Reasonable time for repair/replace oven?

Reasonable time for repair/replace oven?

Greenwood, IN · Member since 2013 · 346 posts · 93 votes

Tenant called on saturday afternoon, indicating there was an issue with the oven and is not working.

I called some appliance repair companies on saturday, but of course most aren't working and returned my call on Monday. I scheduled for service on Tuesday during the day, as the tenant said that was fine. 20 mins later the tenant texts back and says, they won't be there and they must be there while the appliance repair is taking place. One of them gets home at 5:30pm. Most appliance places stop service calls at 6. Giving me a 30minute window to work with. Currently. I have someone scheduled to come out on Wednesday to look at it.

The tenant believes this is an unreasonable turnaround time for a repair of an oven. She says she doesn't know how she is going to eat. Which kinda through me. As the tenant has a microwave and a working fridge, and is within a 1 mile radius of 20 places to eat. Apparently, she spent all her money on groceries, and is out of microwavable food. And she has no money to eat, and no way to cook the food, and it's my fault.  Before we even fix the problem, she is hinting that she believes she deserves a deduction in rent of 15 dollars a day from the time the problem was reported. Which I indicated is not something I can do.

To me this all seems unreasonable. If we were taking heat going out in the winter, or AC going out in some of the hottest days of the year, or no running water. These things I deem an emergency.

An oven going out, while I understand it's an inconvenience, isn't an emergency, however it's something I will get repaired as soon as possible and act on, as soon as I hear the request.

However, Monday is the time I am able to schedule with the companies, then add they are making it hard for a particular time that works for them, the service guy has to come out on Wednesday, if he has parts it fixed then. If not, he has to order parts and it could be a few more days. Considering the oven is only 3 years old. I believe I have an obligation to see if it can be repaired.

I would say  if the oven is repaired within a week, that would be reasonable.

What does everybody else think?  What would be a reasonable turn around time in this situation for your business?

Am I wrong?

0Reply
356 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2017 · 54 posts · 44 votes
9y

I only manage a couple of properties so take my $0.02 for what it's worth.

I always have my service providers call the tenant and schedule directly with them.  That way, the tenant is responsible for managing their own schedule and any delay in the problem getting repaired is on them.  I've found that most service providers have fairly flexible schedules and can get the job done in a time that is convenient for the tenant's work schedule.

See this reply in the discussion

30 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Greenwood, IN · Member since 2013 · 346 posts · 93 votes
    9y

    Just an update. The issue with the oven, ended up being a shorted out light for the oven, the wires arched and caused the spark they saw.

    Repair man came out last night, and adjusted the wires so they could use the oven, while the part is being ordered.

    The issue was addressed in 2 business days. Perfectly acceptable in anyone's world.

  • Greenwood, IN · Member since 2013 · 346 posts · 93 votes
    9y

    Follow up question.

    These appliance repair places really get you.

    They are quoting 174. to replace the oven light switch.

    That is coming out diagnosing it, and then coming back and installing it.

    Since I see the part quoted online at 15-20 bucks.

    Does this seem reasonable?

  • BIsbee, AZ · Member since 2018 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    8y

    Gabe now your upset about repair costs, I think spare stoves to throw in are a good idea in the future.  I’m curious how many rental units you have and how you got into the business of renting? How long have you been a landlord? 

    I liked the ideas that some others had to provide temp replacement toaster oven. And someone should always be at residence in my opinion when there are repairs. It is hard to have disruptions in life, but this stuff happens , things break right! she may have just spent her last $ on food for an oven, she is stressed . I don’t know her, I’m just relating. A little kindness goes a long way, a gift certificate to Macdonald’s would be a nice gesture. Meet people halfway? 

    To the group at large what is reasonable when you as landlord want to fix something rather than quick get in and out replacement , and let resident get on with their life? This is not a comment to this oven, but read below.

    I rent, the hot water heater started failing on Nov27,  11 service calls to trouble shoot later and now feb 3rd. They have refused to replace as the manufacturing life says 15-20 years and its nine years old. I’ve lost hot water at least 30 times mid shower, I only started a journal in January. So it’s acctually 45 -60 . They are coming back this week to rescale again, it’s a automatic one not a tank, suppose to give continual hot water.

    Now I’m being seen as “difficult” when I’ve been very cooperative for first five weeks and first 7 service calls. I have not asked for compensation, I have boiled water for dishes and baths. I paid rent on time this month, one day “late” last month (on the second /tech late is the 5th).  I’ve googled reasonable rights law regarding I can’t find my rights online. They are technically responding but I disagree with a reasonable approach in a rental unit, maybe for your own house!

    Thank you for your time anyone who responds! Oh I live in Arizona

  • Member since 2021 · 402 posts · 277 votes
    5y

    appliances are there for the tenants' convenience. additionally a broken oven does not make a property uninhabitable. that means is some states you may have as little as 30 days to repair or more. again, if you contract specifies that the tenants are responsible for the fixes with the proof of the repairs done professionally that is what needs to happen. If they do not pay, I take it out of their security deposit.

  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    5y

    First, the tenant is unreasonable. $15 a day rent reduction for an oven? If rent is $2,000 a month then a daily rate is $67. Does the oven comprise 1/5 of the value of the home? I don't think so. And what happens if your oven goes out? Does your mortgage company give you a deduction if you have to go without an oven for two days? Get serious.

    Second, if the tenant wants the repair done quickly, they need to be responsive to the vendor's schedule. Vendors have other jobs and personal lives to deal with and can't be available 24/7. If your tenant insists on being home, let them know it may cause delays in repair.

    Finally, my rule of thumb is to consider replacing the appliance if it's around 10 years old or older. At that point, repairs aren't worth it because you can typically purchase a gently used appliance for the cost of a repair. You're going to spend $200 or more and you can probably find a like-new unit for that price.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7246 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.