I bought my first property earlier this year in Chicago and it has a sump pump in the basement unit. Being that this is my first property and I have never dealt with sump pumps before I had someone come out and look at it. He said everything was working well although he couldn't tell how old the actual pump was. He also mentioned that I should consider getting a backup in case the power goes out during a storm. I asked him for a quote and it came back around $3600 which includes a new pump as well as the backup with two batteries.
My question to experienced investors and home owners, is getting a backup worth the money? Has anyone ever had a basement flood because the power went out and there was no backup? I have no issues spending that kind of money but I just would like to know if it is worth it or if backups really aren't used in the Chicago area.
Thanks in advance for your replies.
Tim
A finished basement should have a good reliable pump with battery backup. Chicago has combined sewers and MWRD can't keep up with the load during storms.
The pit and start stop actuators must be designed so the pump runs for about a minute or a minute and a half. Anything shorter than that will reduce the useful life of your equipment. Ask your plumber to run the calcs. Get a pump curve indicating rating gpm capacity and pump head.
Zoeller is a great brand. Metropolitan Pump in Romeoville has great options. Buy a good product.
Get a detailed bid from your plumber, $3,600 goes a long way, and sump pumps are not that expensive.
Best,
Frank
I can only give you my experience with Sump Pumps and I am not an expert. I have sump pumps in 3 of my properties and even in my own house. I think they are great and do their job when installed correctly.
I've had one installed for as little as 1200 bucks, all included. That's here in Atlanta though. I think the key is making sure to put the pump where the water willl collect or diverting the water to the pump so it does it's job correctly. That additional work could push the price higher.
I don't have backups on any of my properties. Actually I've never heard of having a backup just for the sump pump. Sounds logical but I haven't been bit yet for that reason.
Does the electricity go out that often in that area? Is the basement a living space or just a storage / unfinished space?
Hemanth
Tim, we should have a sump pump support group!
Actually mine is in a crawl space and we have developed quite a relationship (she is a 1/3 horse Zoeller), but I do have a new back up ready to drop should she fail in my storage closet. My back up is more for when she starts to go out....
Yes, in power outages, she would not work, but when they kick on, it pumps it all out in minutes, and I just have a dirt crawlspace with vapor barrier so some water is less risk for me....
If you have one of uncertain age, actually I might have a back up ready (not just for power outs) because you have to call the plumber, who may or may not have the one you want and may mark it way up. And mine is REALLY easy to drop in and attach (see the manual)...
So yes on back up just in case from me.... And on Chicago power outs, keep investigating, but my favorite brand (and the one in my master plumber's crawl space) is a Zoeller like this (600 bucks for model with battery, which I don't have) so three grand to hook it to a piece of pipe seems high, but maybe your plumber has a higher end, higher capacity pump... Keep researching price and need..
http://www.zoro.com/zoeller-sump-pump-wbattery-bac...
Best of Luck
@Hemanth Grandhige The basement is a finished unit which I live in now and will rent when I move out. And although it doesn't happen often, Chicago does experience outages during major storms. Fortunately I personally have never had an outage last longer than overnight until the power comes back on.
@Michael Boyer The replacement would be a 3/4 HP pump. The backup has two batteries which would last for 6 hours each unless there is an extreme storm and it would be pumping constantly in which case it would last about 4 hours.
See if you can price that same brand in 3/4 with the battery pack... It may still be under a grand... A finished basement is worth protecting. So you could have a back up in your garage anyway...
Ultimately, you will have to make the decision on the battery backed one... Call some plumbing places and ask about whether it is the recommended norm and about pricing.... I think your plumber's bid could be building second pit for the back up pump (my guess on the price)..
It may be an ok price if he is cracking in to make a second pit and pump and hard piping it out separately or with the current outflow...
I am not sure if you are planning to drop in the battery powered pump when power goes out (which seems odd if you were away, defeats purpose) or if he has a second pump put in and it is on standby (maybe by elevation or overflow, I am not a plumber.. Just got to know mine well, dug the pit myself)..
Or maybe the batteries go on a single existing pump....??
Get a scope of work for a bid and see exactly what is entailed...It would be hard to say without specifics. Find out more about exactly what he will be doing (I mean there are even little cheap emergency back up pumps at HD for 150 bucks--but the 3/4 makes me think you are moving some water and this may have some larger work behind it)..
@Account Closed, Call Vince Tinc. A year ago I was quoter about $500-$600. :)
$3600 seems crazy. I just installed a pump (not a battery backup pump) just a replacement sump pump for $600 parts and labor (and he did a few other minor plumbing things while there)
PM me if you want the guys info.
A finished basement should have a good reliable pump with battery backup. Chicago has combined sewers and MWRD can't keep up with the load during storms.
The pit and start stop actuators must be designed so the pump runs for about a minute or a minute and a half. Anything shorter than that will reduce the useful life of your equipment. Ask your plumber to run the calcs. Get a pump curve indicating rating gpm capacity and pump head.
Zoeller is a great brand. Metropolitan Pump in Romeoville has great options. Buy a good product.
Get a detailed bid from your plumber, $3,600 goes a long way, and sump pumps are not that expensive.
Best,
Frank
We get a LOT of water during our 'wet' season & snow melt!!!
After many years of swapping pumps out every 18 months to avoid failure (usually impellers) I now only use good quality heavy duty 'sewage/solids' pumps ($215) & the last one has been in there 4 years. I always have good quality backups on hand because when one fails the stores are usually sold out. But again they only work if you have 'power' & a functioning float switch (also spares on hand). I only buy those with a detectable float switch mechanism for that reason. I can swap out my entire pump system in <30 minutes.
I have tried all sorts of backups, battery, water & double units. But we have had power failures for several days at a time so the 6 hr battery backup is moot. Up here for the price quoted you could install a small NG Generator that would eliminate all future power issues. Our 14 year old NG generator has been a life saver with the longest loss of power being 5 days in the middle of winter.
I also notice a lot of installed units simply pump the water out against the building so the pump is constantly running as that water seeps back into sump tank burning out the cheaper motors prematurely. We corrected that same issue on a SFR with 2 sump pumps. The old larger pump literally burned out & the cheaper secondary finally gave up.
Good luck.
water powered sump pump: they run on city pressure water. (@Pat L. mentioned them "water units")
This-Old-House has 2 shows mentioning type of sump pumps....
Chicago experienced some flooded basement/houses either because primary sump pump give the ghost, battery backup drained because of extensive periods of power outs, local sewer system....
One brand is called BASEPUMP. (shout out to @Scott Weaner for mentioning it)