Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 172 posts · 58 votes
Does Zillow (or other listing sites for that matter) have fairly accurate estimates or should you only rely on getting appraisal or inspecting and comparing to comps?
@Ben Feder Look to a real estate agent to help you. Often the buyer agent fee is paid by the seller so it won’t be an added expense for you. This agent can help you compare properties and determine values.
Most important - don’t over-complicating the process. Studying the process too long will keep you from making deals and making deals is where the knowledge and experience comes from.
In my area, the sale value zestimate is heavily influenced by auction sales. These are typically much lower than mls sales and are a very significant amount of them. So the zestimate is way lower than what you can get for a fully rehabbed place. There just aren't many comps for fully rehabbed places because they almost always go as rentals to investors who don't buy or sell listed properties. The rent zestimate is better, but also tends to on the low side of what you can get if you do a place up nice.
Check the fine print with Zillow. It specifically states the estimate can be 20% + or - in either direction. It's a good place for consumers to start but it doesn't tell the whole story. I have to explain this all the time to clients on the retail side. Most are disappointed until you get one Zestimate that underestimates the homes value.
@Bob Prisco you said checking Zillow’s sold prop is more accurate. If I’m trying to see rental prices in the area, can I trust Zillow rentals for that?
My experience with the published rental rates are decent...mainly because the rates are based on data that is entered right on Zillow by landlords that are trying to rent their units....very common place to advertise units for rent, so the landlord puts up the ad and the rent..... the info isn't being pulled from 20 different sources and estimated.
But the best way to check rental rates is to visit all the sites you would visit if you were looking for a unit....pretend your are looking for a place to rent and start pulling up the rates for available units in the area. That will give you the best idea of the rent for the area
Don't rely on the Zillow "rent estimator" as much as the real ads for the area
@Timothy Boyd I use redfin for everything. I think they are the most accurate. Interesting to see how the different sites had various figures. I'm sure this is due to the algorithms. Congrats.