The Tables Have Turned – Why Ohio Is Winning and What That Means for Wholesalers

The Tables Have Turned – Why Ohio Is Winning and What That Means for Wholesalers

Virtual Assistant · Toledo, OH · Member since 2026 · 84 posts · 36 votes

I've been watching the 2026 housing data closely, and the shift is becoming impossible to ignore. Fortune recently reported that Florida and Texas are now the biggest losers in the housing market, while Ohio has quietly emerged as the surprise winner.

Here's what the numbers are saying:

· Columbus home prices are up more than 7% year over year, with a median sale price of $301,000.

· Toledo was ranked the fourth-hottest housing market in the country by Realtor.com for 2026, with projected price growth of 13.1%.

· Meanwhile, the Q2 2026 Fix-and-Flip Index fell to its second consecutive quarterly decline – but flippers in the Midwest and Northern California are still selling above ARV.

What this means for wholesalers:

· More buyer interest in the Midwest – As investors pivot away from saturated Sunbelt markets, Ohio is positioned to absorb that capital.

· Motivated sellers are becoming more accessible – With inventory rising across Ohio and days on market stretching, sellers are more open to cash offers.

· Off-market deals are still the best opportunities – The best deals never hit Zillow. Direct mail, skip tracing, and relationships are still how you find motivated sellers.

I've been tracking tax-delinquent lists and skip-tracing owners in Cleveland, Columbus, and Toledo, and the conversations are noticeably different now compared to six months ago. More owners are picking up the phone.

For those actively sourcing in the Midwest – are you seeing the same shift? Are sellers becoming easier to engage, or is the softening market making them more hesitant? And for those still in Sunbelt markets – are you feeling the strain, or is there still opportunity?

Curious to hear what others are seeing on the ground.

1Reply
436 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Virtual Assistant · Egypt · Member since 2026 · 51 posts · 15 votes
    1mo

    This tracks with something I've seen too when a market shifts and sellers feel more pressure (rising inventory, longer DOM), pickup rates and receptiveness on calls genuinely change, even with the same list quality. It's a good reminder that outreach performance isn't just about your list or script; sometimes it's just the market doing some of the work for you. Are you seeing the actual conversations get easier, or just more owners answering the phone? They're different things.

  • Englewood, NJ · Member since 2018 · 356 posts · 60 votes
    2w

    Treasure, you're already doing the hardest part — tracking tax-delinquent lists in Cleveland, Columbus, and Toledo. The question is what happens after you skip-trace the owner. There's a path that skips the cold call entirely and goes straight to the auction.

    Both Cuyahoga County (Cleveland) and Lucas County (Toledo) run tax foreclosure sales. The county has already done what you're doing now — identified delinquent properties, sent legal notices for 1-3+ years, and set an auction date. The difference between where you are (skip tracing + calling) and the auction model is: instead of convincing one owner to sell, you're connecting cash buyers with properties the county has already legally processed for sale.

    Here's how it works in Ohio specifically:

    Cuyahoga County runs sheriff sales through the Court of Common Pleas. Properties are published in advance on the county website. You can cross-reference the sheriff sale list with the county auditor's values (free at fiscalohio.gov or the Cuyahoga County Auditor site) to calculate spreads between the tax debt / minimum bid and market value. Toledo's 13.1% projected price growth from your Realtor.com data means properties selling at tax foreclosure in Lucas County could have significant equity gaps — the kind of spread cash buyers look for.

    Franklin County (Columbus) also publishes tax lien sale lists. With Columbus median prices at $301K and up 7% YoY, the appreciation is building equity on one side while tax delinquency creates forced-sale pricing on the other.

    Lucas asked whether conversations are getting easier or just more owners are answering. Tax deed flips that question: you're not calling owners at all. The county already identified them, notified them, and set the auction date. Your job shifts from skip-tracing and cold calling to researching spreads and connecting cash buyers who want to bid.

    Your VA operation in Toledo is perfectly positioned for this — you already know the tax-delinquent neighborhoods, you already understand the data, and you already have the research workflow. The difference is the exit: instead of wholesaling a contract to an end buyer, you're connecting cash buyers directly with county auction properties where the motivation is as real as it gets (they're about to lose the property to tax sale).

    Have you looked at the Cuyahoga County sheriff sale calendar or the Lucas County auditor's tax foreclosure list yet? Curious whether the auction angle is something you've considered alongside the traditional skip-trace-and-call approach.

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 30k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    1w

    Wholesaling is still a thing? Naaaaa

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.