Can anyone recommend a good property manager in Cleveland?

Question

I own in CA and am looking at diversifying into Cleveland. Can anyone recommend a good property manager? Most of what I find online is people listing companies to avoid, not ones to work with.

Also, if anyone has advice on what areas have strong rental demand?

Thanks!

Nicholas L. · Answer

@Kendra Mattson

Hi Kendra. Are you able to go to Cleveland and meet a few in person? That's what I would do. Who are the other investors working with?

And, you mentioned you're diversifying - do you own rentals only locally, or out of state as well? Out of state is more challenging than as it's been presented. Given the current rate environment I believe the benefit of out of state has diminished, even for those in HCOL areas like CA.

Patrick Drury · Answer

@Kendra MattsonIf you are looking in the Cleveland, Oh market I would recommend being in areas on the West Side of Cleveland like West Blvd, Cudell, Old Brooklyn, Clark Fulton, Edgewater, Jefferson, and Brooklyn Centre. The reason is the rent-to-price ratio is good so you can cash flow, and most of the West side doesn’t have a Point of sale inspection which is really annoying.

Drew Sygit · Answer

Chat with @James Wise

Chaim Pfeiffer · Answer

Anyhow just stay really far from AES Property consultants if you hate loosing money

Jessica Larson · Answer

Property management is a tough business, so you won't find any company that is everyone’s favorite. There are some solid options in the area though, but you’ll definitely want to screen them carefully before moving forward. A great way to get a true picture is by asking for client references—this will give you insight into what working with them is really like.

Arman Ahmed · Answer

Finding a solid PM in Cleveland is huge, especially coming from out of state, and the best ones usually aren’t the loudest online, they come from referrals from active investors in the area. I’d focus less on just fees and more on how they handle tenant placement, maintenance markups, communication, and eviction processes, because that’s what really impacts your returns. For rental demand, a lot of investors see consistency in areas with stable working-class tenants and proximity to jobs, not just “nice” neighborhoods on paper. Cleveland can definitely work for cash flow, just make sure your team is dialed in first, since that’s what makes or breaks remote investing in Midwest markets.

Arman Ahmed · Answer

Finding a solid PM in Cleveland is huge, especially coming from out of state, and the best ones usually aren’t the loudest online, they come from referrals from active investors in the area. I’d focus less on just fees and more on how they handle tenant placement, maintenance markups, communication, and eviction processes, because that’s what really impacts your returns. For rental demand, a lot of investors see consistency in areas with stable working-class tenants and proximity to jobs, not just “nice” neighborhoods on paper. Cleveland can definitely work for cash flow, just make sure your team is dialed in first, since that’s what makes or breaks remote investing in Midwest markets.

Chaim Pfeiffer · Answer

I am really happy with Evernest, In general I saw bad reviews on them, but in Cleveland specifically I heard great things about them, I have 2 Duplexes with them and I am really happy.

Chaim Pfeiffer · Answer

Actually they had since my last post done a bad enough job that I had to leave them, 2 units were vacant for 6 months despite lowering asking rent to what they told me (after leaving them, and reaching out to a rental agent I got a tenant in a few weeks)
When I needed a things fixed, coordination was horrible, prices were crazy (much more than I pay now when reaching out myself to people) Because they get a extra 10% fee un top of that so they take the most expensive people
I would not recommend them.
I wasn't planning to self manage out of town but it ended up being very good the las t few months, I make more money, I have less issues and things are great.
I have a leasing agent for finding tenants, when something needs to be addressed my buyers brokers gives me good contacts with very good prices, Or I tell the tenant to call someone themselves since coordination works out best like that, they get me a few quotes, I make sure the price makes sense, I talk with the guy myself, I get before and after pictures, I even had the tenant pay them and I deducted it from the rent.
I don't know if this will work forever, I now have just 4 units, But it is working now.

Samuel Reznikoff · Answer

@Chaim Pfeiffer hey can you tell me about your expierence with them? Had any turnovers rehabs or evictions with them? I'm looking for a pm right now

Can anyone recommend a good property manager in Cleveland?

Can anyone recommend a good property manager in Cleveland?

Most Popular Reply

16 Replies