I’ve worked with several out-of-state investors purchasing rental properties in Oklahoma, and while the cash-flow numbers look great on paper, there are a few recurring mistakes I see:
1. Underestimating rehab costs
Oklahoma homes (especially older inventory) often need plumbing updates, foundation work, or HVAC replacements. Rehab budgets here can surprise investors who are used to newer markets.
2. Not fully understanding property taxes
Taxes can vary significantly by county and assessed value adjustments after purchase. What shows on Zillow isn’t always what you’ll pay post-sale.
3. Hiring the cheapest contractor
Low bids often turn into change orders, delays, or incomplete work. A reliable, licensed team is worth the investment.
4. Overestimating rent based on list prices
Just because a home is listed at a certain price doesn’t mean that’s what it’s leasing for. True rental comps matter.
5. Trying to self-manage from out of state
It sounds good in theory, until you’re coordinating HVAC repairs at 10 PM from another time zone.
Oklahoma is still a strong cash-flow market if you buy right and build the right team.
For those investing remotely, what lessons did you learn the hard way?
@Rosa Watson I agree with your post on the points as they are very valid reasons why some people do not do as well in real estate investing, especially if they are out of state.
1 & 3. This is common, as the price for things are increasing like labor, materials, then not as many qualified people doing these trades (then a lot of those quality people are getting taken or scared of ICE). Older homes do need more work. One can reduce this by having others on their team that are either investors themselves (that can better estimate repairs based on the intent of the future owner), have construction experience or rely on having actual contractors come out to get legit bids on priority work Vs pre-offer & during inspection periods.
2, 4 & 5. Many investors need to properly ensure deal analysis is being done, factoring in rental comps for the area, know your target market, the estimate of the increase in taxes, insurance, maintenance and CAPEX, etc. One should backwards plan as much as possible, synchronize work to quickly get the work done on time to reduce holding costs, then always ensure you follow good principles on making a good deal. ARV x profit (you want to make) - Repairs (scope of work to get to ARV) = Max Allowable Offer (MAO)
Ensuring hiring a great leasing agent that has good leasing experience and does a thorough screening process is always worth the money vs going with the cheaper option. Great screening & standards = great tenants.
Self managing out of state is very hard and I agree with your points. One should screen & consider multiple property managers in their search to build a team. Most of the time, one still does need to manage the manager as most property management companies stay in business with the more they manage. Finding out one's level of involvement and experience in the industry, seeing how many properties they manage, what systems they have in place for common operations, there individual leasing & marketing plans are, how often inspections are, and pricing can all help with determining the quality of a PM.
@Rosa Watson I agree with your post on the points as they are very valid reasons why some people do not do as well in real estate investing, especially if they are out of state.
1 & 3. This is common, as the price for things are increasing like labor, materials, then not as many qualified people doing these trades (then a lot of those quality people are getting taken or scared of ICE). Older homes do need more work. One can reduce this by having others on their team that are either investors themselves (that can better estimate repairs based on the intent of the future owner), have construction experience or rely on having actual contractors come out to get legit bids on priority work Vs pre-offer & during inspection periods.
2, 4 & 5. Many investors need to properly ensure deal analysis is being done, factoring in rental comps for the area, know your target market, the estimate of the increase in taxes, insurance, maintenance and CAPEX, etc. One should backwards plan as much as possible, synchronize work to quickly get the work done on time to reduce holding costs, then always ensure you follow good principles on making a good deal. ARV x profit (you want to make) - Repairs (scope of work to get to ARV) = Max Allowable Offer (MAO)
Ensuring hiring a great leasing agent that has good leasing experience and does a thorough screening process is always worth the money vs going with the cheaper option. Great screening & standards = great tenants.
Self managing out of state is very hard and I agree with your points. One should screen & consider multiple property managers in their search to build a team. Most of the time, one still does need to manage the manager as most property management companies stay in business with the more they manage. Finding out one's level of involvement and experience in the industry, seeing how many properties they manage, what systems they have in place for common operations, there individual leasing & marketing plans are, how often inspections are, and pricing can all help with determining the quality of a PM.
True for all DIY investors, even when they are managing locally!
I'm currently buying 2 rental properties in OKC. I bought my first in 2025. It's been all turn key but I'd like to step it up and do the leg work myself. I'm out of state, Cali. I'm building relations with GC, lender and agent. Nothing final but I'm working on it.