, preferably from a LL that has gone through this in NJ. I have a long time tenant that has let me know via email that she has decided to move on. I spoke with her on the phone. She wants to be with family. She says her vacate date is Dec 6. Her lease runs until Mar 2027.
I have sent her a letter outlining her liabilities under the lease and my responsibilities to re-rent the unit as well. She has not responded.
I understand my obligation to mitigate damages. That notwithstanding, I'm concerned about recovering any unpaid rent between her departure and the start of a new tenancy, assuming I'm able to find a replacement before March.
For anyone that has worked through this type of situation, what strategies have worked best.? Did you pursue the tenant for unpaid rent? If so, how? Was it successful?
Very interested in hearing from those NJ LL's that have been able to collect outstanding rent when tenant voluntarily breaks a fixed term lease.
Not legal advice, but here's how this usually goes in NJ. You have a duty to try to re-rent (NJ courts have required that since the 1970s), so list it now and keep dated proof of every listing and showing. You can only collect rent for the months it actually sits empty, plus reasonable re-letting costs. Apply the deposit first, and send the itemized list within 30 days of move-out. For anything left over, Special Civil Part small claims handles up to $5,000 and you don't need a lawyer. Before you file, a written settlement offer like 'pay X and I'll release you once it's re-rented' often gets paid faster than a judgment.
John, not legal advice, and NJ has its own rules, so a local attorney or your county's landlord association is worth a quick call before you file anything. On the process side, what usually helps is a paper trail that shows you tried to re-rent:
Relist now and save dated screenshots of every listing, price, and showing.
Do a move-out walkthrough the day she leaves, with dated photos you can compare against the move-in condition report.
Keep a simple ledger: rent owed by month, re-letting costs (ads, turnover cleaning), the deposit applied, and the balance left.
Send her an itemized statement in writing and keep a copy.
Once a new tenant signs, the claim is usually only the gap months plus costs. It's a lot easier to settle or take to small claims when that ledger is clean and dated.
Start by getting everything in writing while the tenant is still cooperative. Confirm the move out date, the condition the unit will be left in, and what they are offering toward the remaining rent, in an email or a signed note. Then price the real gap: rent through March, minus the time you realistically need to re-rent, because in New Jersey you have a duty to mitigate, and a judge will ask what you did to fill the unit. List it the day you have access, keep records of showings and applications, and document every week it sits empty. Offer a clean exit in exchange for something concrete, like a lump sum for two months plus forfeiting the deposit as a lease break fee, if the lease allows it. If they walk away owing money, send a written demand with the ledger attached, then small claims court is the realistic path for a few thousand dollars. A collection agency will take a big cut and a judgment only helps if they have wages or assets to collect against.
Not a lawyer, so I'll leave the collection side to Ezra and Logan, but the part you control most is how short the gap is. Dec 6 is about the slowest week of the year to start a vacancy, so I'd use the time before she leaves:
- ask her now for showing access while she's still there (she has every reason to help, since a shorter gap is better for her too)
- get photos and the listing up this week instead of after move-out
- price it to fill in December. $75 under market is $900 a year, a second empty month is the whole rent
- think about a lease term for the new tenant that ends in late spring or summer so you're not relisting in winter again
The smaller the gap, the smaller the number you're chasing, and a tenant who left on decent terms is a lot more likely to just pay a small balance. Has she said whether she'd cooperate with showings?