Deal Analysis - Pre Construction Miami Beach

Deal Analysis - Pre Construction Miami Beach

Investor · Miami, FL · Member since 2023 · 120 posts · 46 votes

Hey guys,

I am trying to asses the deal of a condo in 72 Park Miami Beach

https://72parkmiamibeachcondo.com/

The apartment is 1 Bedroom + 1 Den + 1 Bathroom

755 Sq/f + 195 sq/f Balcony

14th Floor North facing

Price $1,150,000

The building is STR approved and these are the estimated income they sent me:

Daily Rate $530

80% Occupancy

$154,760 Yearly Rent

Management 20% - $30,952

HOA - $12,231

Property Tax - $20,826

Insurance - $1,087

Net Expenses: $34,144

Net profit $89,662 - %7.75

There isn't any other buildings like this in North Miami Beach that can really be compared to, I haven't found any data on AirDNA that can support such an income, and it seems like most new condos in the area are selling for $850 sq/f.

I am trying to understand if this is a good deal, if anyone can give me "insider" insight into the likelihood of achieving such a return and in general what you guys think of this deal

Thanks

0Reply
67 views

Most Popular Reply

Realtor · Miami, FL · Member since 2019 · 46 posts · 22 votes
3y
Quote from @Ray Hage:

It sounds good on paper.  However, the issue is they area really overbuilding condos all over Miami. Personally, I wouldn't want to take this kind of risk and feel like there is a potential condo crash coming. Over time, you would have to worry about things like assessments as well. You also have to trust management will do a good job. 

To me, 530/night sounds very steep and you can be sure it won't be anywhere near that high in the off season....it is quite a lot of variables. Do an airbnb search in that area for Jan/Feb/Mar timeframe and see what's out there as a double check


 Ray I'd like to provide a different perspective on your statement about overbuilding. We are no where near building the same amount of condos built in the last 2 market cycles. Look at the Miami Report by ISG World. No one is predicting a condo crash.

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    3y

    It sounds good on paper.  However, the issue is they area really overbuilding condos all over Miami. Personally, I wouldn't want to take this kind of risk and feel like there is a potential condo crash coming. Over time, you would have to worry about things like assessments as well. You also have to trust management will do a good job. 

    To me, 530/night sounds very steep and you can be sure it won't be anywhere near that high in the off season....it is quite a lot of variables. Do an airbnb search in that area for Jan/Feb/Mar timeframe and see what's out there as a double check

  • Investor · Miami, FL · Member since 2023 · 120 posts · 46 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Ray Hage:

    It sounds good on paper.  However, the issue is they area really overbuilding condos all over Miami. Personally, I wouldn't want to take this kind of risk and feel like there is a potential condo crash coming. Over time, you would have to worry about things like assessments as well. You also have to trust management will do a good job. 

    To me, 530/night sounds very steep and you can be sure it won't be anywhere near that high in the off season....it is quite a lot of variables. Do an airbnb search in that area for Jan/Feb/Mar timeframe and see what's out there as a double check

    It's to my understanding that there isn't a lot of where to build new condos when it comes to Miami Beach, especially North Miami Beach, and especially STR allowing buildings. 

    I also didn't see these sort of numbers on AirBNB, but the broker claims that there isn't anything like it in Miami Beach and it's like an alternative to a Hotel rather than an apartment due to all the amenities etc.

    Condo price crash in Miami Beach, is that really something that is being talked about?
  • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    3y

    There's not a lot of empty land in that specific area and also agree, there is not a lot of STR allowances. However check out Hilton Cabana Miami Beach nearby 72. I checked that price for Jan 13-20 and it's 276/night pre-tax and fees. Am I supposed to believe, people will pay double vs the Hilton? It seems unlikely to me.

    A condo price crash hasn't been talked about...To me, it just seems it's a possibility due to the overbuilding and exorbitant HOA fees (including high insurance) that will come with it. I am not an expert in condos by any means but I am cautious/conservative in investments.

  • Real Estate Agent · Miami, FL · Member since 2019 · 64 posts · 31 votes
    3y

    Hi Daniel,

    I am a realtor/investor in the Miami area. I specialize in new development, short term rentals and foreign investors. I also own a short term rental. I am familiar with the 72 Park development. Did you get those numbers from the developer or your agent? 

    If the developer gave you these numbers they are basically getting them from similar units in the area. I like to use the enemy method. Basically looking up other units near by on airbnb to see if it matches up. I do think the nightly rate is realistic. When there are big events prices can go as high as $1,000/night. Like any market there is a high season and low season. Data rabbu is a free website to look up seasonality. Airdna charges but has very accurate information. It is good to make that part of your due diligence. I recommend reaching out to your developer or agent, if you have one, with all of these question. If you need an agent with experience in this field I would be happy to speak with you.

