Best Areas to buy my first rental property?

Best Areas to buy my first rental property?

New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes

Hello all, 

I'm a newbie investor (to be) based in San Francisco. I've been doing a lot of reading and learning for the past two years. I have decided to invest in Pittsburgh (rental) and I was wondering what would be some of the best areas to look into? I'm familiar with the city's history and most areas (virtually) and plan on visiting as soon as the current situation (Covid-19) allows. 

A bit more about myself: $110k cash, 810 credit score, no debt. I'm thinking of getting a duplex in or near a class B or C neighborhood. 

Thanks, 

Terry

5Reply
101 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2020 · 35 posts · 11 votes
6y

@Terry Louwerse@Terry Louwerse I agree with @Jeremy Lee with some of the areas (Brookline, Beechview, Dormont) to look into. Those are my areas of interest. I too am a new local real estate investor in Pittsburgh. Recently, I put my first duplex, in Brookline, under contract in March. The coronavirus virus has halted the inspection and closing. I will be owner occupying living in one side and renting out the other. This will be my entry into real estate investing, eventually I will repeat turning this into a proper rental investment.

See this reply in the discussion

41 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2017 · 41 posts · 20 votes
    6y

    Terry, 

    Welcome to BP! 

    Pittsburgh is very diverse in terms of home prices and areas. There are houses priced between $10k to 1 million +.

    Maybe a good place to start is to create a 'profile' of the types of tenants you want living in your property - how much do they make, where they work, etc. Based on that look at rental listings where there are duplexes for $110k and see if your tenant 'profiles' make 3x the income to afford the rent and if you can picture them living there as your tenants. 

    A couple areas to look at:

    B areas: crafton, beechview, brookline, dormont

    C areas: sheradan, munhall, homestead

    You can probably get a duplex in a C area for that price, it may be more difficult to get a duplex in a B area. 

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y

    Hi Jeremy, 

    Thanks for your your first reply to my first post :)

    Yes, I have been looking on Zillow and I see a fair amount of houses I can afford all over town. I will look in the areas you mentioned. 

    And just to clarify, I'm not only looking for a duplex. SFHs are good too as long as number make sense. And my price range is above what I have cash right now. I can get a mortgage for a property up to $300k. 

    Cheers!

    T

     

  • Real Estate Agent · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2014 · 822 posts · 255 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse Pittsburgh has a lot of options both for SFH and MFH but as you know Pittsburgh neighborhoods, and their properties, often change street by street. Sending you a message....Thanks, Gary

  • Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2020 · 35 posts · 11 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse@Terry Louwerse I agree with @Jeremy Lee with some of the areas (Brookline, Beechview, Dormont) to look into. Those are my areas of interest. I too am a new local real estate investor in Pittsburgh. Recently, I put my first duplex, in Brookline, under contract in March. The coronavirus virus has halted the inspection and closing. I will be owner occupying living in one side and renting out the other. This will be my entry into real estate investing, eventually I will repeat turning this into a proper rental investment.

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Gary Swank:

    @Terry Louwerse Pittsburgh has a lot of options both for SFH and MFH but as you know Pittsburgh neighborhoods, and their properties, often change street by street. Sending you a message....Thanks, Gary

    Exactly! That's why I want to start getting familiar with sub-neighborhoods and areas so I know where to look once I get there. 

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Javonn Musgrove:

    @Terry Louwerse@Terry Louwerse I agree with @Jeremy Lee with some of the areas (Brookline, Beechview, Dormont) to look into. Those are my areas of interest. I too am a new local real estate investor in Pittsburgh. Recently, I put my first duplex, in Brookline, under contract in March. The coronavirus virus has halted the inspection and closing. I will be owner occupying living in one side and renting out the other. This will be my entry into real estate investing, eventually I will repeat turning this into a proper rental investment.

    Awesome, looks like you're a few steps ahead of me. I wish I could do house-hacking here in SF but there's absolutely no way I can even dream of doing that. 

  • Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2020 · 35 posts · 11 votes
    6y

    Thank you! I just started in January of this year. My mentor, private lender, known to me as dad, is an active investor in the Pittsburgh market as well. He is not as far as you but he invest from Philadelphia. 

