Renting to a violent felon?

Renting to a violent felon?

San Francisco, CA · Member since 2016 · 193 posts · 98 votes

Hey y'all,

I know this post is going to seem so rookie to a lot of you but here we go I need your help... I had a potential tenant come by last week (alone) and fell in love with the property... It's not rented yet and she wanted to come by again with her husband and 2 children, which they did tonight... They were pretty much instant friends with me, my mom, and niece and applied before even leaving my house... 

Well low risk credit scores, no evictions, but wait spouse has a murder conviction?!!!... Oh boy... So it was explained to me what happened by the wife he was 17 and went to jail for 25 years and got out 2 years ago...

I'm not a type of person that won't give someone a shot... He left the state it happened when he got out started a new life has a job for nearly a year and is ready to be done with that part of his life...

My question is what type of liability could this open me up to if any? I read that in some states landlords have been sued for knowing about a violent past and something happening at the unit... This is a 2 unit current house hack but I won't be here forever... Am I opening myself up to potential liability issues in the future? Or is it okay to rent to someone that is done with their past and just wants to move on???? 

19Reply
367 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2017 · 861 posts · 1k+ votes
5y

I will flip it around a little bit, if you develop your screening standards beforehand, you won't have this dilemma on your hands.  I haven't run into this myself, but if you decline one applicant for reason X, but accept another applicant even though they also had reason X, someone might make the case it was due to the first applicant being part of a protected class. 

There is a mega-landlord in my state that publishes their rental criteria, and I like their document for being a good model to work off of when developing your own criteria:    https://www.vinebrookhomes.com...     Page 3 has a nice table.  (I am not at all connected to this company) 

See this reply in the discussion

101 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2020 · 671 posts · 937 votes
    5y

    @MarieChele Porter

    Welp.  As I'm now emotionally invested, curiosity has gotten the best of me.  Is there resolution that you can share with us?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.