  • Investor · Miami, FL · Member since 2023 · 120 posts · 46 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Lindsey Clark:

    Hi Daniel,

    I am a realtor/investor in the Miami area. I specialize in new development, short term rentals and foreign investors. I also own a short term rental. I am familiar with the 72 Park development. Did you get those numbers from the developer or your agent? 

    If the developer gave you these numbers they are basically getting them from similar units in the area. I like to use the enemy method. Basically looking up other units near by on airbnb to see if it matches up. I do think the nightly rate is realistic. When there are big events prices can go as high as $1,000/night. Like any market there is a high season and low season. Data rabbu is a free website to look up seasonality. Airdna charges but has very accurate information. It is good to make that part of your due diligence. I recommend reaching out to your developer or agent, if you have one, with all of these question. If you need an agent with experience in this field I would be happy to speak with you.


     Honestly, from the bit of due diligence I did do, I don't see how thats realistic for that part of Miami Beach. I couldn't find a single condo in the entire Miami Beach that averages these kind of numbers. Do you have some data to show me how you conclude that it's realistic?

    Thank you

  • Real Estate Agent · Miami, FL · Member since 2019 · 64 posts · 31 votes
    3y

    The average daily rate is realistic. I've done the enemy method for that area and prices range between $300-$1,000/night depending on the time of year. I don't think investors are seeing an occupancy rate of 80% though. If you purchased the airdna data you may want to look at Occupancy rate from 2020 or 2021 pre covid.

  • Realtor · Miami, FL · Member since 2019 · 46 posts · 22 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Lindsey Clark:

    Hi Daniel,

    I am a realtor/investor in the Miami area. I specialize in new development, short term rentals and foreign investors. I also own a short term rental. I am familiar with the 72 Park development. Did you get those numbers from the developer or your agent? 

    If the developer gave you these numbers they are basically getting them from similar units in the area. I like to use the enemy method. Basically looking up other units near by on airbnb to see if it matches up. I do think the nightly rate is realistic. When there are big events prices can go as high as $1,000/night. Like any market there is a high season and low season. Data rabbu is a free website to look up seasonality. Airdna charges but has very accurate information. It is good to make that part of your due diligence. I recommend reaching out to your developer or agent, if you have one, with all of these question. If you need an agent with experience in this field I would be happy to speak with you.


    In my experience working with the new dev sales agents they would never ever provide any STR data or forecasts. If they provide forecasts it could be considered an "investment" and not Real Estate. It would have to be a 3rd party like a property manager or a Realtor who is providing the data.

  • Realtor · Miami, FL · Member since 2019 · 46 posts · 22 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Ray Hage:

    It sounds good on paper.  However, the issue is they area really overbuilding condos all over Miami. Personally, I wouldn't want to take this kind of risk and feel like there is a potential condo crash coming. Over time, you would have to worry about things like assessments as well. You also have to trust management will do a good job. 

    To me, 530/night sounds very steep and you can be sure it won't be anywhere near that high in the off season....it is quite a lot of variables. Do an airbnb search in that area for Jan/Feb/Mar timeframe and see what's out there as a double check


     Ray I'd like to provide a different perspective on your statement about overbuilding. We are no where near building the same amount of condos built in the last 2 market cycles. Look at the Miami Report by ISG World. No one is predicting a condo crash.

  • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Joe Biscaha:
    Quote from @Ray Hage:

    It sounds good on paper.  However, the issue is they area really overbuilding condos all over Miami. Personally, I wouldn't want to take this kind of risk and feel like there is a potential condo crash coming. Over time, you would have to worry about things like assessments as well. You also have to trust management will do a good job. 

    To me, 530/night sounds very steep and you can be sure it won't be anywhere near that high in the off season....it is quite a lot of variables. Do an airbnb search in that area for Jan/Feb/Mar timeframe and see what's out there as a double check


     Ray I'd like to provide a different perspective on your statement about overbuilding. We are no where near building the same amount of condos built in the last 2 market cycles. Look at the Miami Report by ISG World. No one is predicting a condo crash.

    I appreciate the hard data. I assume these figures are continuing to expect big population growth within South FL. Personally, I still expect population growth as well but I think it will be far slower. Again, this is strictly a gut feeling, not any analysis. It feels like every time I am in Brickell, downtown or Wynwood, there's a new gigantic building going up....But based on that data you presented, I should do a little research
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.