I found what looked to be a decent property for a long term rental. After putting the information in the rent property calculator it seems to be quite the opposite. I'm not sure if this property just doesn't make sense to buy and own or if I'm being too conservative on my input values to the calculator.
Austin, sometimes the calculator is right and the deal is just thin, but a few inputs swing it a lot. The big ones are the financing terms (down payment, loan type, rate), the rent you're using, and what you're holding back for vacancy, repairs and capex. If you post the price, what similar places actually rent for, and what you plugged in for those, people here can tell you pretty quick if you're being too conservative.
On the financing side I'm happy to run a couple of scenarios with you, like conventional vs DSCR or a different down payment, so you can see if it works with real terms instead of guesses. Give me a call, my number's in my signature below.
Austin, if the calculator says it's bad, it's usually one of two things. Either the rent you're using is too high or the price is. Most people go too conservative on repairs and vacancy, but I'd rather see that than the opposite. Pull 3 actual rented comps nearby (not listings, what they really leased for) and rerun it with a flat 8 to 10% for vacancy. If it still doesn't cash flow at a price you'd pay, walk. Plenty of properties just don't pencil and that's fine.
Running the numbers before you make an offer is the right habit, and a calculator pushing back is it doing its job. One input that sinks a lot of rentals is property tax. People plug in the seller's current bill, but in many states the assessment resets after a sale, so yours can come in well above it. It also helps to run the calculator backwards, solving for the price that gets the cash flow you want, and see how far that sits from asking. Most DSCR lenders size the loan off gross rent against the payment, so a deal can pass their test and still lose money once your expenses are in. What state is it in? That decides how much the tax line moves.
Hi Austin, welcome, and you are doing the right thing by running the numbers before you fall in love with a property. A calculator that says no is not necessarily too conservative, it is usually pointing at one of the inputs.
I would check them one at a time: is the rent based on actual leased comps nearby rather than what similar listings are asking, are taxes and insurance from real quotes rather than the seller's numbers, and are vacancy, maintenance, and CapEx each their own line instead of one hopeful number? If the deal only works when you shave those reserves down, that is the calculator telling you the truth, not a flaw in the tool.
Keep practicing on listings in your market, and when one still pencils out with honest numbers, you will know you have found something worth pursuing.