Investor · Stamford, CT · Member since 2013 · 75 posts · 30 votes
Hi, I'd greatly appreciate any input on this deal. I'm fairly familiar with the terms I'd seek for a local (NYC suburb) single-family flip, but this 4-family has possibilities to flip or rent. The CAP and ROI seem attractive, but am I giving up too much in terms of the returns given my equity position??
4-family home.
Purchasable for $310K, significant refurb needed (say $135K).
Finance acquisition 70% through hard money loan, 30% through equity. **90% of the equity would be my contribution here.
End-game possibilities to (a) put on the market to sell after 4 months refurb – could be worth $575K ARV and if sold quickly yield me a 30%+ cash on cash return, or (b) if soft buyer's market then put out to rent, with projected 9% cap rate.
My main questions:
If I put in 90% of equity, what % of profits would be competitive? Maybe 50, 60 , 70%??
Have folks out there arranged an LLC structure where the small equity holder (the developer) makes a higher % if it's sold quickly but the large investor (me) makes more if it's rented out for years? Or does this complicate incentives
Do you know what the total rents would be on something like that?
As for % of equity, that's tough, though I'd think you should split it based on how much money the other person is putting in. If you put in 90% of the down payment, and they put 10% of it, you should get 90%, no? I dunno!
Finally - that's a HUGE rehab job. If you are off on your estimates, it could spell disaster! Just a word of caution!
Anyways, I'm curious about the rents, and what they would be running it through the 50% rule.
Hi Brandon, thanks for writing. There are good comps to indicate $6,600/mo rent potential, after repair work. Total monthly operating costs should be $2250.
In terms of the deal split, my partner would be the person who sourced the property opportunity and who will serve as general contractor. I'm solely an investor.
Q:So how might our roles affect the equity % returns? I've gleaned from BP forums deals ranging from 50/50 no preferred, to 8% preferred with 70/30 going to the investor. I've also read that general contracts might merit 20-40% markup over materials if bid out competitively.
Q2: Do you know of boilerplate/sample contracts between an investor and developer on rental properties? I'd like to compare those terms to the ones I see and potentially incorporate some of the safety features.
You've noted the key element of the deal. It's a good location and solid structure in a city with high demand, but the interiors were treated poorly pre-foreclosure so will need a major overhaul. At minimum, preferred equity returns may help buffer some downside.