    One thing he is currently teaching me about is private money/lenders. With $110K cash, you could save a good portion of that by financing deals with other people's money (OPM)/private money. You would be able to buy more than one property with that cash in the right area(s) of Pittsburgh.  

  • Jeremy TaggartBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2014 · 850 posts · 647 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse Are you looking at 110k all in or planning on leveraging and have 110k for down payments? Generally speaking, 150-200k will get you a decent duplex in a B area, and 100-150k in a C area here. You can get sub 100k in the D areas near the city or C areas 30+ mins from downtown. Most B areas are at about the 1% rule, and C gets you a little closer to 1.5% cash flow wise.  

    DHRE- The Jeremy Taggart Team590 Reviews
    View Page
  • Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2015 · 56 posts · 24 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse, I agree with the thoughts in this chat. I'm an investor in Pittsburgh as well and I think that your $110k can go a long way, depending on how you want to use it. If you are willing to use that type of money for a down payment, you may want to look in Oakland where the universities are (Pitt, Carnegie Mellon, Carlow, Chatam, and Duquesne is close by). I currently invest on the Northside where I'm from and there are some good rentals in the 15212, 15214 zip codes. For example, theres a duplex on Massachusetts on the Northside going for $125k. Brighton Heights, The Mexican War Streets, Bellevue, and Avalon may also interest you. 

    If you want to purchase homes free and clear, you can walk away with two properties for that type of cash. Either way, you are in a position of power for our area. 

    @Javonn Musgrove good luck with your transaction. I hope that you can close that deal and get jump started with your investment career through house hacking. I entered the game that way and I recommend that all new investors use that strategy if you can. 

    Good luck fellas. 

  • Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2020 · 62 posts · 23 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse Hi Terry!

    WOW - $110k saved is amazing. Tell me your tips for achieving such a sizeable down payment? High paying job? Living below your means?

    Warmly,

    AJ

  • Sunnyvale, CA · Member since 2018 · 191 posts · 178 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse hey, I’m was in a similar boat: From SF but I actually decided to move to pgh. I don’t know how long you lived in the Bay Area but the first thing I had to do was unlearn everything I thought I knew about real estate. Pricing, size, age, tenant class. Since the housing stock is so old here, quality plays a much bigger role than just picking a a nice looking house on the outside. I am still learning the rehab and management side of things.

    I guess the few things I’ve picked up on:

    Upper Saint Clair and Fox Chapel got the good school district.

    The city prosper of Pittsburgh and the rest of the greater Pittsburgh area are very different.

    I’m just going to say it, Pittsburgh is rapidly gentrifying.

    There are many ways to invest here: 50-100k houses half an hour away from downtown. 100k-150k houses half an hour away from downtown. 150k-400k houses half an hour away from downtown. Take your pick!!

  • Denver, CO · Member since 2017 · 38 posts · 14 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse there are opportunities in many places, depending on what criteria you set that defines a good deal for you.
    Also remember to assemble your core 4 long distance investing team (thanks David Greene!):

    1. Deal Finder
    2. Property Manager
    3. Contractor
    4. Lender

    More details here, good luck!

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Javonn Musgrove:

    Thank you! I just started in January of this year. My mentor, private lender, known to me as dad, is an active investor in the Pittsburgh market as well. He is not as far as you but he invest from Philadelphia. 

    One thing he is currently teaching me about is private money/lenders. With $110K cash, you could save a good portion of that by financing deals with other people's money (OPM)/private money. You would be able to buy more than one property with that cash in the right area(s) of Pittsburgh.  

    That's great that you have someone close and trustworthy to learn from!

    Yes, currently reading about that (lenders/OPM). 

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Jeremy Taggart:

    @Terry Louwerse Are you looking at 110k all in or planning on leveraging and have 110k for down payments? Generally speaking, 150-200k will get you a decent duplex in a B area, and 100-150k in a C area here. You can get sub 100k in the D areas near the city or C areas 30+ mins from downtown. Most B areas are at about the 1% rule, and C gets you a little closer to 1.5% cash flow wise.  

    Right now I'm unsure about which approach to take (still learning about this part) but open to whatever makes financial sense. 

    Thanks for the info. Is there a place where I can see a map or list of letter classification areas for Pittsburgh? Or is it something I'll gradually learn as I read and speak with locals?

    Thanks. 

