The most expensive underwriting mistake in Detroit

The most expensive underwriting mistake in Detroit

Member since 2026 · 16 posts · 9 votes

The most expensive underwriting mistake in Detroit is using the seller's tax bill.

Proposal A caps annual taxable value growth at inflation or 5%, whichever is lower. For 2026 the State Tax Commission set it at 2.7%. Hold fifteen years and taxable value drifts far below what the place is worth.

Then it sells. Taxable value uncaps and is set equal to assessed value. The trap is timing: that happens the year after the transfer. 

Buy in 2026 and your first bill still looks fine. The real one lands in 2027.

That means the average Detroit home would see taxes rise about $1,403 if sold today.

After removing outliers, 1,208 homes would jump over $10,000.

Buying as a rental? Add the loss of the Principal Residence Exemption, up to 18 more mills.

Also, use the Assessor's Estimated Property Tax tool, not the current bill.

P.S. NEZ (Neighborhood Enterprise Zone) Properties get a seperate discount so this math doesn't apply.. feel free to comment/DM if you have a specific parcel that you're curious about.

1Reply
253 views

1 Reply

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2026 · 31 posts · 9 votes
    1mo

    The year-after timing is what makes this such a good trap. You get one clean bill that confirms your model right before the real one shows up.

    Worth flagging for the tax sale side specifically, since that's this forum: winning at auction is still a transfer, so the uncap applies there too. Someone bidding a Wayne County parcel off the current taxable value is underwriting a number that's about to be replaced, and if the plan is buy and hold as a rental, they eat the uncap and lose the PRE in the same year.

    Does the $1,403 average include the PRE loss, or is that the uncap alone?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.