Rental Property Investor · Member since 2018 · 56 posts · 38 votes
I have a tenant that just signed their 1 year lease Sat. 4 days ago. Today they said they want out of their lease and will have everything removed from the home by this Saturday. They questioned having 3 business days after signing lease to not be liable for any of the lease. I have never heard of this or found anything online. I will call attorney in the morning but thought someone might know.....
If they signed the lease and gave you a deposit AND moved in, then they agreed to the lease. Had they changed their mind within a day or two of signing and not given you a deposit and not moved in, perhaps.
Tell them they are free to break the lease and you will find another tenant. Wait til they move out before doing the inspection and returning the deposit. Keep the rent until you find a new tenant. If you find a new tenant return the unused portion of the rent. I'd also charge them for advertizing if you incur costs.
First time I have heard of this. My lease (which has been reviewed by 3 lawyers) does not have any such clause. You might try reaching out to Brad Dornish’s group, they specialize in landlord tenant law. (No affiliation here, he speaks at ACRE monthly.)
I, too, have never heard of a 3 day contingency. There could be one, you'd just have to parse through the law to figure it out, but by and large, once the tenant signs the lease, they're liable to you for the entirety of the rent until the lease expires. That is unless you have in your lease a termination clause.
Of course, you being the lease holder, you can elect to tear the lease up, but in my preference that creates a bad precedent. The tenant signed a contract with you. And now they want to break the contract. There are consequences to breaking legally binding contracts and this should not be foregone. Who is to say that you're not the second, third, or fourth person this person has broken a contract with? How many more people will this person break contracts with?
If, after you speak with your attorney, he/she says that they cannot break the lease, I strongly recommend that you impose financial ramifications for their decision. I am hoping that you have a termination clause in you contract. If you don't, then make sure you update your lease to include one before signing on another tenant. My termination clauses generally impose a two month penalty. If the tenant is in month three of tenancy and they want to back out, that's fine with me, but they're required to pay two month's rent.
What you might also want to consider is why they're interested in backing out. Have you asked for the reason? Maybe they feel that the property has been misrepresented. Maybe they just found a different property that they like better. If the latter is the reason, you need to "educate" them (I dislike that term - "educate" - it sounds so pedantic) in how a contract works. You will be doing them a favor and you will be doing anyone they sign a contract with down the road a favor.
The way I see it with tenants and the contract is that if you don't hold up on your end, they're quick to call you out on it. Tenants are quick to become lawyers, citing law (they usually can't articulate any law in particular - just, "that's against the law") and telling you that they're taking you to court. A contract is a contract. Plain and simple. If you let this tenant back out without imposing the penalties outlined in the contract and those outlined in contract law, you open yourself to a discrimination suit down the road if you do hold someone else accountable. They'll look back and see that you didn't hold that person accountable, but you're holding me accountable.
And I will allude to a route I generally take when dealing with such instances: create a "bad guy." Make the contract the bad guy. Apologize, but remind them that they signed the contract and it is legally binding. Tell them that your attorney said you will be open to liability if you do not strictly adhere to the contract. (Make the attorney the bad guy.) This is assuming your attorney visit yields a result saying they can't back out, even this early on.
You can also go so far as to explain why you must be strict in these matters. You ceased searching for a new tenant once the lease was signed. You now have to start the process over. You are losing rent income because of them. This is called "consequential damages."
I wish you the best of luck. If you get a chance, let us know what the attorney said. I'm curious to know.
The 3 day clause came/comes from a salesman who enters your house to sell you something. The idea being if he won’t leave without you agreeing you can agree and back out once they’ve left your house. Assuming you didn’t go to their house this is not in effect.
I’d look up your lease’s early cancellation policy. I would assume you have this months rent and enough security deposit to cover next month. Tell them you’ll try your hardest to get it rented out by the end of next month so they won’t face additional charges assuming the place doesn’t need much make ready after 4 days.
If they signed the lease and gave you a deposit AND moved in, then they agreed to the lease. Had they changed their mind within a day or two of signing and not given you a deposit and not moved in, perhaps.
Tell them they are free to break the lease and you will find another tenant. Wait til they move out before doing the inspection and returning the deposit. Keep the rent until you find a new tenant. If you find a new tenant return the unused portion of the rent. I'd also charge them for advertizing if you incur costs.
@Theresa Harris I just wanted to second this post for what my firm has advocated in the past. I’ve definitely told clients to let people go and find a new tenant. It seems easier to find a happy tenant than to satisfy an idiosyncratic one. Good luck