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Kesete Thompkins:

    @Terry Louwerse, I agree with the thoughts in this chat. I'm an investor in Pittsburgh as well and I think that your $110k can go a long way, depending on how you want to use it. If you are willing to use that type of money for a down payment, you may want to look in Oakland where the universities are (Pitt, Carnegie Mellon, Carlow, Chatam, and Duquesne is close by). I currently invest on the Northside where I'm from and there are some good rentals in the 15212, 15214 zip codes. For example, theres a duplex on Massachusetts on the Northside going for $125k. Brighton Heights, The Mexican War Streets, Bellevue, and Avalon may also interest you. 

    If you want to purchase homes free and clear, you can walk away with two properties for that type of cash. Either way, you are in a position of power for our area. 

    @Javonn Musgrove good luck with your transaction. I hope that you can close that deal and get jump started with your investment career through house hacking. I entered the game that way and I recommend that all new investors use that strategy if you can. 

    Good luck fellas. 

    Thanks for the info Kesete. That sounds good. I guess I'll wait for the pandemic to end and go there and spend a week or two seeing places and getting familiar with the area. Do you generally find properties through agents or online (Zillow, etc)?

    Cheers!

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Kesete Thompkins:

    @Terry Louwerse, I agree with the thoughts in this chat. I'm an investor in Pittsburgh as well and I think that your $110k can go a long way, depending on how you want to use it. If you are willing to use that type of money for a down payment, you may want to look in Oakland where the universities are (Pitt, Carnegie Mellon, Carlow, Chatam, and Duquesne is close by). I currently invest on the Northside where I'm from and there are some good rentals in the 15212, 15214 zip codes. For example, theres a duplex on Massachusetts on the Northside going for $125k. Brighton Heights, The Mexican War Streets, Bellevue, and Avalon may also interest you. 

    If you want to purchase homes free and clear, you can walk away with two properties for that type of cash. Either way, you are in a position of power for our area. 

    @Javonn Musgrove good luck with your transaction. I hope that you can close that deal and get jump started with your investment career through house hacking. I entered the game that way and I recommend that all new investors use that strategy if you can. 

    Good luck fellas. 

    Thanks for the info Kesete. That sounds good. I guess I'll wait for the pandemic to end and go there and spend a week or two seeing places and getting familiar with the area. Do you generally find properties through agents or online (Zillow, etc)?

    Cheers!

  • Jeremy TaggartBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2014 · 850 posts · 647 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse It's kind of hard to generalize areas here because you can have one neighborhood range from A-D and everything in between, depending on the street or part of the neighborhood. Very street by street here with a lot of neighborhoods having nice pockets and bad pockets. Crime maps like on Trulia can help give an indication and searching specific neighborhood names on city-data can give you a good insight on each of the individual areas, besides for learning from people that are here in the trenches. Home prices are a good indication as well. If you search comps on zillow or realtor you can sort by price and see which parts of town are selling for certain prices. 

    DHRE- The Jeremy Taggart Team590 Reviews
    View Page
  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Alleia James:

    @Terry Louwerse Hi Terry!

    WOW - $110k saved is amazing. Tell me your tips for achieving such a sizeable down payment? High paying job? Living below your means?

    Warmly,

    AJ

    Hi Alleia. I don't have any particular tips other than "make more than you spend" but I'm able to save 3/4k a month because: I don't have kids, no mortgage/debt, no car/gas/insurance and very low rent. My salary is considered to be low here in the Bay Area (I work in public education) but I do make much more than I need to live on. I'm not a big spender but don't skimp on buying good quality groceries and go on vacations abroad about 3 months/year altogether. With that said, I'm totally unable to buy anything in my area for my purpose (rental investment). The SF Bay Area and California so damn expensive!

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Derek Hutson:

    @Terry Louwerse there are opportunities in many places, depending on what criteria you set that defines a good deal for you.
    Also remember to assemble your core 4 long distance investing team (thanks David Greene!):

    1. Deal Finder
    2. Property Manager
    3. Contractor
    4. Lender

    More details here, good luck!

    Thanks Derek! Actually, I just bought David's book a few days ago :)

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Jeremy Taggart:

    @Terry Louwerse It's kind of hard to generalize areas here because you can have one neighborhood range from A-D and everything in between, depending on the street or part of the neighborhood. Very street by street here with a lot of neighborhoods having nice pockets and bad pockets. Crime maps like on Trulia can help give an indication and searching specific neighborhood names on city-data can give you a good insight on each of the individual areas, besides for learning from people that are here in the trenches. Home prices are a good indication as well. If you search comps on zillow or realtor you can sort by price and see which parts of town are selling for certain prices. 

