Hello @Nick Virovec,
In my opinion, none of the online sites (Rentometer, Zillow, Redfin, etc.) are accurate enough for evaluating specific properties. In this post, I will explain why and how to obtain the required accuracy.
How Online Sites Estimate Rent
Online sites calculate the average rent per square foot for an area. When you enter the address of a property, the site estimates the rent by multiplying the average area $/SF by the subject property's square footage. For example, if the average $/SF for 3-bedroom homes in an area is $1.10/SF, and the subject property has an area of 1,500 SF, then the estimated rent would be:
- 1,500 SF x $1.10/SF = $1,650/Mo
The problem is these sites do not consider a property's specifics.
Property Specific Examples
Proximity to nuisances - Property A, located next to Interstate 15, will have a lower rental price than Property B, even if the physical attributes of the properties are the same. This is because of the noise generated by I15.

Property condition - Would you expect this property to rent for the same amount as a similar property in good condition?

Age - These two properties have similar sizes and the same number of beds and baths. Would you expect them to have the same rent?

I could continue, but I believe you see some problems with online sites for estimating rent.
Rentometer vs. Actual
I decided to use Rentometer for the following comparisons. Any online site could be used, and the results would be about the same.
I looked up four recently rented properties on the MLS and compared the median Rentometer prediction to the actual rent. As you can see below, the information provided by Rentometer is nowhere near the actual rent.

Next, I used Rentometer to estimate the rent for another property. Rentometer provided a rent range of $1,852 to $2,258, a range of $406.

I then compared the return for this property based on the low, median, and high Rentometer projections. See below.

So, depending on which Rentometer rent estimate you choose, you will either lose $94/Mo or make $312/Mo. Would you be willing to purchase a property with this quality of information? I would not.
What is the best source of property-specific rental rates? Property managers.
How Property Managers Estimate Rent
Property managers largely base rent estimates on current competition. For example, suppose recently rented similar properties went for $2,300/Mo. But, when your property goes on the market, similar properties are available for $1,950/Mo to $2,000/Mo. It's likely your property will rent for around $2,000/Mo, not $2,300/Mo. Rental history is not that relevant when it comes to actual rental rates. Online tools only use past rental data for making rental estimates.
Important considerations:
- The current competition is what determines the monthly rent, not prior rentals.
- Your competition is not necessarily the property down the street. It could also be a property across town, as illustrated below. Prospective tenants who work in the "main job area" consider all properties in acceptable areas with similar commute times.
- Property specifics matter. For example, what if you paint the interior dark green, which is unacceptable to the tenant segment normally attracted to your property? You could only rent it if you decreased it well below market.
Summary
No online site I have seen provides property-specific rental rates accurate enough for making investment decisions. The most dependable source for accurate rent information is an experienced property manager.
We have delivered 490+ properties and never selected one without first obtaining the rent estimate from a reliable property manager.
Nick, I hope this helps. Reach out if I can help, or you can find more investing insights, methodology, and processes in my (free) weekly blog: ericfernwood.substack.com
...Eric