Insurance, Liability & Risk

Insurance, Liability & Risk

Member since 2026 · 77 posts · 26 votes

Happy Thursday everyone. Three more observations from the self-managing side of rental property.
 

Three Landlord Tips

1. Homeowners insurance may not provide adequate coverage for a rental property.
Once a property becomes a rental, your coverage needs may change significantly. Some policies limit or exclude rental activity. Know what your policy actually covers before you need it.
2. A pet agreement is not the same as a pet policy.
A verbal understanding is difficult to enforce. A written pet agreement documents the approved animal and the tenant’s responsibilities. If it matters, put it in writing.
3. Wear and tear is not the same as damage.
Normal aging — scuffed floors, faded paint, small nail holes — is a cost of ownership. Actual damage — carpet burns, broken fixtures, holes in walls — is the tenant’s responsibility. Misclassifying one for the other is one of the most common reasons landlords lose deposit disputes.

 Two Things To Think About
• The cheapest landlord mistake to prevent is often the most expensive one to fix later.
• Documentation is not paperwork. It is protection.

 One Question
What is one insurance or legal mistake you see new landlords make repeatedly?
Looking forward to hearing your answers.

1Reply
717 views

Most Popular Reply

Drew SygitBusiness Member
Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
2mo

Many insurance companies that primarily focus on owner-occupied policies, that also offer landlord policies, have a sneaky clause in their policies that allow them to deny claims after a rental has been vacant for more than 30-days.

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2mo
    Quote from @Kim Gray:

    Happy Thursday everyone. Three more observations from the self-managing side of rental property.
     

    Three Landlord Tips

    1. Homeowners insurance may not provide adequate coverage for a rental property.
    Once a property becomes a rental, your coverage needs may change significantly. Some policies limit or exclude rental activity. Know what your policy actually covers before you need it.
    2. A pet agreement is not the same as a pet policy.
    A verbal understanding is difficult to enforce. A written pet agreement documents the approved animal and the tenant’s responsibilities. If it matters, put it in writing.
    3. Wear and tear is not the same as damage.
    Normal aging — scuffed floors, faded paint, small nail holes — is a cost of ownership. Actual damage — carpet burns, broken fixtures, holes in walls — is the tenant’s responsibility. Misclassifying one for the other is one of the most common reasons landlords lose deposit disputes.

     Two Things To Think About
    • The cheapest landlord mistake to prevent is often the most expensive one to fix later.
    • Documentation is not paperwork. It is protection.

     One Question
    What is one insurance or legal mistake you see new landlords make repeatedly?
    Looking forward to hearing your answers.

    Great points, Kim. One mistake I see newer landlords make is assuming a standard lease template covers everything they need without checking their state and local requirements. Security deposits, required notices, late fees, entry rules, and lease language can all have specific requirements. I’d also add move-in and move-out documentation to your point about wear and tear. Good photos, videos, and a signed condition report can make a huge difference if there’s ever a disagreement about a deposit.

  • Real Estate Agent · Memphis · Member since 2026 · 632 posts · 363 votes
    2mo

    One that comes to mind is using a generic lease and assuming you're covered because everyone signed it. If the lease doesn't match the property, local requirements, and how you actually manage things like maintenance, pets, utilities, or access, those gaps tend to show up at the worst possible time. That's one area where I'd much rather get the language right upfront than find out during a dispute that the lease doesn't say what I thought it did.

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2mo

    Owners that fail to properly mesh their HO6 deductibles and coverage with the COA/HOA Master Policy. You need to get an updated "insurance summary" from your COA/HOA management each year to compare and review your needs WITH your insurance agent.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    2mo

    Many insurance companies that primarily focus on owner-occupied policies, that also offer landlord policies, have a sneaky clause in their policies that allow them to deny claims after a rental has been vacant for more than 30-days.

  • Stuart UdisPro Member
    Attorney · Philadelphia · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2mo

    I've posted this before but there should be studies performed on tenant responses to security deposit withholdings. The irrational response and the time that is then committed to defending the deductions when calculated on an hourly basis is rarely worth the time and expense.

    Having the correct insurance is important but equally as important and where most fail is in ensuring those connected to their business whether it be tenants, vendors, contractors, PM's etc. maintain appropriate insurance AND equally important there are contractual provisions and appropriate additional insured endorsements that allow those policies to supersede your own when a liability event occurs. It's the biggest miss I repeatedly see. 

    Great recent example: Someone is building a ground up duplex, hires a GC to pull the permit and oversee the construction. The subcontractor framer leaves a mess, bank draw inspector trips and breaks ankle and files lawsuit against property owner and contractor. Property owner is listed as additional insured under the contractors GL policy with indemnification, Per contract between property owner and GC, GC is required to have framing subcontractor list Owner as additional insured under their GL policy. Contractor and framing insurance carriers cover litigation expenses, owner pays $500 towards settlement and no loss run record on their policy.  This outcome is less about the insurance and more about the contractual obligations.

  • Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 19 posts · 6 votes
    2mo

    Great points, especially that documentation is protection - not just paperwork.

    One mistake I see smaller landlords make is assuming that strong tenant screening eliminates the risk of missed rent or property damage. Screening is important, but it only reflects what is known at the time. A renter’s circumstances can change after the lease is signed.

    The strongest approach is usually layered: clear and consistently applied screening criteria, the right property and liability coverage, a well-written lease, thorough move-in documentation, adequate reserves, and a plan for how to respond when payments fall behind.

    I’d also add that landlords should understand exactly what each form of protection does and does not cover. Gaps often aren’t discovered until something has already gone wrong.

  • Coral Springs, FL · Member since 2018 · 498 posts · 119 votes
    1mo

    the biggest one for me was not requiring renters insurance from day one. i used to think my landlord policy would cover everything but it only covers the building, not the tenant's stuff. when a pipe burst and ruined a tenant's furniture, they expected me to pay for it. now every lease requires renters insurance and i ask for the declarations page before move-in. costs them like $15/month and saves you from a conversation you don't want to have.

    also an umbrella policy is way cheaper than people think. i was paying an extra $200/year for $1M in additional coverage on top of my landlord policy. for a self-managing landlord that peace of mind is worth it.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.