    Gotcha! That's what I thought. It's a bit different in SF. Generally we go by district but there are a few newly developed areas (Hunter's Point, Dogpatch etc) were you can have that type of setup (one block is "high end" and down the street there are projects and/or high crime). 

  • New to Real Estate · San Francisco · Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 20 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Steven Ko:

    @Terry Louwerse hey, I’m was in a similar boat: From SF but I actually decided to move to pgh. I don’t know how long you lived in the Bay Area but the first thing I had to do was unlearn everything I thought I knew about real estate. Pricing, size, age, tenant class. Since the housing stock is so old here, quality plays a much bigger role than just picking a a nice looking house on the outside. I am still learning the rehab and management side of things.

    I guess the few things I’ve picked up on:

    Upper Saint Clair and Fox Chapel got the good school district.

    The city prosper of Pittsburgh and the rest of the greater Pittsburgh area are very different.

    I’m just going to say it, Pittsburgh is rapidly gentrifying.

    There are many ways to invest here: 50-100k houses half an hour away from downtown. 100k-150k houses half an hour away from downtown. 150k-400k houses half an hour away from downtown. Take your pick!!

    Thanks for the tips, Steve. May I ask what made you move from SF to Pgh? I've been in SF for 20 years now and thinking about moving (to another state or another country) in 4-5 years. 

    I've been reading about good out of state markets for a while and couldn't make up my mind (Vegas, Tampa, Jacksonville etc). Once I did an online search to see what would be a good/affordable city for educators to live in and Pittsburgh was mentioned in all articles I found. Then I looked on BP and saw that in was also a good area for investing. Right now I'm looking for an investment but I might move to Pittsburgh in a few years. My salary as an educator would be close to my current one but the cost of living would be so much lower and Pgh seems like a really cool city, with lots of mom and pop's businesses, close to nature, pretty working class and rich history. 

  • Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse a good book to get you started is Rich Dad Poor

    Dad. Great basics and an easy read

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2016 · 118 posts · 147 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse - First, congrats on managing yourself to a strong financial position. Second, I would suggest you look at Cleveland as well. At this price point you can get into Class B areas with strong yields.


    As I tell everyone starting with out of state investing your team on the ground is more important than the underwriting on a particular property. I'm happy to connect and help in any way I can (my company has 33 apartments in Cleveland currently).

  • Sunnyvale, CA · Member since 2018 · 191 posts · 178 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse too expensive. Not worth the cost. It’s a wonderful place but is it worth $2100 for a 700 sqft apartment in San Mateo? No way. My friend was paying $4000 for a luxury apartment + parking next to civic center in sf.

    But let me tell you a little about myself. I drive for Doordash. I make more money here than I do “back home”. But that’s my income source. Not much.. So I’m limited in what I can invest in. It pretty much leaves the bottom of the barrel. Which is good because I am a goof and if I gon’ goof up on a project, it’s going to be on a sub 50k property. Then eventually I want to move up to C class.

    Just the throw some numbers at you:

    “My” 400k Rental in Sac makes 1.5k/month in rents (1.8k market).

    Here, you could flat out buy a property for 250k in a A/B neighborhood and easily rent for 1.5k.

    Now, I’m trying to buy a house for somewhere around 25k. Fix up what I can (learn) myself. And rent it out for 1.5k in a D, borderline C neighborhood.

    You can get into C neighborhoods for a little more but I’m limited for now by my income. It’s not the glitz and glamor of bp re podcast but a lot of people around me are making good money doing similar things. There’s a lot of opportunities here but I still think it is early in the growth phase and things have a risk of still fizzling out. I think going forward we’re depending on people staying after graduating from CMU and more young people moving in like myself and possible yourself. Pollution is a slight political problem so we’ll see where that goes going forward. Overall can’t go wrong investing in pgh.

  • Property Management · Memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 668 posts · 362 votes
    6y

    @Terry Louwerse if your considering investing in Memphis, TN I would be happy to share my Memphis Area Investment Map that details areas by Class

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.