Investor · Atlanta · Member since 2019 · 602 posts · 102 votes
Hi, I see south Atlanta home prices cheaper than north atlanta area. But rents also low in south Atlanta. I see north Atlanta homes selling like 3 times compared to south Atlanta. School ratings also better on north Atlanta. As a landlord what crucial factors I have to consider like evictions etc. Is it better to wait long long time and purchase sfh in north Atlanta for half to one million making 4000$ rent hopefully or buy 200k south side sfh home and get rents around 1700$ in this slower times. Please advise
Run the rent against the price, not the school rating. North Atlanta at $500K-$1M for $4,000 rent is 0.4-0.8% — that doesn't hit the 1% rule, and it won't carry a DSCR loan at 70-80% LTV on rent alone. South Atlanta at $200K for $1,700 rent is 0.85% — closer, and the math is plain before you buy.
I buy single-family in Memphis for the same reason: under $100K, ARV $180K-$265K, 3BR+ Section 8 rent $1,395-$1,950. That's rent that actually covers the payment, taxes, insurance, and a real allowance for maintenance and vacancy.
On landlord factors, look at the same numbers in both areas: how long a unit sits vacant, turnover cost, and whether the rent holds if a tenant leaves. A cheaper house that rents steady beats an expensive house that only works if you wait a long time and hope appreciation saves it. Buy the rent, not the ZIP.
Hi Gp — James laid out the math really well, so I'll add the part I see most as an agent. The north-versus-south question is really a street-by-street question, not a side-of-town question: two homes a few blocks apart can have very different vacancy, turnover, and maintenance histories, so I'd underwrite each property on its own numbers rather than the area's averages. On landlord factors, I'd weigh how quickly homes lease in that specific pocket, what condition the home is in — a cheaper purchase that needs a roof or an HVAC in year one isn't actually cheaper — and how strong the local property management and screening process is. I'd also talk with a local landlord attorney about eviction timelines in that county before you buy, since that varies a lot. My general rule: buy a home that works on today's rent, not one that only works if appreciation bails you out.
South of atlanta you will experience longer vacancies, tenant quality being lower, much less (or no) appreciation, but you will get much more cash flow.
North of atlanta and the surrounding suburbs will have higher price points, lower vacancy, better tenant quality, less evictions, and much more appreciation.
I usually try to find sitting deals in the north metro areas that are being ignored by the general market, doing some light rehabs, renting them out.
First few years will come at negative cashflow but you'll benefit from appreciation keeping your equity stable and eventually cash flow very well as rent goes up and you are able to refinance one day.