Which would you choose: build or buy?

Which would you choose: build or buy?

Member since 2018 · 12 posts · 1 vote

Which would you choose in my position??

I am looking at investing in my second rental. My rental now is great, as it’s my downstairs that has its own entrance, more than pays my mortgage plus gives me several tax advantages and write offs.

I am considering either purchasing a SFR in my college town that has a strong economy OR building a garage with an apartment on my 15 acre property. I would be using one of the two garage stalls for myself. Not sure if that is a pro or con as far as taxes, etc. (I live in northern Minnesota). I would build this a short distance away from my house but still close enough to utilize the garage stall.

So far in my research I’ve determined that the cost would be approx 80k for this garage and apartment vs around 100k or more for a so-so house in town that would rent for the same amount.

I know I wouldn’t have trouble finding a tenant for either option.

What is the best option?

0Reply
39 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Shakopee, MN · Member since 2015 · 985 posts · 374 votes
7y

The one nice thing about building is you shouldn't have to worry about any major expenses for a while.

The downside would be you could see a big rise in your property taxes or possibly even see resistance from the city.  Some are pickier than others.  I'm not in Northern Minnesota, but it was a huge pain in the butt for my dad to get a garage built.  It took 6 months of going back and forth to meetings, revising, resubmitting paperwork.  He told me he would never do this again.  A plus would be they are close by if something happens.

SFR sounds like a good option too. My friends dad owned one near a big college and did really well with it. The nice part about that is it should be easy to sell. The downside is college kids can be reckless and irresponsible. In 10 years if you needed money for some reason and had to sell it probably would. Another Con would be it could possibly need some big repairs. Whereas the brand new one probably won't.

I have seen people do what you are doing and subdivide into another plot.

See this reply in the discussion

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Shakopee, MN · Member since 2015 · 985 posts · 374 votes
    7y

    The one nice thing about building is you shouldn't have to worry about any major expenses for a while.

    The downside would be you could see a big rise in your property taxes or possibly even see resistance from the city.  Some are pickier than others.  I'm not in Northern Minnesota, but it was a huge pain in the butt for my dad to get a garage built.  It took 6 months of going back and forth to meetings, revising, resubmitting paperwork.  He told me he would never do this again.  A plus would be they are close by if something happens.

    SFR sounds like a good option too. My friends dad owned one near a big college and did really well with it. The nice part about that is it should be easy to sell. The downside is college kids can be reckless and irresponsible. In 10 years if you needed money for some reason and had to sell it probably would. Another Con would be it could possibly need some big repairs. Whereas the brand new one probably won't.

    I have seen people do what you are doing and subdivide into another plot.

  • Tim SwierczekPro Member
    Lender · White Bear Township, MN · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    @Amy Kircher from what I'm understanding you would either buy an existing house for $100k or build a new large garage that you could live above or has living quarters in it.  If that is true I would think the better long term use for the capital is the existing house.  I say this because what you are proposing to build likely will not be worth what you need to put into it to build it, of course, I'm guessing here so you need to confirm the validity of that assumption.  In addition, odd properties have limited markets which will lead to generally less demand and also can great lending issues which effects a buyers ability to pay you upon sale, causing other issues.  


    If this type of structure is common in the area and easily financeable I would reconsider, but only if both of those things were true.

  • Member since 2018 · 12 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    Thank you both for the reply.  I think I have some more research to do such as getting a definite quote on what the garage with living quarters will cost and any tax ramifications etc.  Maybe the safest route would be to buy a house in town...

  • Contractor · Grand Marais, MN · Member since 2016 · 249 posts · 417 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Tim Swierczek:

    @Amy Kircher from what I'm understanding you would either buy an existing house for $100k or build a new large garage that you could live above or has living quarters in it.  If that is true I would think the better long term use for the capital is the existing house.  I say this because what you are proposing to build likely will not be worth what you need to put into it to build it, of course, I'm guessing here so you need to confirm the validity of that assumption.  In addition, odd properties have limited markets which will lead to generally less demand and also can great lending issues which effects a buyers ability to pay you upon sale, causing other issues.  


    If this type of structure is common in the area and easily financeable I would reconsider, but only if both of those things were true.

    Agree with everything Tim said. I would go with the house. 80 seems low for the garage, and will make selling your property more difficult, and it's money you likely will not recoup.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.