Try not to react too quickly to tenants' call. It's case by case. Many "emergency" issues are not true emergency, and not many issues happen late at night because tenants are not doing much during that time (normally things break when being used). Best is try to understand the situation and decide. I had one call at night for sewage clog-up, but the it was not too severe that I can wait until the next morning to bring in plumber. If it was flooding the house, then I would react differently.
This isn't perfect, but helps a little. I give all of my tenants my business card, which has has my office and cell phone (and the address to send rent to - one less excuse!). I tell tenants to call me at the office first. On my office voice mail, the recording says to leave a message or call my cell phone with a TRUE emergency and I give the cell phone number there too.
When I get calls, I screen them to determine what is truly an emergency. No heat late Friday night when it is 10 degrees outside qualifies, my shower faucet handle just broke but I got the water shut off does not qualify. I then call the appropriate contractor to handle it. If it is what I consider more of a nuisance issue or a routine service call, then I schedule it as soon as I can get to it without paying overtime or after-hours fees.
It is rare that I go to after hours service calls personally, with the exception of fire or major police calls (break-in, alarm sounding at a commercial property, etc.). It is also rare that I answer the phone late at night, unless I see it is the alarm company or I recognize the number as belonging to a tenant that would NOT call me unless it was an emergency. I do, however, listen to the message right after it is left to qualify it as urgent/emergency or not.
That is the long way of saying that I make myself available, but not TOO available, if that makes sense.
All my tenants have my cell number and I turn my ringer off at about 9pm every night. They know they can call and leave a message or text me and I will respond at a reasonable hour typically the next morning when I wake up and get their family to a safe place in the event it is that kind of emergency.
Try not to react too quickly to tenants' call. It's case by case. Many "emergency" issues are not true emergency, and not many issues happen late at night because tenants are not doing much during that time (normally things break when being used). Best is try to understand the situation and decide. I had one call at night for sewage clog-up, but the it was not too severe that I can wait until the next morning to bring in plumber. If it was flooding the house, then I would react differently.
The only "emergencies" I jump to are when the AC goes out and it is 105 degrees outside.
Typically if it is a water leak flooding the house situation I would very much like to know as it can cause a large amount of damage. To mitigate this event a) the tenants were shown where the shutoff valve is and b) they have been told that they can call the City 24/7 to come shut off the water at the mains.